Constitution & Polity of India

Draconian rules

Context : This editorial is a critical analysis of the IT (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Amendment Rules, 2023 , and specifically the rules which are dealing with the issue of fake news. This write up sheds light on the recently added provisions and argues how these rules are in contravention to the Fundamental Right of free speech and expression as enshrined in Article 19 of the Indian constitution.

Fake news 

  • Fake news is an inaccurate, sometimes sensationalistic report that is created to gain attention, mislead, deceive or damage a reputation. 

Implications of Fake News

  • Conditioning of knowledge – Levels of penetration of social media has enabled the spread of fake news as a wild fire.  In lack of proper authentication check soon it becomes a validated knowledge thus helping in creating a wrongly modulated environment against or in favour of anything. For ex : Our national anthem being recognised as worlds best anthem by UNESCO.
  • Polarization and Politicization -  Fake news is being used as a tool by political parties as well as prominent news channels to build a narrative which is suitable to their cause. The end result is again a fabricated environment, which often serves a narrow objective. For ex. Union Home ministry used the picture of Spain Morocco border in its annual report to show that it had installed floodlights in border areas.
  • Social Disharmony – Fake narratives often creates hatred among communities , this results into incitement of violence. Fake news has also been used to radicalization of youth which poses threat to national security at various levels. For ex . Use of fake news in Muzaffarnagar riots of 2013 ; and recent Fake videos of migrant workers in Tamilnadu which created an atmosphere of fear and stress among the population.

Regulations in India

  • India does not have a robust and exclusive framework for curbing the menace of the fake news.
  • However government by the use of Section 69A of the Information technology Act, 2000, has granted itself greater power to strike down any unpalatable content. 
  • Some provisions of The Disaster Management Act 2005 and the Epidemic Diseases Act 1897 are evoked to regulate the fake news.
  • Indian Penal Code 1860 deals with fake news specifically causing riots and defamation cases.
  • Government has come up with the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 , or IT Rules, 2021 to regulate content by online publishers of news and social media intermediaries.
  • Now recent amendments in this Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, have drawn criticism from various experts , who term it as an attempt by government to curb the exercise of free speech and expression.

INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (INTERMEDIARY GUIDELINES AND DIGITAL MEDIA ETHICS) RULES, 2021

Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MEITY) has notified the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics) Rules, 2021 to regulate IT intermediaries such as Twitter, Facebook and digital media outlets. While many IT intermediaries have complied to these rules Twitter has failed to comply with them.

CONCERNS HIGHLIGHTED ON IT RULES

Privacy versus National Security - The rules only make superficial attempts at balancing privacy and security interests as security interests are being given primacy over both civil liberty interests as well as economic interests.

Breaking End-to-end Encryption - The traceability obligation (i.e. to track—and be able to identify—the originator of any message) in the new rules is problematic as it would amount to breaking end-to-end encryption provided for all users on platforms such as WhatsApp. This will give greater powers of surveillance to state over personal affairs of citizens and tantamount to interference in right to privacy.

Data Theft & Hacking - Breaking of end-to-end encryption will increase chances of data theft and hacking.

Traceability clause capable of misuse - The rule as it’s currently drafted is vague and this allows the government to use traceability power in a broad way and therefore open to misuse. Thus, to use traceability powers, court must clarify the grounds and circumstances for its use by state authorities.

Limited Purview of IT Act - Regarding digital news and media portals, the purview of the Information Technology Act, 2000, is limited. It only extends to the blocking of websites and intermediary liabilities framework but does not extend to content authors and creators.

Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics code) Amendment rules, 2023

Objective: Government Notified Amendments for an Open, Safe, Trusted and Accountable Internet. These amendments layout a comprehensive framework for Online Gaming Eco-system and also deals with Fact checking related to online content pertaining to Government.

Amendments: It has been made obligatory on the part of intermediaries to make reasonable effort to not host, publish or share any online game that can cause the user harm, or the content that has not been verified as a permissible online game by an online gaming self-regulatory body/bodies designated by the Central Government. The self-regulatory body will have the authority to inquire and satisfy itself that the online game does not involve wagering on any outcome.The amended rules also cast additional obligations on online gaming intermediaries in relation to online games involving real money.

These include the displaying of a mark of verification by the self-regulatory body on such games;informing their users of the policy for withdrawal or refund of deposit, manner of determination and distribution of winnings, fees and other charges payable; obtaining the KYC details of the users; and not giving credit or enabling financing by third parties to the users.The amended rules now also make it obligatory on the intermediaries to not to publish, share or host fake, false or misleading information in respect of any business of the Central Government. These fake, false or misleading information will identified by the notified Fact Check Unit of the Central Government.

Concern About These Amendments:

It is in contravention to “safe harbour” protections in Section 79 of the IT Act, which allows intermediaries to avoid liabilities for what third parties post on their websites. These notified amendments can bypass Section 69A of the IT Act, 2000 which elucidates the procedure to issue takedown orders. According to author , a threat to remove a platform’s immunity for content that is flagged by a government unit, would create a “chilling effect” on the right to speech and expression on online platforms. 

Challenges in Curbing fake news in India 

  • Regulation vs Rights Conundrum  - Flagging of fake news often gets entangled between debate of intention. While those proponent term it as necessity to maintain tranquillity and order, critics term it as attempt of curbing free speech.
  • Low Digital literacy – As per India Inequality report 2022 , around 70% of the population has poor or no digital connectivity. Now such a low level of digital literacy acts as a barrier in verification and authenticity of the news.
  • No dedicated framework – Lack of robust and exclusive framework has affected the efforts in curbing fake news at every stages. For ex- insufficient infrastructure for verification, no penalties etc all have contributed in flourishing of this trend.
  • Inherent Nature of ICT – Anonymity of content creator poses greatest challenge in front of the regulatory bodies as well as intermediaries to track and address the issue of fake news.

Way forward

  • Users 
    • Digital literacy about verification and authentication of any published facts or reports should be promoted.
    • Sensitization of publishers and content creators about the impacts and repercussions of the fake news and its propagations.
  • Intermediaries
    • Should be encouraged to formulate policy and actions in tracking and removing fake news.
  • Government 
    • Strengthening Regulations and their application is of utmost importance. Fact check mechanism should be made robust and effective. 
    • Transparency in identification and regulation should be adopted to address the concerns of various stakeholders.

National Human Rights Commission

Context: The All India Kisan Sabha (AIKS) has alleged that farmers were attacked and their sources were destroyed during the post-poll violence in Tripura. Leaders of the AIKS demanded urgent intervention of the National Human Rights Commission to control the violence.

Introduction about NHRC

The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) of India was established in 1993. The statute under which it is established is the Protection of Human Rights Act (PHRA).

It is in conformity with the Paris Principles, adopted at the first international workshop on national institutions for the promotion and protection of human rights held in Paris in 1991, and endorsed by the General Assembly of the United Nations.  

The NHRC is an embodiment of India’s concern for the promotion and protection of human rights.

The Protection of Human Rights Act (PHRA), 1993 defines Human Rights as the rights relating to life, liberty, equality and dignity of the individual guaranteed by the Constitution or embodied in the International Covenants and enforceable by courts in India.  

Sub Committee on Accreditation (SCA) 

The National Human Rights Commission, India has retained its 'A' status of accreditation with the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions, GANHRI.

The accreditation is given after a rigorous process of review of the NHRI by the GANHRI through its Sub Committee on Accreditation (SCA). 

The United Nations' Paris Principles provide the international benchmarks against which national human rights institutions (NHRIs) can be accredited. 

Paris Principles

The Paris Principles set out six main criteria that NHRIs require to meet. These are: Mandate and competence, Autonomy from Government, Independence guaranteed by a Statute or Constitution, Pluralism, Adequate resources; and adequate powers of investigation. 

