Context: Tamil Nadu Governor R. Ravi’s decision to unilaterally dismiss with immediate effect arrested Minister V. Senthilbalaji from the Council of Ministers only to hurriedly backtrack his decision tests the constitutional limitations on the role of the Governor and pushes the Raj Bhavan into uncharted political territory. So, the primary question which emanates is whether withdrawal of pleasure by the Governor unilaterally allowed under the constitutional set-up?
About Governor
The State Executive consists of the Governor, who is the head of the State, and the Council of Ministers with the Chief Minister at its head. The Governor acts as:
Constitutional Head of a State under Article 153 and 154, and as
An agent of the Centre as he holds office during the pleasure of the President under Article 156.
The governor is neither directly elected by the people nor indirectly elected by a specially constituted electoral college as is the case with the president.
Under Article 155, Governor is appointed by the President by warrant under his hand and seal. In a way, he is a nominee of the Central government.
Under Article164, Governor appoints the Chief Ministers and other Ministers and the Ministers holds office during the pleasure of the Governor.
Meaning of Withdrawal of pleasure
“Pleasure of the Governor”did not mean the Governor has the right to dismiss the Chief Minister or Ministers at will. The “pleasure” of the Governor is understood to flow from the fact that the government enjoys majority on the floor of the House. The Governor can have his pleasure if the government enjoys a majority in the House.
The Governor can withdraw his pleasure only when the government loses majority but refuses to quit. Then he withdraws the pleasure and dismisses it. Without the advice of the Chief Minister, a Governor can neither appoint nor dismiss a minister.
Surya Narain Choudhary vs Union of India (1981) - Rajasthan High Court held that the pleasure of the President was not justiciable, the Governor had no security of tenure and can be removed at any time by the President withdrawing pleasure.
Supreme Court to Aid & Advice under Art. 163
Article 163 of the Constitution states that there shall be a Council of Ministers with the Chief Minister at the head to aid and advise the Governor in the exercise of his functions, except in so far as he is by or under this Constitution required to exercise his functions or any of them in his discretion. However, the discretion as such has neither been elaborated nor provided explicitly under the Indian Constitution.
Shamsher Singh v State of Punjab –
Seven Judge Constitution Bench held that the Governor must exercise “formal constitutional powers only upon, and in accordance with the aid and advice of their ministers, save in a few well-known exceptional situations.
These exceptions relate to dismissal of a government that has lost its majority or decision to invite a party to form the government. In both these circumstances, the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers becomes unavailable or unreliable.
Court also held that the Governor has no right to refuse to act on the advice of the Council of Ministries. Such a position is antithetical to the concept of ‘responsible government’.”
Similar issue arose when Governor of Kerala withdrew pleasure from Finance Minister KN Balagopal - Responding to this, constitutional law expert and former Secretary General of the Lok Sabha Mr. PDT Achary said that a Governor can take such a decision only on the advise of Chief Minister.
Way Forward
The Supreme Court, in its recent ruling in Shiv Sena case relating to the political crisis in the Maharashtra government, cautioned against the Governor stepping in to settle political rivalry.
Thus, Governor must act according to the mandates of the Constitution and should avoid political confrontation with the elected government especially with respect to withdrawal of pleasure.
Context: Lieutenant-Governor of Delhi has raised the issue of the Delhi government’s 10-year delay in framing rules for conducting a social audit into the functioning of the public distribution system (PDS) and fair price shops under the National Food Security Act (NFSA), 2013.
About Social Audit
It is a continuous process that includes verification of works at the various stages of implementation of programmes/schemes with active involvement of the primary stakeholders.
It is a way of measuring, understanding, reporting and ultimately improving an organization’s social and ethical performance.
It helps to narrow gaps between vision/goal and reality, between efficiency and effectiveness.
It creates an impact on governance. It values the voice of stakeholders, including marginalized/poor groups whose voices are rarely heard.
It is taken up for the purpose of enhancing local governance, particularly for strengthening accountability and transparency in local bodies.
The key difference betweena development and a social audit is that a social audit focuses on the neglected issue of social impacts, while a development audit has a broader focus including environmental and economic issues, such as the efficiency of a project or programme.
It is a powerful tool, that is, associated with accountability and promotes the Right to Information (RTI).
