Constitution & Polity of India

A top-down code

Context: The central government has codified 29 labour laws into 4 labour codes but, labour legislation is under the concurrent list so the responsibility of framing the rules related to these codes lies with states but they have not framed the rules yet which is defeating the very purpose of these codes.

Labour Code (Wage Code) – 2019

  • After 73 years of independence, work is being done to provide wage security, social security and health security to 50 crore workers, covering organized and unorganized sectors.
  • The guarantee of minimum wages is available to 50 crore workers in organized and unorganized sectors.
  • Review of minimum wages every 5 years.
  • Guarantee of timely payment of wages to all workers
  • Equal remuneration to male and female workers.
  • For the first time, around 40 crore workers of the unorganized sector in the country have got this right.
  • To remove regional disparity in minimum wages the provision of floor wage has been introduced.
  • The determination of minimum wages has been made easy. It will be based on criteria such as skill level and geographical area.
  • From 28.08.2017 Payment of Wages Act has increased the wage ceiling from Rs. 18000 to Rs. 24000.

Social security code 2020

  • Through a small contribution, the benefit of free treatment is available under hospitals and dispensaries of ESIC.
  • The doors of ESIC will now be opened for the workers of all sectors and the unorganised sector workers.
  • Expansion of ESIC hospitals, dispensaries and branches up to the district level.
  • This facility is to be increased from 566 districts to all 740 districts of the country.
  • Even if a single worker is engaged in hazardous work, he would be given ESIC benefit.
  • Opportunity to join ESIC for platform and gig workers engaged in new technology.
  • Plantation workers get the benefit of ESIC.
  • Institutions working in hazardous areas are to be compulsorily registered with ESIC.

Expansion of Social Security

  • The benefit of a pension scheme (EPFO) to all workers of organized, unorganized and self-employed sectors.
  • Creation of social security fund for providing comprehensive social security to the unorganized sector.
  • The requirement of minimum service has been removed for payment of gratuity in the case of fixed-term employees.
  • Employees engaged on fixed terms get the same social security benefit as permanent employees.
  • Creating a national database of workers of the unorganized sector through registration on Portal.
  • Employers employing more than 20 workers to mandatorily report vacancies online.
  • A Universal Account Number (UAN) for ESIC, EPFO and Unorganised Sector workers.
  • Aadhaar-based Universal Account Number (UAN) to ensure seamless portability.

OSH Code (Occupational, Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code) - 2020

  • Various provisions in the OSH Code will ease the lives of the Inter-State Migrant Workers.
  •  Anomalies of the Inter-State Migrant Workers Act, of 1979 have been comprehensively addressed in the OSH Code. Earlier only workers appointed by a contractor were recognized as Inter-State Migrant Workers. However, under the new provisions of the Code, workers can be Aatmanirbhar as they can now register themselves as Inter-State Migrant Workers on the national portal. By this provision, the worker would get a legal identity which would enable them to get the benefits of all social security schemes.
  • A provision has been made for employers to provide a travelling allowance annually to an Inter-State Migrant Worker for undertaking a to-and-fro journey to his native place.
  • Providing of appointment letters to the workers has been made mandatory.
  • Mandatory, free annual health check-ups of the workers to be provided by the employers.
  • For a worker engaged in building and other construction work in one State and moving to another State, benefit from the Building and Other Construction Workers’ Cess fund will be provided.
  • Under the “One Nation - One Ration Card”, an Inter-State Migrant Worker would get a ration facility in the State he is working in and the remaining members of his family would be able to avail of the ration facility in the State where they reside.
  • Mandatory helpline facility in every State for the resolution of Inter-State Migrant Workers’ grievances.
  • A national database is to be created for the Inter-State Migrant Workers.
  • Instead of 240 days, now if a worker has worked 180 days, he shall be entitled to one-day leave for every 20 days of work done.
  • Women’s Empowerment through the Labour Codes
  • Right to women workers to work in all types of establishments.
  • Women have been given the right to work at night with their consent and it has also been ensured that the employer would make adequate arrangements to provide safety and facilities to women workers at night.
  • The Maternity Benefit Act was amended in 2017 to increase the paid Maternity leave for women workers from 12 to 26 weeks and ensure mandatory crèche facility in all establishments having 50 or more workers.

Industrial Relations (IR) Code, 2020

  • In case of job loss, a worker will get benefits under the Atal Bimit Vyakti Kalyan Yojna.
  • Under the Atal Bimit Vyakti Kalyan Yojna, a worker of the organized sector who loses his job gets financial aid from the Government. This is a type of unemployment allowance, the benefit of which is admissible to the workers covered under the ESI Scheme.
  •  At the time of retrenchment, a worker would Chapter 8 New Labour Code For New India 20 be provided 15 days’ wages for re-skilling. The wages would be credited directly into the bank account of the worker so as to enable him to learn new skills.
  • Faster justice for the workers through the Tribunal.
  • Workers’ disputes are to be resolved within a year in the Tribunal.
  • Industrial Tribunals to have 2 members to facilitate faster disposal of cases.
  • In industrial establishments, a Trade Union having 51 per cent votes shall be recognised as the sole negotiating union which can make agreements with employers.
  • In industrial establishments in which no trade union gets 51 per cent votes, a negotiating council of trade unions shall be constituted for making agreements with employer.

National Commission for Schedule Caste

Context: The National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) on Friday issued a notice to Punjab government officials, seeking an action taken report on the alleged sexual misconduct by Lal Chand Kataruchak, a Minister in the ruling Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government.

The National Commission for Scheduled Castes is an Indian constitutional body established with a view to provide safeguards against the exploitation of Scheduled Castes and Anglo Indian communities to promote and protect their social, educational, economic and cultural interests, special provisions were made in the Constitution. Article 338 of the Indian constitution deals with National Commission for Scheduled Castes.

Institutions are often distinguished by whether they perform a protective or a promotional role. The NCSC is clearly more of a protective institution, though it does monitor the progress of promotional policy initiatives emanating from other state agencies. While its creation was mandated by the Constitution, neither the responsibility of promoting the welfare of the scheduled castes nor that of protecting them against injustices has been vested exclusively in this institution. Indeed, though it enjoys constitutional status, the recommendations of the Commission are advisory rather than mandatory.