Functions

The NHRC has the following key functions:  

  • To bridge the gap between responsibilities of the State and the rights of individuals 
  • To intervene in any judicial proceeding involving allegations of violation of Human Rights pending before a Court 
  • To protect Human Rights and recommend measures for their effective implementation 
  • To monitor and evaluate the factors, including acts of terrorism that curtail the enjoyment of Human Rights and recommend appropriate remedial measures 
  • To study treaties and other international instruments 
  • To enquire into complaints of violation of Human Rights 
  • To conduct research in the field of Human Rights 
  • To spread Human Rights literacy and awareness 
  • To encourage the efforts of Non-Governmental Organisations and Human Rights Defenders 
  • Assessment of developments in areas like IT, sports, business etc. impinging on Human Rights protection 
  • To perform any such functions as it may consider necessary for the promotion of Human Rights as provided in the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993

Type of complaints not entertained by the Commission

Ordinarily, complaints of the following nature are not entertained by the Commission:

a) In regard to events which happened more than one year before the making of the complaints;

b) With regard to matters which are sub-judice;

c) Which are vague, anonymous or pseudonymous;

d) Which are of frivolous nature;

e) Which pertain to service matters.

Composition

The NHRC consists of: The chairperson and five members (excluding the ex-officio members)  

  • A Chairperson, who has been a Chief Justice of India or a Judge of the Supreme Court. 
  • One member who is, or has been, a Judge of the Supreme Court of India and one member who is, or has been, the Chief Justice of a High Court.
  • Three Members, out of which at least one shall be a woman to be appointed from amongst persons having knowledge of, or practical experience in, matters relating to human rights.
  • In addition, the Chairpersons of National Commissions viz., National Commission for Scheduled Castes, National Commission for Scheduled Tribes, National Commission for Women , National Commission for Minorities, National Commission for Backward Classes, National Commission for Protection of Child Rights; and the Chief Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities serve as ex officio members.

The sitting Judge of the Supreme Court or sitting Chief Justice of any High Court can be appointed only after the consultation with the Chief Justice of India.

Appointment

The Chairperson and members of the NHRC are appointed by the President of India, on the recommendation of a committee consisting of:

  • The Prime Minister (Chairperson)
  • The Home Minister
  • The Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha 
  • The Leader of the Opposition in the Rajya Sabha 
  • The Speaker of the Lok Sabha 
  • The Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha 

Limitations

  • Human right commissions can (including State Human Right Commissions) only make recommendations, without the power to enforce decisions. This lack of authority to ensure compliance has unfortunate consequences.
  • The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 requires that three of the five members of a human rights commission must be former judges but does not specify whether these judges should have a proven record of human rights activism or expertise or qualifications in the area.
  • Under the Act, human rights commissions cannot investigate an event if the complaint was made more than one year after the incident. Therefore, a large number of genuine grievances go unaddressed.
  • State human rights commissions cannot call for information from the national government, which means that they are implicitly denied the power to investigate armed forces under national control.
  • Most human rights commissions are functioning with less than the prescribed Members. This limits the capacity of commissions to deal promptly with complaints, especially as all are facing successive increases in the number of complaints.
  • Scarcity of resources - or rather, resources not being used for human rights related functions - is another big problem. Large chunks of the budget of commissions go in office expenses and in maintaining their members, leaving disproportionately small amounts for other crucial areas such as research and rights awareness programmes.
  • As human rights commissions primarily draw their staff from government departments - either on deputation or reemployment after retirement - the internal atmosphere is usually just like any other government office. 

Strict hierarchies are maintained, which often makes it difficult for complainants to obtain documents or information about the status of their case. 

The presence of security guards, armies of peons and office attendants creates barriers for ordinary people to personally meet officials in regard to their complaint.

Suggestion for reforms

  • The effectiveness of human rights commissions will be greatly enhanced if their decisions are immediately made enforceable by the government. 

This will save considerable time and energy as commissions will no longer need to either send reminders to government departments to implement the recommendations or alternatively to approach High Courts through a cumbersome judicial process to make the government take action.

  • Commissions must also have clear and well-defined powers to proceed against government departments furnishing false reports.  This will assist in preventing the many instances where the departmental version of events is more often than not a white-wash, particularly in those cases where the police has been accused of violations.
  • As non-judicial member positions are increasingly being filled by ex-bureaucrats, credence is given to the contention that commissions are more an extension of the government, rather than independent agencies exercising oversight. 
  • If commissions are to play a meaningful role in society, they must include civil society human rights activists as members.
  • Complaints regarding police excesses and misbehaviour take up most of the time of human rights commissions. It is perhaps time to think about an alternative agency, dedicated solely to civilian oversight of the police. 

Here we can learn from international experience: the UK, for instance, has an Independent Police Complaints Commission; South Africa has an Independent Complaints Directorate; and Brazil has Police Ombudsmen offices is some provinces to deal exclusively with police complaints. 

End note: Reform initiatives can only bear fruit when ordinary citizens take an active interest in good governance and human rights. 

Himachal considering legalising cultivation of cannabis says CM

Context: Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu announced that the State government is considering legalising the cultivation of cannabis. The announcement was made during the Budget Session of the State Assembly in Shimla. The State government is cautious about the potential increase in drug use and has formed a five-member committee of MLAs to conduct a thorough study of each and every aspect related to cannabis cultivation in the State.

Background:

  • India banned the cultivation of the cannabis plant under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act in 1985. 
  • However, the act allows state governments to allow controlled and regulated cultivation of hemp for obtaining its fibre and seed for industrial or horticultural purposes. 
  • In 2018, Uttarakhand became the first state in the country to legalise the cultivation of only those strains of the cannabis plant which have a low concentration of tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), the primary psychoactive constituent of cannabis that produces a high sensation.
  • Uttar Pradesh followed a similar policy, while Madhya Pradesh and Manipur are also considering it.

Uses and Benefits of Hemp

  • Traditionally in Himachal, hemp is used for footwear, ropes, mats, and food. Kept people warm, and energetic in the snow. CM said seeds are used for paint, ink, and biofuel; quality is among the world's best.   
  • Globally, hemp is used for health, medicines, and building material. Can generate employment, the economy in Himachal given limits on the industry, and tourism (hit by Covid-19). Seeking to attract the hemp industry to meet debt (higher than budget), and fund dependence. 

Concerns Around Legalization

  • Hemp source of psychoactive intoxicants like charas (hashish), and ganja (bhang in Himachal). Smoked, in food/drinks. Banned under NDPS Act regardless of hemp legalization.
  • Risk of diversion to recreational use. Strict regulation and monitoring are required. Limits on THC, licensed cultivators can address concerns. Awareness of the difference between recreational cannabis is needed.

Argument For and Against Legalization 

  • For: Tradition of use; regulated medicinal/commercial use allowed; economy, jobs; tax source. 
  • Against: Risk of misuse, addiction, social problems; challenges for law enforcement.

Global Experience: Lessons for India

  • Facts: Canada and the US legalized recreational cannabis. Medicinals are allowed in many nations. India is not ready for recreational use given social factors.
  • Learn from Uruguay (govt controlled cannabis market), and Colorado (the first state to legalize recreational use; $1.5bn in cannabis sales in 2019). Strict regulations on cultivation, sale, and use.
  • Alternative to the illegal black market if regulated. But risks of over-commercialization, corporate cannabis. Balanced policy approach for society's well-being.

Hemp cultivation is reasonable for the economy, and regulated medicinal/commercial uses given tradition, and potential. But risks around illicit narcotics require close oversight and control. Policies must ensure benefits outweigh the costs to society and the environment.

Awareness, and responsibility key to gain public trust. With guidelines, hemp can drive the rural economy, and livelihoods sustainably. The policy intervention requires nuanced thinking considering both pros and cons. With strict oversight and responsibility, regulated hemp cultivation may benefit livelihoods and the state economy. But it calls for a cautious, balanced approach given social and health factors.

Tetrahydrocannabinol

  • Tetrahydrocannabinol or THC is the main psychoactive compound found in cannabis plants like marijuana and hemp. 
  • THC acts on specific receptors in the brain called cannabinoid receptors. It produces a high sense of euphoria by influencing the release of dopamine in the brain.
  • The amount of THC determines how strong the psychoactive effects of cannabis will be. Cannabis plants are often bred to have high THC content to produce greater highs. Products with higher THC can cause more mind-altering effects.
  • THC in large amounts can lead to negative health effects like memory and cognition problems, risk of addiction, anxiety, and psychosis. However, in controlled amounts, THC may have certain medical benefits like relieving chronic pain, nausea from chemotherapy, appetite loss, etc.
  • THC acts much faster when cannabis is smoked compared to when it is eaten. Smoking delivers THC to the brain within seconds. Edibles take 30 minutes to 2 hours as THC is absorbed through the digestive tract. This can often lead to the overconsumption of edibles.
  • THC is fat-soluble, meaning it binds to fatty molecules in the body. So, it can accumulate in the body's fatty tissues and organs over multiple uses. It may remain detectable in urine for 3 to 7 days after use. In hair, it can be detected for months.
  • The legal status of THC depends on its source and concentration. Marijuana and marijuana-derived products with high THC content are illegal under federal law in most countries. However, some countries and states have legalized the recreational or medical use of marijuana with limits on THC. Hemp and its derivatives with very low THC (less than 0.3%) are legal in many places.
  • Synthetic THC compounds like SPICE or K2 act on the same cannabinoid receptors as THC but often have more potent and undesired side effects. They are illegal for recreational use in most countries.

Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985

The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 or NDPS Act is an act of the Parliament of India which prohibits persons from producing/manufacturing, possessing, selling, purchasing, transporting, storing, and/or consuming any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance.

Key provisions of the NDPS Act:

  • It consolidates and amends the law relating to narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances and precursor chemicals and provides stringent punishments for violations.
  • It aims to fulfil India's obligations under various international conventions on narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances. India is a party to the Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs 1961, the Convention on Psychotropic Substances 1971 and United Nations Convention Against Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances 1988.
  • It prohibits cultivation, possession, sale, purchase, transport, storage, or consumption of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances except for medical and scientific purposes.
  • It includes control over precursor chemicals, essential chemicals that are used in the production of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, to prevent their diversion.
  • It provides for the forfeiture of properties and assets derived from or involved in illicit traffic and also includes provisions for the treatment and rehabilitation of addicts.
  • Offences under the Act are cognizable and non-bailable. Stringent punishments including imprisonment up to 20 years or even life imprisonment, and fines up to Rs.2 lakh or more have been prescribed under the Act for violations.
  • Enforcement is carried out by narcotics control authorities under the Department of Revenue, Government of India coordinated by the Narcotics Control Bureau. Preventive detention is allowed under the Act.
  • It also includes provisions for mutual legal assistance with other countries in cases related to narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances.

Amendments to NDPS act

  • NDPS (Amendment) Act, 1988: It enhanced penalties for certain offences under the Act and also included additional substances under its purview.
  • NDPS (Amendment) Act, 1989: It further enhanced penalties and included more substances. It amended Section 9 of the Act to authorize officers of DRI and above the rank of Inspector to investigate offences under NDPS Act.
  • NDPS (Amendment) Act, 2001: It provided for precursors of narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances to be regulated and controlled. It also included forfeiture of illegally acquired property under the Act.
  • NDPS (Amendment) Act, 2014: Some key changes were:
    • Only officers of gazetted rank can investigate cases.
    • Punishment for financing illicit trafficking and harbouring offenders was prescribed.
    • Period of limitation to file an appeal increased from 30 to 60 days.
    • Power to freeze or seize illegally acquired properties provided.
    • Fast track courts for speedy trials were constituted.
    • Punishment for repeat offenders was enhanced.
    • Officers not below Deputy SP rank can investigate offences.
  • NDPS (Amendment) Bill, 2019: It aims to amend NDPS Act 1985 to improve India’s compliance with international conventions on narcotic drugs and make offences under the Act more stringent. Key proposals:
    • List of drugs/narcotics is proposed to be updated. New psychotropic substances are intended to be added.
    • Definitions of certain terms like ‘narcotic drug’ and 'psychotropic substance' are proposed to be expanded. 
    • Punishments proposed to be made stricter for cultivating, producing, manufacturing, possessing, selling, purchasing, transporting, importing or exporting narcotic drugs.  
    • Prosecution of directors/partners/proprietors of companies/ partnerships/ proprietorship proposed for offences by company/partnership/proprietorship.
    • Control of precursor chemicals used to produce narcotic drugs proposed to be strengthened. 

The NDPS Bill 2019 is still pending. The amendments over the years have aimed at tightening the NDPS Act provisions and increasing compliance with India's international obligations.

Major Criticisms of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act 1985

  • Harsh and disproportionate punishments: The NDPS Act provides for stringent punishments like a minimum of 10 years of imprisonment for possession of small quantities of drugs for personal consumption. Critics argue that this is disproportionate and harsh. It leads to overcrowding in prisons and hampers the rehabilitation of offenders.
  • Ambiguous definitions: Definitions of certain terms like 'narcotic drug' and 'psychotropic substance' under the Act are very broad. This gives wide discretion to law enforcement agencies and can lead to misuse. The Act also does not clearly distinguish between drug users/addicts and traffickers.
  • Lack of focus on harm reduction: The NDPS Act focuses more on deterrence through harsh punishments rather than harm reduction. It does not have adequate provisions for the rehabilitation of drug dependents. The Act takes a punitive approach rather than seeing drug addiction as a public health issue.
  • Encourages corruption: The NDPS Act encourages corruption among law enforcers as they have been given wide powers with little accountability. Harsh punishments also incentivize bribery to escape imprisonment.
  • Disproportionate impact on marginalized groups: The NDPS Act has a disproportionate impact on marginalized groups like the poor, minorities and youth. They are more prone to drug abuse due to disadvantaged backgrounds but the criminal justice system is more likely to target them.
  • Undermines right to privacy: Wide powers given to law enforcers under NDPS Act in conducting raids, searches and seizures can violate the right to privacy of individuals. Powers of arrest and detention also undermine civil liberties.
  • Does not curb drug problem: Despite the stringent provisions, the NDPS Act has failed to effectively curb the drug menace in India. Drug trafficking and abuse continue to rise. So, there is a need to rethink the punitive approach in tackling this issue.

These are some of the major criticisms of the NDPS Act that point to the need for reforms in India's anti-narcotics legal framework and policies. The NDPS Act needs to take a balanced approach focusing on harm reduction and decriminalization of certain offenses.

If Governor withholds nod, it means Bill is dead

Context:  Recently, Tamil Nadu Governor said that if a Governor withholds assent to a Bill passed by the Assembly, it means the “Bill is dead”. 

More about the news:

The Supreme Court has defined withholding assent as the Bill falls through, the Bill is dead.

Under Article 200, once a Bill has been passed by the State Legislature, then the Governor has three options:

 1. Either he assents to the Bill; or

 2. He withholds assent therefrom; or 

 3. Reserves the Bill for the consideration of the President.

  •  The Governor as soon as possible shall return the Bill for the consideration of the House with his message as to what provisions of the Bill should be reconsidered by the Assembly. Now, the term “as soon as possible” has not been defined. 
  • Now, when the Bill is so returned, the Assembly shall reconsider the Bill and look into the suggestions or messages of the Governor regarding any specific provision. 
  • However, if the Bill is passed again by the House or Houses with or without amendment and presented to the Governor for assent, the Governor shall not withhold assent therefrom. 
  • The Governor does not have discretion on matters of the Assembly and is bound to follow the advice of his Council of Ministers even on matters where he/she might be withholding assent.
  • Provided further that the Governor shall not assent to, but shall reserve for the consideration of the President, any Bill which in the opinion of the Governor would, if it became law, so derogate from the powers of the High Court as to endanger the position which that Court is by this Constitution designed to fill. 
  • In the entire provision of Article 200, no time frame as such has been provided. So, if the Bill is even reserved for the President’s Assent, then he is not time bound to accept or reject the Bill.

Is the president bound to accept or reject the bill which is reserved for president under Article 201? 

Article 201- Bills reserved for President’s consideration 

  • When a Bill is reserved by a Governor for the consideration of the President, the President shall declare either that he assents to the Bill or that he withholds assent therefrom.
  • Provided that, where the Bill is not a Money Bill - the President may direct the Governor to return the Bill to the House or Houses of the Legislature of the State together with such a message as is mentioned in the first proviso to article 200. 
  • And when a Bill is so returned, the House or Houses shall reconsider it accordingly within a period of six months from the date of receipt of such message and, 
  • if it is again passed by the House or Houses with or without amendment, it shall be presented again to the President for his consideration. 