General Studies- II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International relations.

  • General Studies- II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International relations.

Mains: 

  • 2020. Which steps are required for constitutionalization of a commission? Do you think imparting constitutionality to the National Commission for Women would ensure greater gender justice and empowerment in India? Give reasons.
  • 2018. Whether National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) can enforce the implementation of constitutional reservation for the Schedules Castes in the religious minority institutions? Examine.

So we can see that coverage of constitutional bodies is important. From the perspevtive of Mains as well as Prelims. So in this discussion we are going to cover the following: 

  • Main functions of the NCSC
  • Evaluation of the performance of the comssission:
  • Way forward

The National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) is an Indian constitutional body established under Article 338 of the Constitution of India. It was set up in 2004 to investigate and monitor all matters relating to the constitutional safeguards provided for the Scheduled Castes (SCs) and to protect their rights.

The main functions of the NCSC

  1. To investigate and monitor all matters relating to the safeguards provided for the Scheduled Castes under the Constitution or under any other law for the time being in force.
  2. To inquire into specific complaints with respect to the deprivation of rights and safeguards of the Scheduled Castes.
  3. To participate and advise in the planning process of socio-economic development of the Scheduled Castes.
  4. To evaluate the progress of the development of the Scheduled Castes under the Union and any State.
  5. To make recommendations for the effective implementation of safeguards for the Scheduled Castes.

Four areas of functioning:

Of the four core areas of the Commission’s functioning – viz., service safeguards, education, economic development and atrocities – the Services Safeguards Wing is the most active. These complaints relate mostly to promotions, discrimination and harassment on various counts, institution of disciplinary proceedings on flimsy grounds, the conduct of departmental enquires in an unfair manner, adverse entry in the annual confidential reports, transfers to far off places or insignificant positions, delay in payment of retirement benefits, delay in the completion of departmental inquires, and so forth. It has also succeeded in institutionalizing the system of liaison officers and special SC and ST cells in all central ministries and public sector enterprises for the speedy and effective resolution of the grievances of employees of these communities.

The NCSC also has the power of a civil court and can summon witnesses, record evidence, and issue orders. It submits annual reports to the President and the Parliament on its performance and recommendations.

The NCSC plays an important role in protecting the rights and interests of the Scheduled Castes, which are one of the most vulnerable and marginalized sections of the Indian society. It ensures that the constitutional safeguards provided for them are effectively implemented and any violations are addressed promptly.

Evaluation of the performance of the commission:

  • There are a variety of conflicts that characterise the functioning of the Commission. Firstly, there has historically prevailed a conflict between the Commission and its nodal ministry, the Ministry of Social Welfare (now the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment), which has often taken the form of conflict between the Minister and the Chairman of the NCSCST. Conflict between the Chairperson and members has also tended to characterise the Commission, because of the politicised nature of appointments to it. 
  • By choosing to interpret its constitutional mandate narrowly, the Commission has laid itself open to the charge of elite bias. The fact that it is most effective in the area of servicerelated safeguards speaks for itself.
  • The Commission’s competence in settling service-related grievances may be contrasted with its inability to reduce the incidence of atrocities and violence against dalits, or to effectively fight the persistent scourge of untouchability.
  • A particular Commission seems to be only as good as its members, and especially its Chairperson, are. The lack of institutionalisation in the procedures of appointment to the Commission has meant that competent and committed members are less likely to be appointed, especially in a political and policy environment where membership of the Commission becomes a convenient sinecure for unemployable politicians or a temporary shelf for bureaucrats belonging to these groups.
  • The most significant handicap of the Commission is the fact that its decisions are not binding, but recommendatory. Though this is not explicitly stated in the Constitution (as amended), Article 338, with all its sub-clauses, is deeply ambiguous on this issue. It gives the Commission quasi-judicial powers of investigation, but does not mention the form in which the Commission’s judgement of a particular issue would be delivered and implemented.
  • The quality of reports in terms of the data they contain, and the manner in which the data is organized, has also been declining over the years.
  • The Commission is supposed to prepare an Annual Report for presentation to Parliament. Reports are often tabled two or more years after they have been submitted to the President.
  • Even when Reports are tabled in Parliament, they are frequently not discussed. There is no evidence in the Lok Sabha debates of a discussion on any of the first four reports. Of the four Special Reports, only one has an all-India scope and this is about service safeguards.

Way Forward: 

It is often argued that the Commission is a paper tiger which needs to be armed with greater powers. This argument is premised on an inadequate appreciation of the location of the Commission in the existing constitutional setup. To give the Commission additional powers, in the matter of criminal investigation for instance, would require it to follow prevailing rules and procedures pertaining to evidence and prosecution. These may in fact retard the effectiveness of the Commission by rendering it vulnerable to litigation in the form of appeals to higher judicial bodies, and thereby nullifying its

operational effectiveness, and diluting its moral stature.

  • An amendment is required either in Article 338 itself, or in the rules by which the President may fix a period for the discussion of the Report in Parliament.
  • It would be appropriate for the Commission to undertake qualitative studies, commission social anthropologists and other social scientists to undertake such studies, and to institutionalize mechanisms by which contemporary changes and transitions in the social structure can be mirrored, recorded and acted upon.
  • The process of appointment to the Commission should be made more autonomous of the government of the day. 

It would be desirable for the Commission to engage in an internal evaluation of its priorities on an ongoing basis, and to redefine them in a substantively more egalitarian way so as to accomplish its mandate in the spirit in which it was intended.

Do CCTV cameras protect us or invade our privacy?

Context: India’s CCTV camera coverage has grown rapidly over the years. Today, Delhi and Chennai have more cameras per square mile than cities in China. States argue that CCTV cameras reduce crime, and the public finds the presence of these cameras reassuring. However, surveillance is a big concern. Recently, in Telangana, the wrong man was apprehended when authorities purportedly recognised him from security camera footage as a potential culprit in a chain-snatching event. He died days after being released.