Note - Even under Article 201, no time limit has been provided under which the President has to assent or reject the Bill once the Governor reserve the Bill for President’s Assent.

The Article ends with the words that the Bill shall again be presented again to the President for his consideration. But what happens after the Bill is presented again has not been mentioned. So, technically, the President is not time bound to assent or reject the Bill which is sent again for his consideration and the Bill can be delayed.

The Supreme Court order in Shamser Singh vs State of Punjab (1975) that “the constitutional conclusion is that the Governor is but a shorthand expression for the State government and the President is an abbreviation of the Central government.”

Motivated PILs pose grave danger to credibility of the judicial process

What is Public Interest Litigation (PIL) 

PIL has not been defined in any Indian statute. However, Courts have interpreted and defined PIL. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has, in the case of Janata Dal v. H.S.Chaudhary 1993, held that the expression ‘PIL’  means a legal action started in a court of law for the enforcement of public/general interest where the public or a particular class of the public some interest (including pecuniary interest) that affects their legal rights or liabilities.

Source of PIL

  • American law was the source of the term "public interest litigation," which was intended to provide legal representation to previously unrepresented groups such as the disadvantaged, members of racial minorities, unorganized consumers, and individuals who were enthusiastic about environmental issues, among others.

Who Can File a PIL?

  • Under Article 32 of the Indian Constitution, in the supreme court, Article 226 in the High Court, and Section 133 of the Criminal Procedure Code in the magistrate court, any citizen can file a public case by filing a petition. 
  • However, the petitioner must prove to the court's satisfaction that the petition is being filed in the public interest and not as a frivolous litigation by a busybody. The court may take cognizance of the matter and proceed with Suo motu, or any public-spirited individual may file a petition.
  • The concept of “Locus Standi” has been relaxed in the case of PILs so as to enable the Hon’ble Court to look into grievances that are filed on behalf of those who are poor, illiterate, deprived or disabled and are unable to approach the courts themselves.
  • A PIL can only be brought against the Central, state, or municipal governments and not against any individual. The Governmental and Parliament of India, each State's Government and Legislature, and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India are all included in the definition of a state.

Genesis and evolution 

  • In the case of Mumbai Kamagar Sabha vs. Abdul Thai case, 1976, Justice Krishna Iyer laid the groundwork for the concept of public interest litigation in India.
  • Hussainara Khatoon vs. State of Bihar (1979), which focused on the inhumane conditions of prisons and under-trial prisoners and resulted in the release of more than 40,000 under-trial prisoners, was the first PIL case to be reported. These prisoners had been denied the fundamental right to speedy justice.
  • A new era of the PIL movement was heralded by Justice P.N. Bhagawati in the case of S.P. Gupta v. Union of India. In this case it was held that any member of the public or social action group acting bonafide can invoke the Writ Jurisdiction of the High Courts or the Supreme Court seeking redressal against violation of a legal or constitutional rights of persons who due to social or economic or any other disability cannot approach the Court. 
  • In 1981 the case of Anil Yadav v. State of Bihar, exposed the brutalities of the Police. Newspaper report revealed that about 33 suspected criminals were blinded by the police in Bihar by putting the acid into their eyes. Through interim orders Supreme Court directed the State government to bring the blinded men to Delhi for medical treatment. It also ordered speedy prosecution of the guilty policemen. The court also read right to free legal aid as a fundamental right of every accused. Anil Yadav signalled the growth of social activism and investigative litigation.
  • In 1982, the Supreme Court in its far- reaching decision in the case of PUDR People's Union for Democratic Rights vs. Union of India, it recognised that a third party could directly petition, whether through a letter or other means, the Court and seek its intervention in a matter where another party's fundamental rights were being violated. In this case, adverting to the Constitutional prohibition on begar, or forced labor and traffic in human beings, PUDR submitted that workers contracted to build the large sports complex at the Asian Game Village in Delhi were being exploited.
  • The Supreme Court in Indian Banks' Association, Bombay and ors v. M/s Devkala Consultancy Service and Ors, held that In an appropriate case, where the petitioner might have moved a court in her private interest and for redressal of the personal grievance, the court in furtherance of Public Interest may treat it a necessity to enquire into the state of affairs of the subject of litigation in the interest of justice. Thus a private interest case can also be treated as public interest case.
  • In the case of M.C Mehta v/s Union of India 1987 - In a Public Interest Litigation brought against Ganga water pollution so as to prevent any further pollution of Ganga water. Supreme court held that petitioner although not a riparian owner is entitled to move the court for the enforcement of statutory provisions , as he is the person interested in protecting the lives of the people who make use of Ganga water.

Significance of PIL 

  • Affordable legal remedy - In Public Interest Litigation (PIL) vigilant citizens of the country can find an inexpensive legal remedy because there is only a nominal fixed court fee involved in this.
  • Accessibility of justice - This is done by relaxing the traditional rule of locus standi. Any public spirited citizen or social action group can approach the court on behalf of the oppressed classes.
  • Addressing larger public issues - through the so-called PIL, the litigants can focus attention on and achieve results pertaining to larger public issues, especially in the fields of human rights, consumer welfare and environment.
  • Instrument of social change - PIL is working as an important instrument of social change. It is working for the welfare of every section of society. PIL has been used as a strategy to combat the atrocities prevailing in society. It’s an institutional initiative towards the welfare of the needy class of the society. In Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan Supreme court has laid down exhaustive guidelines for preventing sexual harassment of working women in place of their work.
  • Monitoring of state institutions - such as jails, women’s protective homes, juvenile homes, mental asylums, and the like. Through judicial invigilation, the court seeks gradual improvement in their management and administration.
  • Checks and balances – Provides a tool in the hands of the judiciary along with enhanced participation of the public to keep tab on executive and administrative actions.
  • Devising new kind of reliefs and techniques of fact finding - By fashioning new kinds of reliefs under the court’s writ jurisdiction. For example, the court can award interim compensation to the victims of governmental lawlessness. In most of the cases the court has appointed its own socio-legal commissions of inquiry or has deputed its own official for investigation. Sometimes it has taken the help of National Human Rights Commission or Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) or experts to inquire into human rights violations.

Challenges 

  • Disturbing the constitutional balance of power- Although the Indian Constitution does not follow any strict separation of power, it still embodies the doctrine of checks and balances, which even the judiciary should respect. However, the judiciary on several occasions did not exercise self-restraint and moved on to legislate, settle policy questions, take over governance, or monitor executive agencies.
  • Frivolous use - PIL has become a tool for harassment as a result of the large number of insignificant cases that are filed by people with the minimal court fee. Numerous false PILs have been filed to obtain publicity for unworthy causes. Even chief justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud noted that PIL has become tool for harassment and several experts are of opinion that the letter ‘P’ has been substituted for publicity and private as against the original intention of Public.
  • Primacy to PIL cases over other cases - The debates over the limits of Judicial Activism in the area of PIL, have been vigorous. A private members bill entitled “Public Interest Litigation (Regulation) Bill, 1996” was tabled in the Rajya Sabha. The statement of objectives and reasons stated that PIL was misused in the name of providing justice to the poor sections of the society and also that PIL cases were given more priority over other cases which led to pending of several “general section cases” in the court for years. However, the bill was not passed.
  • Pendency of PIL cases - Adjudication takes several years as PIL cases further aggravate the challenges of already burdened judiciary.
  • Overuse-induced non-seriousness- PIL should not be the first step in redressing all kinds of grievances even if they involve public interest. In order to remain effective, PIL should not be allowed to become a routine affair which is not taken seriously by the Bench, the Bar, and most importantly by the masses. The overuse of PIL for every conceivable public interest might dilute the original commitment to use this remedy only for enforcing human rights of the victimised and the disadvantaged groups. If civil society and disadvantaged groups lose faith in the efficacy of PIL, that would sound a death knell for it.

Conclusion

PIL has an important role to play in the civil justice system in that it affords a ladder to justice to disadvantaged sections of society, some of which might not even be well-informed about their rights. Furthermore, it provides an avenue to enforce diffused rights for which either it is difficult to identify an aggrieved person or where aggrieved persons have no incentives to knock at the doors of the courts. PIL could also contribute to good governance by keeping the government accountable. Last but not least, PIL enables civil society to play an active role in spreading social awareness about human rights, in providing voice to the marginalized sections of society, and in allowing their participation in government decision making.

Plausible solution lies in introspection and exercise of rationality by the various stake holders. Firstly judiciary must exercise caution and restrain while entertaining the PILs , i.e. PILs should be admitted only when they comply with the guidelines of the SC. Frivolous PILs should be discouraged and penalised. There is need for sensitization of the lawyers and social activists too. Last but not least executive inaction creates space for such judicial activism so if the concern is blurring of the separation of power, executive must also act proactively.

Grant of bail: the question of delay, even in-laws like the NDPS Act

Context: Recently SC held that undue delay in the trial can be a ground for granting bail to an accused even under the stringent Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act.

What is bail?

  • The CrPC does not define the word bail but only categorizes offences under the Indian Penal Code as ‘bailable’ and ‘non-bailable’.
  • But in general, Bail is defined as the conditional release of a person accused of a crime, for an amount, pledged for the appearance of the accused when the same is due in court.  
  • The CrPC empowers magistrates to grant bail for bailable offences as a matter of right. This would involve release on furnishing a bail bond, with or without security.
  • Non-bailable offences are cognisable, which enables the police officer to arrest without a warrant. In such cases, a magistrate would determine if the accused is fit to be released on bail.

Types of Bail in India

There are three types of bail in India-

Regular bail:  

  •  Regular bail is the release of an accused from custody to ensure his presence at the trial in a non-bailable offence.

Interim bail:

  • This bail is granted as a temporary means and granted for a short period, either during the time of pendency of an application or when the application of anticipatory or regular bail is pending before the court.
  • It is always conditional and can be extended

Anticipatory bail:

  • Anticipatory bail is self-defining.
  • It is a type of bail that is given to someone who is in anticipation of getting arrested for a non-bailable offence by the police.
  • A person who has been granted anticipatory bail cannot be arrested by the police.

Conditions governing bail in a bailable offence:

  • Section 436(1) of Cr.P.C.  lays down the conditions under which bail can be granted for bailable offences committed under the Indian Penal Code (1862).
  • Whenever a person is arrested or detained by police for any non-bailable offence is produced before the court and is prepared to give bail, he may be released on bail.

Conditions governing bail in a non-bailable offence:

  • Section 437 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,1973 states that bail can also be granted for committing non-bailable offences.
  • However, here the discretion is that of the Court and the accused cannot claim it as a matter of right.

Conditions governing bail in anticipation of arrest:

  • Section 438 of the CrPC lays down the procedures for getting bail in anticipation of arrest for a non-bailable offence.
  • The provision was incorporated as per the recommendation of the report of the 41st Law Commission.
  • There should be an element of apprehension, i.e. the person seeking bail feels that he will be framed or arrested in a false case or someone having enmity with him will try to get him arrested on the pretext on a fabricated charge.
  • Anticipatory bail can be granted only by a High Court or a Court of Sessions.

Other conditions affecting the grant of anticipatory bail:

  • The person concerned will have to make himself available for interrogation by the police.
  • He shall not make any direct or indirect inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case.
  • He will not leave the country without the prior permission of the court.

Bail Reforms Required in India

  • Grant of bail should not depend on the sections in which a person is charged, i.e., on the nature and gravity of the offence (which is yet to be proved), but it should be evidence-based and the careful understanding of the judge as to the probability of the accused committing the offence.
  • Revamping the system of arrest. The system should be made more rational, fair and transparent. For this, Section 41 of Cr.P.C. should be amended.
  • All statutes and laws should emphasize the principle of ‘innocence unless proven guilty’ and should be amended to the extent required.
  • Requirement of bond or security can be rationalised to avail bail to poor
  • Section 436A of the Cr.P.C. needs further reforms to deal with under-trials.
  • This is a gross crime against humanity that can never be rectified.
  • Ensure speedy justice.
  • A separate law for bail as recommended by SC.
  • Bail can be granted without a Bail application.

SC quashes ban on media one

Context: Court lifts telecast ban on Malayalam channel Media One; says unguided and ad hoc use of sealed covers infringes natural justice and open justice.

More on news: The Supreme Court rapped the government for silencing voices in the media who “speak truth to power” by branding them “anti-establishment”, as well as for the state’s “unguided and ad hoc” use of sealed covers in courts to outsmart citizens’ rights to personal liberty, life and profession.

Observations of Supreme Court

  • The critical views about government policies cannot be termed anti-establishment. The use of such a terminology betrays an expectation that the Press must support the establishment.
  • An independent Press is vital for the robust functioning of the democratic republic. 
  • The Press has a duty to speak truth to power and present citizens with hard facts.
  • A homogenised view on issues that range from socio-economic polity to political ideologies will present grave dangers to democracy.
  • State’s “unguided and ad hoc” use of sealed covers in courts to outsmart citizens’ rights to personal liberty, life and profession.

Public interest immunity (PII) 

  • Though recognising the top court’s power to “secure confidential material in a sealed cover” under Rule 7 of the Supreme Court Rules of 2013, the CJI noted that the state’s frequent reliance on sealed covers to validate its actions in courts had reduced constitutional rights and procedural guarantees of a fair hearing under the law to a “dry parchment”.
  • The Supreme Court then evolved the “less restrictive” public interest immunity (PII) claims proceedings as an “alternative” to the sealed cover proceedings while dealing with state requests for confidentiality.
  • Under the alternative PII proceedings, the court would test the relevance of the material the state desires to be kept confidential in ‘public interest’. The court would appoint an amicus curiae in order to “balance the concerns of confidentiality with the need to preserve public confidence in the objectivity of the justice delivery system”.
  • Though the PII proceedings would be a “closed sitting”, a reasoned order, allowing or dismissing the PII claim of the state, should be pronounced in open court. Even if the PII claim is successful, the court could opt to redact confidential portions of the document or provide both parties with a summary of the contents of the documents.
  • While PII claims proceedings conceivably impacts the principles of natural justice, sealed cover proceedings infringe the principles of natural justice and open justice

Right to life, liberty and profession Vs Confidentiality 

  • SC questioned the government’s view that it could investigate or collect intelligence on citizens and later claim blanket immunity from disclosure in court.
  • SC observed that “Intelligence agencies’ reports impact the life, liberty and profession of individuals and entities, and to give such reports absolute immunity from disclosure is antithetical to a transparent and accountable system.
  • SC reasoned that the argument that intelligence reports may contain confidential information is one thing, but to argue that all such reports are confidential is another. Such an argument is misplaced and cannot be accepted on the touchstone of constitutional values.

Principle of natural Justice

Principles of natural justice refer to the basic principles that are required to be followed while making a decision or taking any action. These principles aim to ensure that the decision-making process is fair, unbiased, and transparent. The following are the key principles of natural justice:

  • Audi alteram partem - The right to be heard: This principle means that both parties should be given a fair opportunity to present their case before a decision is made. It also includes the right to cross-examine witnesses and evidence.
  • Nemo judex in causa sua - No one should be a judge in his own cause: This principle requires that the decision-maker should be impartial and not have any personal interest or bias in the matter.
  • Impartiality: The decision-maker should be unbiased and impartial towards the parties involved in the decision-making process. The decision should be based solely on the facts and evidence presented before them.
  • Natural justice demands that a person should be informed of the charges against them and should have the opportunity to respond to those charges.
  • The decision should be based on relevant and admissible evidence.
  • The decision should be communicated in writing and should include the reasons for the decision.
  • Bias: Any actual or perceived bias on the part of the decision-maker can render the decision invalid.
  • The decision should be proportionate and reasonable.
  • Confidentiality: The decision-making process should be confidential to protect the privacy of the parties involved.
  • Evidence: Only admissible evidence should be considered while making a decision.