Arguments in Favour of the installation of CCTV cameras

  • Cameras can help the police identify suspects
  • It can help in gathering evidences and clues of crime
  • They may help in bringing convenience for everyday life.
  • Cameras can help in reducing crime against women

Arguments against CCTV cameras

  • There are multiple studies in the U.K. that show that there is no connection between CCTV cameras and the reduction of crime.
  • Many times, cameras don’t even function, a CAG audit of 2018-19 stated that only 55-68% of cameras were working in Delhi
  • The majority of crimes against women take place at home. CCTV cameras are not helpful in those situations.
  • It is impossible to install CCTV in all places.
  • Over-reliance on these systems, which leads to false negatives (the police have not been able to identify the criminal and he goes free) and false positives (an innocent person is identified as the suspect).
  • Police may use the footage for otherwise
  • There is no oversight of the actions of the police, for instance, the New York and London police departments have oversight committees.
  •  According to the Criminal Procedure (Identification) Act, fingerprints, handprints or any evidence can be kept for 75 years. Why 75 years? There is no explanation. So, even after someone dies, evidence such as your fingerprints could be on record.
  • There are barriers to how freely people can protest and one of them is police intimidation. For example, if the police record me while I am protesting, this can affect not just me, but have a chilling effect on others. They may be scared to be identified by the police. The right to protest, to freedom of speech and to privacy all get violated.
  • There is no law that regulates how the data is collected, processed, stored, when it should be deleted, or with whom it can be shared.
  • There is no specific law with regard to facial recognition, or a standard operating procedure on how the police should use CCTVs or facial recognition technology
  • It is easy to tamper with video footage these days.

Way forward

  • Only the data to be used for a lawful purpose should be collected and stored. It is stored only for the time until which the purpose is carried out. After that, it should be deleted.
  • There should be comprehensive laws regulating the use of data recorded in CCTV cameras.
  • There should be a compulsory provision of an oversight committee to look into the actions of police.

Union Health Minister Dr Mansukh Mandaviya reviews the ‘Food Street Project’ to develop 100 Healthy and Hygienic Food Streets across the country

Context: Union Minister of Health and Family Welfare, Dr Mansukh Mandaviya reviewed the ‘Food Street Project’ to develop 100 healthy and hygienic food streets across the country with senior officers of the Health Ministry and Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI).

About the street food project

  • The aim of this project is to encourage safe and healthy food practices among food businesses and community members, thus, reducing foodborne illnesses and improving overall health outcomes.
  • To operationalize the food streets, the National Health Mission (NHM) of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare will provide assistance of Rs. 1 crore per food street as a pilot project to support 100 such food streets at different locations across the country.
  • The grant will be routed under NHM, in the ratio of 60:40 or 90:10, with the condition that branding of these food streets will be done as per FSSAI guidelines.
  • Financial assistance would be provided for activities such as the provision of safe drinking water, hand washing, toilet facilities, tiled flooring of common areas, appropriate liquid & solid waste disposal, provision of dustbins, using billboards, façade preparation and signage of permanent nature, common storage space, lighting, specialized carts for a specific type of trades, branding etc.
  • The initiative will be implemented through NHM in convergence with the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA), apart from FSSAI’s technical support.
  • The technical assistance will include assistance in designing food streets, preparation of an SOP and providing training under Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP) protocol.

Capital Punishment in India

Context: The Indian government is considering to form a committee to examine the need for a more humane alternative to death by hanging.

Meaning of Capital Punishment:

  • Capital punishment, also called death penalty, results in execution of an offender sentenced to death after conviction by a court of law for a criminal offence. 
  • The term "Capital Punishment" stands for most severe form of punishment. It is the punishment which is to be awarded for the most heinous, grievous and detestable crimes against humanity.

Capital Punishment provided under Indian Laws:

Indian Penal Code

  • Section 302 - Whoever commits murder shall be punished with death or imprisonment for life and shall also be liable to fine.
  • Section 303 - Whoever, being under sentence of imprisonment for life commits murder, shall be punished with death.
  • Section 124A - Whoever by words, either spoken or written, or by signs, or by visible representation, or otherwise, brings or attempts to bring into hatred or contempt, or excites or attempts to excite disaffection towards the Government established by law in, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, to which fine may be added, or with imprisonment which may extend to three years, to which fine may be added, or with fine. 

Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) 

  • Section 366 - When the Court of Session passes a sentence of death, the proceedings shall be submitted to the High Court, and the sentence shall not be executed unless it is confirmed by the High Court.
  • Section 368 - In any case submitted under section 366, the High Court— (a) may confirm the sentence, or pass any other sentence warranted by law, or (b) may annul the conviction and convict the accused of any offence of which the Court of Session might have convicted him, or order a new trial on the same or an amended charge, or (c) may acquit the accused person. 
  • Section 369 – Death Sentence shall be presided by division bench (Bench of 2 Judges) or more, and order should be signed by at least two judges of the bench.  

Death Penalty in India:

  • The death penalty is a legal punishment for certain serious offenses under the Indian Penal Code, but it is imposed only in the most severe cases. 
  • The decision to impose the death penalty is made by a judge after considering the nature and severity of the crime and any aggravating or mitigating factors. 
  • The death penalty is only given in cases where the judge considers the crime to be of such a nature that it warrants the most severe punishment possible.

Death Penalty in Confirmation to Article 21

  • Article 21 - No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.
  • Indian Penal Code under Section 302 provides reason for death penalty and Criminal Procedure Code establishes the process of awarding death penalty.
  • Thus, awarding death penalty or capital punishment cannot be said to be against the principles of Article 21 of the Indian Constitution.

Bachhan Singh v. State of Punjab, 1980

  • Hanging is done in India in the rarest of rare cases as per the Criminal Procedure Code.
  • Supreme Court held that the death penalty given to a convict is constitutional and will be done in rarest of rare cases.
  • The Court said that death penalty is a lawful infliction of death by the state as a punishment for wrongful and heinous committed by the accused.
  • The Court said that capital punishment is not against Right to life and personal liberty as guaranteed under Article 21 because death penalty through capital punishment has been established under law (Section 366 of Code of Criminal Procedure) and is a legal process.
  • Thus, state is empowered to take away life of citizens through procedure established by law if they are found guilty of crime committed which is punishable with death penalty and is a rarest of rare cases.