Principle of open justice 

Open justice is the principle that legal proceedings should be open and transparent to the public. It is a fundamental principle of the legal system in many countries and is considered essential to the rule of law. The following are the key aspects of open justice:

  • Public access to court proceedings: Open justice requires that court proceedings are open to the public, unless there are compelling reasons to restrict access. This means that anyone can attend court hearings and access court documents, subject to certain restrictions, such as protecting the privacy of vulnerable witnesses.
  • Transparency: Open justice also requires that court proceedings are conducted in a transparent manner, with the reasons for the court's decisions being explained to the parties involved and the public. This includes providing written judgments and reasons for decisions, which should be made available to the public.
  • Accountability: Open justice promotes accountability, by allowing the public to see how decisions are made and how justice is administered. This can help to maintain public confidence in the legal system and ensure that judges and other decision-makers are held accountable for their actions.
  • Fairness: Open justice promotes fairness, by ensuring that all parties to a legal proceeding have an equal opportunity to present their case and that the decision-making process is conducted in an impartial and transparent manner.
  • Media access: Open justice also allows the media to report on court proceedings, subject to certain restrictions, such as protecting the privacy of vulnerable witnesses. This allows the public to be informed about legal proceedings and helps to promote accountability and transparency.
  • Exceptions: Although open justice is a fundamental principle of the legal system, there are some exceptions, such as cases involving national security, confidential information, or the privacy of vulnerable individuals. In such cases, restrictions on public access may be necessary to protect the interests of justice.

Overall, open justice is an essential principle of the legal system, promoting transparency, accountability, and fairness. It helps to ensure that the legal system is accessible to all and that justice is administered in a transparent and impartial manner.

Point of order

Context: Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar rejected a point of order raised
by Opposition leader Mallikarjun Kharge against Union Minister and Leader of the
House Piyush Goyal for his speech in the House targeting Congress leader Rahul
Gandhi.

What is the point of Order? 

  • The Lok Sabha Secretariat describes a Point of order as “an extraordinary process which, when raised, has the effect of suspending the proceedings before the House.
  • Point of order concerns the procedure and business of the House and the rule book says that “it should relate to arrangement of items already included in the List of Business for the day".
  • Raising a point of order is “meant to assist the Speaker in enforcing the rules, directions and provisions of the Constitution for regulating the business of the House”.
  • Thus, it can concern both the application of the rules of the House and even any principles enshrined in the Constitution.
  • The procedure vis-a-vis a point of order is covered by Rule 376 of the Lok Sabha rules and by Rule 258 in Rajya Sabha.

When is it raised? 

  • The point of order is concerned with rules of procedure vis-a-vis “a breach of order or a transgression of any written or unwritten law of the House", a wide range of issues can be flagged under a point of order.
  • Further, the test whether a point raised is a point of order or not is not whether the Chair can give any relief but whether it involves such interpretation or enforcement of the rules, etc. and whether it raises a point which the Chair alone can decide.
  • But there are also issues involved with Point of order as it is “one of the most vexatious parliamentary practices which confronts a presiding officer" as the practice “raises real problems for the presiding officer".
  • This is because, unlike the procedures for raising questions or flagging issues in Parliament, most of which involve the giving of prior notice by a member or seeking the presiding officer’s permission, a point of order does not need prior notice and is supposed to receive precedence over any matter that the House may be dealing with right then.

The problem for the presiding officer lies in the fact that, until he hears at least a substantial part of a member’s submission, he (the Chair) is not in a position to rule that it is not a point of order.

How is it raised? 

  • To raise a point of order, a member has just to stand up and say ‘Point of Order’, whereupon she or he has to be first identified by the presiding officer.
  • The member should elaborate on his/her concern only after being identified by the presiding officer. “While formulating her/his point of order, the member should quote the specific rule or the provision of the Constitution relating to the procedure of the House which may have been ignored or neglected or violated.
  • Further it should be noted that a point of order cannot be raised during the Question Hour, or when the House is taking up any motion.
  • It may not be used for a member to ask for information, or to explain her/his position, etc.
  • Also, a point of order regarding an item of business cannot be raised after such business has been disposed of.

Thus it can be concluded that a point of order must refer to procedure and not substantive arguments on a motion.

What happens when it is raised? 

  • The moment a point of order is raised by one member, “the member who is speaking at that time must give way and resume his seat" and it “has the effect of suspending the proceedings before the House".
  • It is the presiding officer who decides whether “a point raised is a point of order or not". No debate is allowed on a point of order, but the presiding officer may hear the member before giving her/his decision.

Vacancies of judges remain high, cases pile up: India Justice Report

Context: The India Justice Report 2022, says that Indian courts are jammed with cases and are seeing pendency increase by the day. At the same time, they are also functioning with fewer judges than the sanctioned number.

India Justice Report

  • The India Justice Report is a first of its kind national periodic reporting that brings together, hitherto siloed information, to measure the capacity of four pillars of the justice system - the police, the prison system, the judiciary and legal aid—in each state.
  • The report is the result of collaboration and research between six organisations:
  • Centre for Social Justice (IDEAL)
  • Common Cause
  • Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI)
  • DAKSH
  • TISS–Prayas
  • Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy

Findings of this report 

  • Against a sanctioned strength of 1,108 judges, the High Courts were functioning with only 778 judges. 
  • The subordinate courts were found functioning with 19,288 judges against a sanctioned strength of 24,631 judges.
  • The number of cases pending per judge is rising in most States over the past five years.
o9ZhdjQ9 aAhsMeZlPm9e aQj9hkU9YAEWi3QZTxDyibvQfE tAjzQnn7N8UDcXiR maoJ0JCMfDAzbqUGvKaxRHIF3PEvOrdtbBRcqwtk5NMXY1L0UaS0miqmrEHGLoOUqWuqY
  • The report found that the High Courts are clearing more cases annually than the subordinate courts.

Challenges Pertaining to Indian Judicial System

  • Pendency – One of the essential issues with the Indian legal framework is the pendency of cases. 2.84 crore cases are pending in the subordinate courts, the backlog clogging the High Courts and Supreme Court (SC) is 43 lakh and 57,987 cases, respectively.
  • Vacancy -  There is persistent tussle between the executive and the judiciary over the appointment of Judges of the Supreme court and the High Courts. This has resulted into unwarranted vacancies which further accentuates the issue of pendency. As per the India Justice Report of 2022 Against a sanctioned strength of 1,108 judges, the High Courts were functioning with only 778 judges.
  • Lack of transparency - Judiciary does not come under the ambit of the Right to the Information Act. In the functioning of the Indian judiciary system, the substantial issues like the quality of justice and accountability are not known to the citizens properly. There is also a need for transparency in the appointment of the judges.
  • Lack of interaction and information among people and court - For any Judiciary to be fruitful, it is vital that the overall population must know the mechanics of legal. The general public must take part in the court procedures. Indian Judiciary system lacks such linkages and interactions. 
  • Less use of technology – Indian courts have exhibited less use of technology in their functioning. Considering the quantum of work, this non-inclusion of technology in their working further complicates the matters.

Way Forward

  • Need to Reduce Disposal Time for Cases - Disposal time is measured as the time span between the date of filing and the date when the decision is passed.
  • Need to better Case Clearance Rate (CCR) - CCR is the ratio of the number of cases disposed of each year to the number of cases instituted in that year, expressed as a percentage. It is mainly used to understand the efficiency of the system in proportion to the inflow of cases.
  • Streamline Judicial Appointments – by identifying vacancies across sections of lower and higher judiciary.
  • Shifting Court workloads through creating Special Courts (255th Law Commission) – based on specialised areas such as commercial cases can be transferred to the commercial division and the commercial appellate division of High Courts. Similarly Special Courts within High Courts can be set up to address litigations pertaining to land, crime, Traffic Challans etc.
  • Merge and rationalize tribunals to enhance efficiency - Appointments to tribunals must be streamlined either through a specialized agency or under the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT).
  • Need to Create Separate Administrative Cadre in the judicial system – This will relieve the Judges who are also involved in administrative capabilities to take care of the day to day functioning of High Courts as well as Lower Courts under Article 227. Problem – Handling administrative responsibilities by Judges reduce time available for dispensing cases pending in the Courts.
  • Creating Indian Courts and Tribunal Services (ICTS) – It will focus on the administrative aspects of the legal system. The major roles to be played by ICTS will be provide administrative support functions needed by the judiciary; identify process inefficiencies and advise the judiciary on legal reforms
  • Creating All-India Judicial Services - merit based all India examination to appoint Judges for Higher Judiciary as per Article 312(3) which was added by the Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976.
  • Increase number of working days for judiciary to increase productivity – reducing length of summer and winter vacations in High Courts and Supreme Court.
  • Deployment of Technology to improve efficiency of Courts - One major effort in this direction is the eCourts Mission Mode Project that is being rolled out in phases by the Ministry of Law and Justice. This has allowed the creation of the National Judicial Data Grid (NJDG). The system is already able to capture most cases, their status and progress.
  • Appointing More Women Judges at all levels – will promote women empowerment and make judgments involving cases of women more gender sensitive.