Methods of execution in India:

  • Hanging
  • Shooting which is provided for under the Army Act, Navy Act, and Air Force Act.

Mode of execution in question?

Supreme Court is hearing a petition challenging the constitutionality of death by hanging as a mode of execution. The court clarified that the constitutionality of the death penalty is not in question, but rather the mode of execution. The government argues that the method of execution is a matter of legislative policy, and in 2018, the Centre supported death by hanging and did not find the method of execution "barbaric, inhuman, and cruel" compared to other methods such as lethal injection.

Need for removal of Capital Punishment (Law Commission 262nd Report on Death Penalty):

  • Does not Serve as Deterrence: Death penalty is no more a deterrent than life imprisonment, which in India can be for the whole life with limited remissions granted after 30-60 years in many cases of serious crimes.
  • Retribution versus Vengeance: Retribution is important in punishment but not synonymous with vengeance. The "eye for an eye" notion has no place in our constitutionally mediated criminal justice system, and capital punishment doesn't achieve any valid societal goals.
  • Restorative & Reformative Justice loses focus on death penalty as the ultimate measure of justice to victims, the restorative and rehabilitative aspects of justice are forgotten through which accused behaviour can be changed.
  • Reliance on the death penalty diverts attention from other problems ailing the criminal justice system such as poor investigation, crime prevention and rights of victims of crime.
  • Death Sentence disproportional for Vulnerable Sections: The vagaries of the system also operate disproportionately against the socially and economically marginalized who may lack the resources to effectively advocate their rights within an adversarial criminal justice system.
  • Death Penalty Abolished by Most Civilized Nations: In retaining and practicing the death penalty, India forms part of a small and ever dwindling group of nations. That 140 countries are now abolitionist in law or in practice, demonstrates that evolving standards of human dignity and decency do not support the death penalty.
Arguments in Favor of Capital PunishmentArguments Against Capital Punishment

It is based on deterrent theory of punishment – and instils fear of punishment including death among wrong doers.  
Morally Wrong - Keeping an accused of heinous crimes alive at the cost of the lives of number of citizens or potential victims in the society is morally wrong.   
Article 21 - Death Penalty in India in accordance with Article 21 and is also used in Rarest of the Rare Cases.
Death Penalty allows for Right to Appeal – Indian laws and the constitution allow for appeal against the decision of High Court and even Supreme Court. Article 72(c) allows the convict to appeal against the decision of Supreme Court to the President of India if death sentence has been awarded. 

Ensures Retribution by State - It ensures retributive justice by the state which deprives a person of his/her life based on the retributive theory of punishment. It is generally argued that retribution even by state is immoral and is a sanitized form of vengeance. 
Person suffering from Mental Illness - The United Nations Commission on Human Rights calls upon countries “not to impose the death penalty on a person suffering from any form of mental disorder or to execute any such person. 
It does not help in reducing or deterring heinous crime.   
Time Gap – Generally there is a large gap between awarding of death penalty between awarding of death penalty and execution. This keeps offenders waiting on death row

Overall, the issue of capital punishment is complex and requires a nuanced approach that takes into account the views of all stakeholders, including the victims and their families. Ultimately, the decision on capital punishment in India should be based on a thorough analysis of its effectiveness, fairness, and compatibility with human rights standards.

Bilkis Bano case convicts playing for time: SC judge

Context: Justice K.M. Joseph, on a Division Bench of the Supreme Court on Tuesday, said that it was “more than obvious” that the men released early from life imprisonment in the case of gang rape of Bilkis Bano and murder of her family members during the 2002 Gujarat riots were raising a maze of procedural objections in successive court hearings to avoid his Bench.

Time line of Bilkis Bano case

  • During the Gujarat riots of 2002, Bilkis Bano (then five months pregnant) along with her three-and-a-half-year-old daughter and 15 other family members were abruptly attacked by about 20-30 people armed with sickles, swords, and sticks. 
  • Among the attackers were the 11 accused men. Bilkis, her mother, and three other women were raped and brutally assaulted. Of the 17-member of the group eight were found dead, six were missing. Only Bilkis (who reportedly was five months pregnant at that time), a man, and a three-year-old survived the attack.
  • The case was looked upon by the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) and the Supreme Court, which ordered an investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation. 
  • Bilkis Bano was not able to receive her well-deserved justice instead, she got threat notices and so, the case was moved to Mumbai from Gujarat.
  • A special CBI court in Mumbai sentenced the accused to life imprisonment on the charges of gang rape and murder in January 2008. 
  • The Bombay high court maintained the conviction of the accused in 2017, and in 2019
  • The SC ordered the Gujarat state government to compensate the victim with Rs 50 lakh, a job, and a house.
  • Almost after ten years, the Mumbai High Court, in May 2017, upheld the conviction and life imprisonment of 11 people in the gang rape case.
  • In 2019, the Supreme Court awarded compensation of Rs 50 lakh to Bilkis Bano.
  • One of the convicts, Radheshyam Shah, had approached the Gujarat High Court seeking remission of the sentence under section 432 (which mentions the empowerment of the state government to remit sentences as prison is a state subject under the constitution) and section 433 (which adds a caveat; convicts who have received a life sentence for an offence that even carry a death sentence) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Gujarat HC dismissed his plea saying that the "appropriate government" to decide about his remission is Maharashtra and not Gujarat.
Power of Remission Under Cr.Pc Different From Constitutional Powers of Pardon

Suspend or Remit – Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.PC) under Section 432 empowers central and state government to suspend or remit a sentence, in whole or in part, with or without conditions. 

Commutation – Section 433 empowers central and state governments to commute death sentence, imprisonment for life and rigorous imprisonment to a lesser degree.

State Government to Consult the Centre – Section 435 of Cr.PC states that powers of state government to suspend, remit or commute a sentence must be done in consultation with the central government if: 

1. The case was investigated by Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) or 

2. The case was investigated by any other agency empowered to make an investigation into an offence under any Central Act. 

3. The offence involved misappropriation or destruction of, or damage to, any property belonging to the Central Government, or 

4. The offence was committed by a person in the service of the Central Government while acting in the discharge of his official duty.

Section 433A adds a restriction on powers of remission or commutation in certain cases. It states that where a sentence of imprisonment for life is imposed on conviction of a person for an offence for which death is one of the punishments provided by law, or where a sentence of death imposed on a person has been commuted under section 433 into one of imprisonment for life, such person shall not be released from prison unless he has served at least 14 years of imprisonment.
  • The Gujarat government had on August, 2022 granted remission to the convicts, as they had served over 15 years in prison and reportedly showed good conduct in Jail. However, the trial court judge at Mumbai as well as the prosecuting agency, the CBI, had opined against grant of remission on the ground that they committed the heinous offences in a gruesome manner.
  • A series of petitions have been filed in the Apex court , challenging the release of the 11 rapists. The court took up the issue explained it was important for it to examine the records to see whether the State government had independently applied its mind to all the relevant factors before granting remission to 11 men sentenced to life imprisonment for the gangrape of Bilkis Bano and the “horrendous mass murder” of her family members during the 2002 riots.

For further readings regarding constitutional and legal provisions related to remission and pardon kindly refer following link

In Karnataka, BJP promises uniform civil code if elected

Context: The BJP’s released its manifesto for the May 10 Karnataka Assembly elections with several poll promises. Prominent among them are implementing the Uniform Civil Code in the State based on the recommendations by a high-level committee which will be constituted if the party is voted to power.

Uniform Civil Code (UCC)

  • Article 44 of the Indian Constitution states that the State shall endeavor to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India. However, it is not so easy to make a uniform law on personal laws of all religions as each aspect of personal life like marriage, divorce, succession etc. are governed differently. So, Uniform Civil Code is an attempt to unify all civilian laws including personal laws for people of all faith living in India
  • UCC is the proposal to administer same set of secular civil laws to govern all people irrespective of their religion, gender, domicile, caste, etc. This law will be distinguished from public law and will subsume all laws covering marriage, divorce, inheritance, adoption and maintenance of different religions into one codified law. However, so far it has been difficult to achieve uniformity in personal laws of all religion.

Present push for UCC

  • Recent promises by BJP in its poll manifesto for Karnataka poll.
  • Proposal to Examine UCC by Uttarakhand CM days after Uttarakhand Chief Minister took oath.
  • Private Members’ Bill proposed on UCC by Rakesh Sinha, Rajya Sabha member.
  • Matter to be taken by 22nd Law Commission as per the Law Minister.
  • Supreme Court - government should explore the UCC to secure gender justice, equality and dignity of women.
  • Proposal by Chancellor of Maulana Azad National Urdu University asked the Supreme Court to direct the government to constitute a judicial commission or a high-level expert committee to prepare a draft UCC in tune with international conventions which protect the rights of women.

UCC and Indian constitution

  • UCC has been provided under part IV of the Indian constitution and is part of DPSP. Article 44 states - “The State shall endeavor to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India.”
  • The objective is to harmonize diverse cultural practices and address the discrimination meted out to various vulnerable groups under the garb of religious practices.
  • During the drafting of the constitution, UCC met with stiff opposition from various corners. Various minority religions especially the Muslims felt that UCC would curtail their freedom of religion, hence were apprehensive of replacing their personal laws with UCC.
  • It was due to this apprehension that UCC was included as a DPSP rather than a Fundamental right and it was envisaged that it will be achieved gradually and not all at once.
  • Nevertheless, having UCC embodied in DPSP reflects the intention of securing justice and equality for all citizens.

Benefits of Uniform Civil Code 

  • UCC would not only protect the vulnerable sections, including women and religious minorities, but “promote nationalistic fervour through unity” as well as simplify the complex personal laws. 
  • It will do away with diversity in matrimonial laws, simplify the Indian legal system and make Indian society more homogeneous. 
  • It will de-link law from religion. 
  • It will create a national identity and will help in containing fissiparous tendencies in the country. 
  • It will also help in establishing social justice and gender equality in family matters. 
  • The introduction of UCC will promote monogamy among all the citizen of India including Muslim and it will lead to betterment in the position of women. 
  • It will also remove prejudices against women regarding personal laws on divorce and maintenance. 
  • It will help in strengthening the secular fabric of the country and promote unity. 

UCC and the Supreme Court 

a) Shah Bano case: In 1985, the Supreme Court ruled in favour of Shah Bano, who had moved the apex court seeking maintenance after her husband divorced her. The then Chief Justice, Y.V. Chandrachud, observed that a Common Civil Code would help the cause of national integration by removing disparate loyalties to law. The Court directed Parliament to frame a Uniform Civil Code. 

Despite the Judgment, the government, in 1986, enacted the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, which nullified Shah Bano judgment. The Act allowed maintenance to women only for 90 days after the divorce”. 

b) In the John Vallamattom v. Union of India case in 2003, Chief Justice V.N. Khare had observed: “It is a matter of regret that Article 44 of the Constitution has not been given effect to. Parliament is still to step in for framing a common civil code in the country.”

c) S.R. Bommai - SC warned against “mixing politics with religion”. The court had worried whether a secular state should bring a code which can be perceived to be a threat to personal laws based on the religious beliefs of individual religions. 

Goa is the only state where Uniform Civil code exists

The Goa Civil Code collectively called Family Laws, was framed and enforced by the Portuguese colonial rulers through various legislations in the 19th and 20th centuries. After the liberation of Goa in 1961, the Indian State scrapped all the colonial laws and extended the central laws to the territory but made the exception of retaining the Family Laws. 