How to combat corruption in India

What corruption is?

Corruption refers to the abuse of power or position for personal gain, typically involving bribery or dishonest behaviour. It involves the use of one's public or private office for personal benefit or the benefit of a group to which one belongs, rather than for the public interest or common good. Corruption can take many forms, including accepting or offering bribes, embezzlement, nepotism, fraud, and other illegal or unethical activities. Corruption undermines democratic processes, weakens the rule of law, and harms economic and social development.

Much evidence indicates that corruption has been around for thousands of years, but in recent years it has attracted increasing attention. Does the attention reflect an increasing awareness or an increasing scope of the problem? Probably, corruption has increased in recent decades. Actions can be taken to reduce corruption, but the fight against it cannot be seen independently from the need to reform the role of the state. The reason is that a certain role of the state almost inevitably creates a fertile ground for corruption.

Defining Corruption

  • Corruption is a term of many meanings, but at the broadest level, corruption is the misuse of office for unofficial ends. Office is a position of duty, or should be; the office-holder is supposed to put the interests of the institution and the people first.
  • Corruption can go beyond bribery to include nepotism, neglect of duty and favouritism. Corrupt acts can involve third parties outside the organisation (in transactions with clients and citizens, such as extortion and bribery) or be internal to an organisation (theft, embezzlement, some types of fraud). Corruption can occur in government, business, civil society organisations and international agencies. Each of these varieties has the dimension of scale, from episodic to systemic.

V.S. Naipaul, the Trinidad-born Nobel Prize winner, once noted that underdevelopment is characterised by a duplicitous emphasis on honorific titles and simultaneously the abuse of those titles: judges who love to be called “your honour” even as they accept bribes, civil servants who are uncivil and serve themselves.

Categories of corruption

  • Bribery: The act of dishonestly persuading someone to act in one’s favour by a payment or other inducement. Inducements can take the form of gifts, loans, fees, rewards or other advantages (taxes, services, donations, etc.). The use of bribes can lead to collusion (e.g. inspectors under-reporting offences in exchange for bribes) and/or extortion (e.g. bribes extracted against the threat of over-reporting).
  • Embezzlement: To steal, misdirect or misappropriate funds or assets placed in one’s trust or under one’s control. From a legal point of view, embezzlement need not necessarily be or involve corruption. Facilitation payment A small payment, also called a “speed” or “grease” payment, made to secure or expedite the performance of a routine or necessary action to which the payer has legal or other entitlement.
  • Fraud: The act of intentionally and dishonestly deceiving someone in order to gain an unfair or illegal advantage (financial, political or otherwise).
  • Collusion: An arrangement between two or more parties designed to achieve an improper purpose, including influencing improperly the actions of another party.
  • Extortion: The act of impairing or harming, or threatening to impair or harm, directly or indirectly, any party or the property of the party to influence improperly the actions of a party.
  • Patronage, clientelism and nepotism: Patronage at its core means the support given by a patron. In government, it refers to the practice of appointing people directly.

What are the major causes of corruption?

Corruption is a phenomenon with many faces. It is characterised by a range of economic, political, administrative, social and cultural factors, both domestic and international in nature. Corruption is not an innate form of behaviour, but rather a symptom of wider dynamics. It results from interactions, opportunities, strengths and weaknesses in socio-political systems. It opens up and closes down spaces for individuals, groups, organisations and institutions that populate civil society, the state, the public sector and the private sector. It is, above all, the result of dynamic relationships between multiple actors.

Principal-agent

  • A principal-agent problem exists when one party to a relationship (the principal) requires a service of another party (the agent) but the principal lacks the necessary information to monitor the agent’s performance in an effective way.
  • The “information asymmetry” that arises because the agent has more or better information than the principal creates a power imbalance between the two and makes it difficult for the principal to ensure the agent’s compliance.
    • So, for instance, public servants or elected officials (who in this case would both be the agents) may be able to abuse their public office to secure private rents in exchange for public services because members of the public (the “principals” in this case) cannot hold them to account.

States and markets

  • Economic systems where the state is heavily interventionist (India before 1991) are also more prone to corruption.
  • The logic is that large involvement of the state in the economy, especially where checks and balances and wider accountability mechanisms are lacking, allows individual politicians and bureaucrats to manipulate markets as a means of generating profits through non-competitive mechanisms.
  • They use such mechanisms not only to enrich themselves but also to build a basis of patronage and political support.

Weak institutions

  • Weak governance is one of the fundamental causes of corruption. The political and economic opportunities available in different political systems, as well as the strength and effectiveness of state, social and economic, shape the conditions in which corruption can thrive.
  • In particular, the centralisation of power in the executive and in accountability mechanisms that are deficient gives actors (especially elites) too much discretion.

Much of the literature on institutions and corruption argues that corruption tends to be especially prevalent in so-called (neo-)patrimonial systems, where:

  • There is weak separation of the public and private spheres, which results in the widespread private appropriation of public resources;
  • Vertical (e.g. patron–client) and identity-based (e.g. kinship, ethnicity, religion) relationships have primacy over horizontal and rights-based relationships;
  • Politics are organised around personalism or “big man” syndrome, reflected in the high centralisation of power and patron–client relations replicated throughout society.

Neopatrimonialism is a system of social hierarchy where patrons use state resources to secure the loyalty of clients in the general population. It is an informal patron–client relationship that can reach from very high up in state structures down to individuals in small villages.

More generally, it is countries undergoing processes of political and economic transition (because of struggles over sources of accumulation, distribution of access, cost of buying legitimacy, etc.) that are particularly susceptible to corruption.

image 1

Corruption and democracy/electoral competition in Plurality Systems:

  • Overall plurality systems (Like in India) are more candidate-centred, which tends to provide greater incentives for politics based on the allocation of patronage, especially if the systems encourage internal (i.e. within-party) competition among candidates.
  • Are less likely to produce desirable public goods. This is because so-called “pork barrel politics” (or the appropriation of government spending for localised projects secured to benefit a narrow group of citizens often in the politician’s home district) are more prevalent where the electoral system is based on candidate-centred electoral competition and candidates need to differentiate themselves from other candidates.
  • Are more prone to electoral malpractice. This is because, by contrast, parties operating in PR systems parties have a greater incentive to enforce compliance with electoral rules to protect party reputation than in plurality systems, which gives individual candidates greater leeway to manipulate the rules.
  • In addition, under plurality, in a close contest only a small number of votes needs to be manipulated to alter electoral outcomes, whereas a far greater number of votes would need to be altered in PR systems to achieve the same result.

Corruption and natural wealth: the resource curse

  • Ample evidence from across the developing world shows countries rich in natural resources also tend to be highly corrupt and poorly governed, in part because of the dynamics and incentives extractive resources tend to generate for the ruling elites.

Corruption as embedded in social relations

  • First, there is evidence that the public sector in some Sub-Saharan African countries is undergoing a process of “informal privatisation”. Rather than signifying an absence of rules, this process is characterised by an excess of complex de facto norms that are at odds with formal rules and blur the boundaries between licit and illicit practices.
  • Second, the boundaries between corrupt practices and other behaviour or actions are often difficult to define because corruption is situated within wider everyday practices that are not corrupt but often facilitate and legitimise corruption.

What are the major impacts of corruption?