Law commission report on UCC - 2018

  • Law commission said that UCC is currently neither necessary nor desirable in India.
  • Need for Religion wise Amendment - The commission has recommended religion-wise amendment in personal laws to end discrimination against women within the communities. 
  • Ensure equality within community - It urged the legislator to “first consider equality within communities i.e. between men and women rather than equality between communities:”
  • Preserve diversity of personal laws in absence of consensus through codification - In the absence of consensus over UCC Commission felt that preserving the diversity of personal law is best way forward. To achieve this, it is desirable that all personal laws relating to matters of family must first be codified to the greatest extent possible and then the inequalities that have crept into codified law, should be remedied by amendment. 

Argument Against UCC

  • Against Right to Freedom of Religion - It will introduce  State interference in religious affairs hence against  the concept of secularism and may violate Article 25. This may go against S.R. Bommai Judgment which  held - The Constitution has chosen secularism as its  vehicle to establish an egalitarian social order.  Secularism is part of the fundamental law and structure of the Indian political system. 
  • It may impact the cultural practices of some tribal communities in India.
  • Considering the plural society of India – it will be a complex task to unify all personal laws of all religions, castes, communities, tribes etc. across the country. 

Way Forward

  • Hence, when and if an Uniform civil Code is brought into effect, it will have to ensure a balance between the protecting of fundamental rights and religious principles of different communities. Before enacting a common personal law, it is necessary to take into confidence all religion and communities of India. 
  • Further, steps can be taken to legislate on such common matters which are least controversial but with complete consent of every community in India. The idea is to provide uniformity in set of rules by consent and not to create more fissures and fault lines in the name of enforcing a uniform common law for India. 

  

‘Grey areas’ in law banning prenatal sex determination need fixing, says HC

Context: The Delhi High Court has remarked that certain aspects of the Pre­Conception & Pre­Natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) (PC & PNDT) Act need reconsideration for effective implementation of the Act. Court also remarked that “the low rate of conviction under the PC & PNDT Act poses a significant challenge, as it is incredibly arduous to prohibit pre­natal diagnosis of sex”.

The problem of declining child sex ratio

  • Continuous decline in child sex ratio since 1961 Census is a matter of concern for the country. Beginning from 976 in 1961 Census, it declined to 927 in 2001. As per Census 2011 the Child Sex Ratio (0-6 years) has dipped further to 919 against 927 girls per thousand boys recorded in 2001 Census.

Important provisions of the Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994 

  • The Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (Regulation and Prevention of Misuse) Act was enacted on September 20, 1994 and the Act was further amended in 2003. The Act provides for the prohibition of sex selection ,before or after conception, and for regulation of pre-natal diagnostic techniques for the purposes of detecting genetic abnormalities or metabolic disorders or chromosomal abnormalities or certain congenital malformations or sex linked disorders and for the prevention of their misuse for sex determination leading to female foeticide and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.

The Act is implemented through the following implementing bodies:

  1. Central Supervisory Board 
  2. State Supervisory Boards and Union Territory Supervisory Boards 
  3. Appropriate Authority for the whole or a part of the State or Union Territory 
  4. State Advisory Committee and Union Territory Advisory Committee 
  5. Advisory Committees for designated areas (part of the State) attached to each Appropriate Authority. 
  6. Appropriate Authorities at the District and Sub-District levels

Registration 

  • Appropriate Authority of the district is responsible for registration of ultrasound diagnostic facilities.
  • Mandatory Displays at ultrasound centre

(1) Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (PC and PNDT) Certificate: It is mandatory for every clinic or facility or hospital etc. registered under the Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques Act to display the certificate of registration at a conspicuous place at such Centre, Laboratory or Clinic. 

(2) Signage, board or banner in English & local language indicating that foetal sex is not disclosed at the concerned facility. 

(3) Copy of the Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques Act must be available in every ultrasound centre

Renewal of registration 

(1) Every certificate of registration is valid for a period of 5 years 

(2) Renewal of registration to be done 30 days before the date of expiry of the certificate of registration. 

Mandatory maintenance of records: Register showing in serial order: 

(1) Names and addresses of men or women subjected to pre-natal diagnostic procedure or test

(2) Names of their spouses or fathers 

(3) Date on which they first reported for such counselling, procedure or test. 

(4) A monthly report should be submitted to the Appropriate Authority regularly, before the 5th of every month. A copy of same monthly reports with the signature of the Appropriate Authority acknowledging receipt must be preserved.

Preservation of the following duly completed forms 

  1. Form F 
  2. Referral Slips of Doctors 
  3. Forms of consent 
  4. Sonographic plates or slides 9. 

Record storage  

  • All above records should be preserved for 2 years. 

Powers of Appropriate Authority 

(1) Appropriate Authority can enter freely into any clinic or facility for search and seizure. 

(2) Examine and inspect of registers, records including consent forms, referral slips, Forms, sonographic plates or slides and equipment like ultrasonography machines. 

(3) To ensure presence of at least two independent witnesses of the same locality or different locality during the search.

Concerns 

  • Non-compliance with the legal requirements for operating the facility is rampant in many parts of India. 
  • The primary reason for non-conviction is due to the inadequate legal expertise provided by the Public Prosecutor. 
  • As per the 10th Common Review Mission Report of the National Health Mission , there are low conviction rates under this Act, due to  lack of witnesses, insufficient evidence, and out-of-court settlements.
  • The ground-level people are more focused on clerical errors than working on the bigger picture of reducing female foeticide. This has led to many instances of harassment of radiologists and has also provided additional avenue for corruption.
  • Future technologies being developed for sex-determination, like testing of craniate cells in maternal blood, subtle techniques for sex-pre-selection, like electrolysis, Ericsson’s methodology, etc are presently not covered under the law.

Suggestions 

  • Implementation of Act should be strengthened through regular survey and inspection.
  • Renewal of the registration  should be done on the basis of track record of the compliance to the record keeping rules.
  • Regular meetings among various implementation bodies of state should be taken up.
  • Monitoring and evaluation process should be made robust by inclusion of PRI’s , NGO’s and community workers.
  • Capacity building various stakeholders like prosecutors, District appropriate authorities, community workers like ASHA’s etc, through training and media workshop should be undertaken.

Conclusion

The sex determination techniques and female infanticide is an inhumane act that needs to be curtailed by effective implementation of the PC PNDT Act. Protection of women and girl child should be priorities through effective implementation of public policies and regulations. There needs to be proper vigilance by the state and civil society to look after the declining sex ratio of the female population in the country.  

Happening Haryana slips as investments drop amid worries over law reserving jobs for locals

Context: Once one of the most sought-after investment destinations, particularly for skill driven manufacturing sectors such as automobiles, Haryana seems to have lost some of its sheen with its share of new investment projects in the country tripping to a six year low of 1.06% in 2022­23, down sharply from almost 3% in the year before.

Highlights 

  • Total investment outlays announced in the State fell 30% last year to ₹39,000­odd crore from nearly ₹56,000 crore in 2021­22.
  • This pushed Haryana from the ninth best State in terms of new investment projects to the 13th rank in 2022­23. 
  • Manufacturing investments declined 60% to just about ₹9,500 crore.
image 2
  • Maruti Suzuki — one of the State’s largest legacy investors, which announced a ₹18,000­crore project, Haryana’s largest investment in 2021­22 — is now eyeing a ₹24,000­crore plant that will come up elsewhere.
  • Compared to 2021­22, when manufacturing, industrial parks, roadways and realty projects dominated the State’s largest investments, realty projects dominate the outlays announced in 2022­23.

The decline in fresh projects in the State coincides with its enactment of a law in early 2022 that reserved 75% of private sector jobs with monthly salaries up to ₹30,000 for local people. The law has been kept in abeyance after being challenged judicially, but the suspense over its implementation remains a worry for investors.

HARYANA’S LOCAL RESERVATION LAW

Haryana government passed a law reserving 75% of private sector jobs for residents of the state. This raised a debate on such sons of soil policies undertaken by state governments like Haryana and Andhra Pradesh.

Haryana Employment of Local Candidates Act 2020

The Act requires private sector employers to reserve 75% of job posts that offer a salary of less than Rs 30,000 for individuals who are domiciled in Haryana. It is applicable to all private companies, societies, partnership firms, trusts, any person employing ten or more persons in Haryana, or any other entity as may be notified by the Government.

Potential Benefits

• Provides employment opportunities to the locals and reduces regional inequalities.

• Reduces the friction between local and Migrant labour and helps in managing labour unrest.

• Since migration of labour is more often seasonal, the law can lower the dependence on migrant labour and reduces absenteeism.

Problems

  • Drive away investments: Mandatory quotas for jobs and powers for officials to slap penalties on companies for violations may drive away competitive firms who will be wary of new inspector raj and the impact on productivity.
  • Barrier to migration: Poses risk of obstructing free flow of labour from labour surplus states to labour shortage states, which is essential to reap the benefits of Demographic dividend.
  • Legal Implications: Violation of Art 14, Art 16 and Art 19(a) guaranteed by the Indian Constitution. In a landmark Pradeep Jain Case, the Supreme Court has raised concerns that such policies may lead to Economic and Social Fragmentation of India.
  • Political Implications: Rise of strong Sons-of-soil movement even in other states and thus end up affecting the spirit of Cooperative Federalism.
  • Increased Automation: Such affirmative actions in private industry might encourage firms to increase automation in production process which reduces employment generation potential of private firms.
  • Social Implications: In a multilinguistic society such as India, restricted work-related migration stifles interaction of different languages and cultures and helps in thriving regionalist tendencies.
  • Unsustainable solution: Though such reservations provide temporary benefits to the local community in terms of assured employment, it will not help in addressing the basic issues that are responsible for low employment growth.

Hence, States need to abstain from such inward- oriented and parochial policies, adopt spirit of cooperative federalism and work in a coordinated and synergistic manner to address the root cause- Lack of employment opportunities.

Governor's power to reserve bills for approval

Context: The Supreme Court has given a timely reminder to Governors that the Constitution expects that a decision to return a Bill to the State Assembly for reconsideration should be made “as soon as possible”. It has drawn attention to the phrase found in the first proviso to Article 200, seeking to convey a sense of immediacy in the matter of returning a Bill.  “The expression ‘as soon as possible’ contains significant constitutional content and must be borne in mind by constitutional authorities,” the Court observed. This effectively means it would be constitutionally impermissible for Governors to hold on to Bills indefinitely without communicating their decision to the House.

Power and function of the Governor pertaining to giving assent to a bill falls under category of legislative powers.

Constitutional Provisions

  • Article 200 – When a Bill has been passed by the Legislative Assembly of a State or, in the case of a State having a Legislative Council, has been passed by both Houses of the Legislature of the State, it shall be presented to the Governor and the Governor shall have following options
  • He may give his assents to the Bill , thus the bill becomes an Act.
  • He may withholds assent , the bill thus ends and does not becomes an Act.
  • He may return the bill for the reconsideration of House or houses.  If the bill is passed again with or without amendments and presented to Governor for his assent, the governor must give his assent to the bill.
  • He may reserves the Bill for the consideration of the President.
  • Article 201 – When a Bill is reserved by a Governor for the consideration of the President, the President shall have following options
  • He may give his Assent. 
  • He may withhold his Assent.
  • He may direct the Governor to return the bill to the House or, as the case may be.

The Governor’s power to withhold assent or return a Bill, with a message, for reconsideration is seen as discretionary.

Article 163

  • Another constitutional provision of importance is Article 163 which states that there shall be a Council of Ministers with the Chief Minister at the head to aid and advise the Governor in the exercise of his functions, except in so far as he is by or under this Constitution required to exercise his functions or any of them in his discretion.  
  • However, the discretionary powers of the Governors have not been explicitly defined in the constitution and can only be ascertained by going through certain constitutional provisions.

Concerns 

There are three clear problems associated with Article 200, which deals with assent to Bills: 

  • The absence of a time limit for acting on Bills
  • The scope for reserving a Bill for the President’s consideration against the express advice of the Cabinet 
  • The claim that the Governor can kill any Bill by declining assent. 

The mischief lies in Article 163, which hedges the primary rule that the Governors function on the ‘aid and advice’ of the Cabinet, with a clause that prohibits any inquiry into whether a particular matter fell within their discretion or not. These provisions give abundant scope for conflict between the government and Raj Bhavan.