  • Macroeconomic costs of corruption
    • Corruption need not have deleterious effects on growth, with countries that vary considerably in terms of their governance environments equally able to achieve high levels of sustained growth over time.
    • As governance quality increases, corruption becomes more damaging to economic growth.
    • Improved governance quality may be able to mitigate the effects of corruption
  • Microeconomic costs of corruption: firms, efficiency and domestic investments
    • There is a substantial body of evidence assessing the impact of corruption on firm profitability, and on the commercial behaviour and choices of individuals and businesses. The evidence overwhelmingly suggests corruption has negative impacts on productivity, on investment and, overall, on profitability and growth.
  • Corruption, trade and foreign direct investment
    • Just as domestic investors are likely to make decisions about production and investment affected by corrupt business environments, so importers, exporters and foreign investors are likely to amend their commercial calculations based on such factors.
    • Typically, they will have to weigh up the costs of engaging in corrupt activities against the benefits of short-term efficiency and/or longer-term profitability.
  • Corruption and inequality
    • Lower income households and businesses pay a higher proportion of their income in bribes than do middle- or upper-income households: as such, bribes are like a regressive tax, since they must allocate a greater amount of their income than the rich to bribes.
  • Corruption and public services
    • Perceptions of a government as corrupt may reduce tax revenues, in turn affecting the delivery of public services.
    • Corruption reduces not just the total level of public investment but also the quality of services procured.
    • The effects of corruption in public service delivery may have gender-specific effects: where women are unable to generate income, they are particularly vulnerable to shortfalls in public service provision.
  • Corruption, trust and legitimacy
    • Trust in public institutions
      • There is a large and statistically significant negative correlation between corruption and levels of confidence in public institutions.
      • Corruption drives down levels of confidence in public institutions; others suggest lower public confidence increases corrupt practices
    • Corruption and social trust
      • Increased levels of corruption undermine social trust
    • Corruption, fragility and conflict
      • Corruption and political instability is positively correlated.
      • Corruption “has doubly pernicious impacts on the risks of violence, by fuelling grievances and by undermining the effectiveness of national institutions and social norms”.
      • Deeper analysis explores some of the circumstances in which corruption may 1) mitigate for or 2) exacerbate conflict
  • Corruption and the environment
    • Corruption leads to worsened environmental outcomes, such as increased polluting emissions, higher rates of deforestation, increased depletion of natural resources and trafficking in illegal or highly regulated environmental products like wildlife and wood.

What are the measures which can act against corruption?

  • Public financial management
    • Public expenditure tracking: Budget tracking reduces leakage (a proxy indicator for corruption).
    • Procurement: reforms can be effective at reducing corruption.
    • Central budget planning and management: has positive effects on reducing corruption.
  • Supreme audit institutions (SAIs)
    • SAIs carry out audits on government accounts to ensure the proper and effective use of public funds, the proper execution of administrative activities, the development of sound financial management and the satisfactory sharing of information with public authorities and the general public.
  • Direct anti-corruption interventions
    • Anti-corruption authorities (ACAs): are ineffective in curbing corruption, but these are often constrained by a poor data foundation and lack of a systematic approach to evaluating performance.
    • National anti-corruption strategies: Design and implementation are critical to the success of NACSs and warns against a one-size fits-all approach. There is currently no evidence to suggest a NACS adds value above and beyond the constituent reforms and initiatives it aims to pull together and coordinate.
  • Social accountability
    • Social accountability mechanisms are intended to enable citizens to hold public institutions accountable in ways other than the traditional vertical channels (e.g. elections) and horizontal channels (e.g. legislatures, courts and institutional checks and balances) of formal political accountability.
    • It includes a broad range of mechanisms: participatory budgeting; public expenditure tracking (PETS); citizen monitoring of service delivery; information dissemination; and public complaints mechanisms, among others.
    • Transparency, and, linked to this, Access To Information, is generally expected to have a positive impact on corruption control.
    • Freedom of the press can reduce corruption and that the media plays a role in the effectiveness of other social accountability mechanisms.
    • Mobilisation and involvement of civil society organisations (CSOs) helps constrain corruption, although the impact is not always direct and is highly dependent on the conditions within which they operate.
  • Civil service reform
    • Factors accentuating corruption include proliferation of opportunities for corruption linked to economic growth; lack of focus on integrity in recruiting, training, appraising and promoting civil servants; failure to establish a merit-based civil service; and macro-level factors such as general accountability and transparency in the public service.
    • E-government initiatives may help reduce corruption and increase accountability in the civil service.

Overall, the evidence on the conditions under which different types of anti-corruption interventions help effectively reduce corrupt practices (or fail to do so) is mixed, and causal effects are hard to prove. The evidence on contextual factors influencing the effectiveness of anti-corruption reforms is still sparse, although its importance is increasingly being recognised, in particular for social accountability mechanisms. The difficulty of separating contextual factors from reforms, and the complexity of identifying the direction of causality, remains a challenge to clearly identifying contextual factors and their effects on reforms.

"Corruption is like a ball of snow, once it's set a rolling it must increase.

The quote by Charles Caleb Colton suggests that corruption can be a self-perpetuating phenomenon, much like a snowball that grows in size as it rolls downhill. Once corruption starts, it can be difficult to stop or reverse, and it may even become more widespread over time.

This analogy highlights the potential danger of corruption and emphasizes the importance of preventing it from taking root in the first place. By addressing the root causes of corruption and taking steps to promote transparency and accountability, individuals and institutions can help prevent corruption from gaining momentum and becoming a more significant problem.

Poll bonds on sale for 10 days starting from April 3

Electoral Bonds

  • Electoral Bonds are bearer instrument, sort of a Promissory Note and are an interest free banking instrument. 
  • Electoral Bond shall be issued for any value, in multiples of Rs 1000, Rs 10,000, Rs 1 lakh, Rs 10 lakh and Rs 1 crore from the Specified Branches of the State Bank of India (SBI). 
  •  The purchaser would be allowed to buy Electoral Bonds only on due fulfilment of all the extant KYC norms and by making payment from a bank account. It will not carry the name of payee.
  •  The Electoral Bonds would have a life of only 15 days during which it can be used for making donation only to political parties which has secured not less than one per cent of the votes polled in the last general election to the House of the People or to Legislative Assembly.
  • Every political party in its returns will have to disclose the amount of donations it has received through electoral bonds to the Election Commission.

Concerns associated with electoral bonds

  • Identity of Donor remains unknown goes against transparency of electoral funding
  • No Upper Limit for Donation Increases Corruption and red tapism through undisclosed identity.
  • Exemption allowed under RTI Act – Section 8(1)(e) , Results in Frivolous Donations from unaccounted source. Further it strengthens Corporate-Political Nexus and results in quid pro quo scenario post elections.
  • Prohibition of donation to be provided by companies older than 3 years removed. This will lead to formation of Shell Companies to route funds as part of electoral finance.
  • Restrictions on corporates for donating more than 7.5% of their average net profit over the previous 3 years to the Political parties removed. FCRA Amendment enables political parties to accept donations from foreign companies – Indian elections may have foreign influence.

CERT-in may be exempted from giving information under RTI Act

Context: Central Government has informed Parliament that Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-in) may soon be exempt from responding to queries under the Right to Information Act.

Major Highlights: 

  • The Department of Personnel and Training has reviewed a proposal from the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology to include CERT-in in the Second Schedule to the RTI Act, which deals with exempted organisations like the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and the Border Security Force.
  • The exemption would allow CERT-in to reject any application for information, even on policy-related matters. 

About CERT:

  • Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-IN) is the nodal agency to deal with cyber security threats like hacking and phishing and strengthens the security-related defence of the Indian Internet domain. 
  • CERT-IN was formed in 2004 by the Government of India under Information Technology Act, 2000 Section (70B). 
  • It is an office within the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology. 
  • CERT-In has been designated to serve as the national agency to perform the following functions in the area of cyber security:
    • Collection, analysis and dissemination of information on cyber incidents.
    • Forecast and alerts of cyber security incidents.
    • Emergency measures for handling cyber security incidents.
    • Coordination of cyber incident response activities.
    • Issue guidelines, advisories, vulnerability notes and whitepapers relating to information security practices, procedures, prevention, response and reporting of cyber incidents.