Way Ahead 

Important Supreme Court Judgements
Shamsher Singh v. State of Punjab (1974) – Supreme Court said: “The Governor has no right to refuse to act on the advice of the Council of Ministries. Such a position is antithetical to the concept of ‘responsible government’.”     B.P. Singhal v. Union of India (2010)Five Judge Bench of Supreme on removal of governors mentioned about the dual role of governor: 1. Agent of the Centre & 2. Head of the state.SC also held that there may be instances of conflict between Centre and states where the governor has to act neutrally.

Sarkaria commission recommendation w.r.t assent to the bills

  • Normally, in the discharge of the functions under Article 200, the Governor must abide by the advice of his Council of Ministers. 
  • In dealing with a State Bill presented to him under Article 200, the Governor should not act contrary to the advice of his Council of Ministers merely because, personally, he does not like the policy embodied in the Bill.
  • Needless reservation of Bills for President's consideration should be avoided.
  • Normally, when a Bill passed by the State Legislature is presented to the Governor with the advice of the Council of Ministers that it be reserved for the consideration of the President, then the Governor should do so forthwith. If, in exceptional circumstances, the Governor thinks it necessary to act and adopt, in the exercise of his discretion, any other course open to him under Article 200, he should do so within a period not exceeding one month from the date on which the Bill is presented to him.
  • State Governments often consult the Government of India at the drafting stage of a Bill. This is a healthy practice and should continue.
  • As a matter of salutary convention, a Bill reserved for consideration of the President should be disposed of by the President within a period of 4 months from the date on which it is received by the Union Government.
  • As a matter of convention, the President should not withhold assent only on the consideration of policy differences on matters relating, in pith and substance, to the State List.
  • President's assent should not ordinarily be withheld on the ground that the Union is contemplating a comprehensive law in future on the same subject. To the extent feasible, the reasons for withholding assent should be communicated to the State Government.

For further readings regarding the details of Article 200 and Article 201 refer to the following links

The challenge of reviving a sense of fraternity

What is Fraternity?

  • The term fraternity is provided in the Preamble of the Indian constitution. In the words of Dr Ambedkar, it means a sense of common brotherhood of all Indians — if Indians are one people. It is the principle that gives unity and solidarity to social life.
  • The idea of fraternity is based on the view that people have responsibilities to each other.
  •  It was defined after the French Revolution in the following terms: ‘Do not do to others what you would not want them to do to you; do constantly to others the good which you would wish to receive from them.
  • It is generally seen as an emotion rather than a principle because it denotes a feeling of attachment to nationals.

Why do we need Fraternity?

  • India is a land of Diversity in terms of race, ethnicity, religion, caste and culture.  To ensure unity and integrity of the nation we need to follow the concept of fraternity.
  • It is the Fundamental duty of every citizen of India ‘to promote harmony and the spirit of commonality among all the people of India, transcending religious, linguistic and regional or sectional diversities.
  • In the words of Ambedkar, these principles of liberty equality and fraternity are not to be treated as separate items in a trinity. They form a union of trinity in the sense that to divorce one from the other is to defeat the very purpose of democracy.
  • Fraternity assures the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the Nation. 

Challenges before Fraternity

  • Social inequalities: There are widespread inequalities in our society based on caste, gender, religion race and culture etc.
  • Political inequalities: Political inequalities are visible in the fact that only 10.5% of MPs are female in our parliament.
  • Economic inequalities: top 10% of the Indian population holds 77% of the total national wealth and 73% of the wealth generated in 2017 went to the richest 1% while 670 million Indians who compromise the poorest half of the population saw only a 1% increase in their wealth.
  • Regional inequalities: it can be seen in the case of South Indian states vis a vis North Indian states specially BIMARU states (Bihar, MP, Rajasthan, UP)
  • Communalism: Communalism is growing in India it can be seen in the communisation of religious festivals like recent Ramanavami processions, Cow vigilantism, Love Jihad etc.

Way forward:

  • Every citizen should follow their constitutional duty of harmony.
  • State agencies should follow the principle of secularism while implementing the law.
  • Religious and political leaders should avoid divisive politics.
  • Civil society can play a crucial role in resistance against state-sponsored discrimination.
  • Institutions’ autonomy should be promoted so that they can perform their duty effectively.

Only half of PMJDY insurance claims were settled in two years

Context: In the last two financial years, only 329 claims for the accident insurance cover provided to bank account holders under the Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) have been settled out of the 647 claims that were filed.

About PMJDY

PMJDY is a National Mission on Financial Inclusion encompassing an integrated approach to bring about comprehensive financial inclusion of all the households in the country.

The plan envisages universal access to banking facilities with

  •  at least one basic banking account for every household,
  •  financial literacy,
  •  access to credit,
  •  insurance and
  • pension facility.

Mobile transactions through telecom operators and their established centres as Cash Out Points are also planned to be used for Financial Inclusion under the Scheme.

Benefits under PMJDY

  •  One basic savings bank account is opened for unbanked persons.
  • There is no requirement to maintain any minimum balance in PMJDY accounts.
  •  Interest is earned on the deposit in PMJDY accounts.
  •  Rupay Debit card is provided to PMJDY account holders.
  •  Accident Insurance Cover of Rs.1 lakh (enhanced to Rs. 2 lakhs for new PMJDY accounts opened after 28.8.2018) is available with a RuPay card issued to the PMJDY account holders.
  •  An overdraft (OD) facility of up to Rs. 10,000 to eligible account holders is available.PMJDY accounts are eligible for Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT), Pradhan Mantri Jeevan Jyoti Bima Yojana (PMJJBY), Pradhan Mantri Suraksha Bima Yojana (PMSBY), Atal Pension Yojana (APY), Micro Units Development & Refinance Agency Bank (MUDRA) scheme.

Achievements of PMJDY

  •  48.82 crore beneficiaries banked so far under PMJDY
  •  Rs. 199341.41 crore balance in the bank accounts under PMJDY
  •  6.55 lakh bank Mitras are delivering branchless banking services in the country.