The states in India have taken up Social Audits of various programmes/schemes such as MGNREGS, Pradhan Mantri Awaas Yojana (PMAY), Mid-Day Meal Scheme (MDM), Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) and Public Distribution System (PDS).
National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, 2005 provides for regular Social Audits so as to ensure transparency and accountability in the scheme. The State Government shall identify or establish, under the NREGS, an independent organization, Social Audit Unit (SAU), at the state level, to facilitate the conduct of social audit by Gram Sabhas.
In April 2017, Meghalaya became the first State in the country to pass a social audit legislation, the Meghalaya Community Participation and Public Services Social Audit Act.
Need for Social Audit:
Reduces corruption: It uncovers irregularities and malpractices in the public sector and maintains oversight of government functioning, thus reducing leakages and corruption.
Monitoring and feedback: It monitors the social and ethical impact of an organization’s performance and provides feedback on the work.
Accountability and transparency: It ensures accountability and transparency in the working of local government bodies and reduces the trust gap between people and local governments.
According to the MGNREGA Social Audit Report of 2020, close to 3 lakh cases of financial misappropriation amounting a total of Rs 658 Crore, combining audits of both 2018-19 and 2019-20 were identified. 60 percent of these financial misappropriation cases pertain to issues of payment to persons who did not work under NREGA.
Participative and democratic: It promotes the participation of people in the implementation of programmes and makes people more forthcoming for social development activities.
Strengthens the Gram Sabha: It gives voice and influencing power to the Gram Sabha, the lynchpin of the rural governance structure.
Collective platform: It provides a collective platform such as a social audit Gram Sabha, for people to express their common needs, resulting in social cohesion.
Objectives of Social Audit
Physical and financial gaps: Assessing the physical and financial gaps between needs and resources available for local development.
Awareness: Creating awareness among beneficiaries and providers of local social and productive services.
Efficacy and effectiveness: Increasing efficacy and effectiveness of local development programmes and ensures that the audited accounts are disclosed to stakeholders.
Scrutiny: Scrutiny of various policy decisions, keeping in view stakeholder interests and priorities, particularly of rural poor.
Timely access: Estimation of the opportunity cost for stakeholders of not getting timely access to public services.
Participatory: Encourages participation of stakeholders and sharing of their values and reflects the views (voices) of all those people (stakeholders) involved with or affected by the organization/department/programme.
Transparency and accountability: Ensure that the social accounts are audited by a suitably experienced person or agency with no vested interest in the organisation.
Advantages of social audit
Trains the community on participatory local planning.
Encourages local democracy.
Encourages community participation.
Benefits disadvantaged groups.
Promotes collective decision-making and sharing responsibilities.
Develops human resources and social capital
Challenges of Social Audit:
Lack of Infrastructure: At ground level to address grievances made by the public during scrutiny.
Lack of administrative and political will: In institutionalizing social audit mechanisms.
Lack of stringent penal action: Against those creating hurdles in the process.
Lack of awareness: Lack of educated and well-informed citizenry to undertake regular audits.
Low skilled capacity: Lack of technical and managerial capacity such as book-keeping, and accounting.
One size fits all approach: Lack of uniform process of social audit across states due to language and cultural barriers. No Benchmarking of Social Audit mechanisms for comparison purposes across districts.
Way forward
Director and staff selection: The selection of Directors of Social Audit Units(SAUs) should be free of political control and the selection process should be strictly followed.
Legally sanctioned outcomes: Social audit arrangements have mostly been ineffective because there is no legal provision for punitive action. States should enact legislation to facilitate social audit by the Gram Sabha on the line of Meghalaya’s Public Services Social Audit Act.
Increased frequency: Social audits must be conducted in every Gram Panchayat once every 6 months.
Using Management Information System (MIS): Usage of MIS to track details of schemes at all levels to streamline the life-cycle of programme planning, implementation and feedback.
Displaying Information of Notice Board: The findings of the social audit should be shared with all local stakeholders. This encourages transparency and accountability. A report of the social audit meeting should be distributed for Gram Panchayat auditing. In addition, key decisions should be written on walls and boards and communicated orally.
Civil society participation: People including students from different universities should be encouraged to participate as Village Resource Persons. Example, Jharkhand has instituted a formal mechanism by inviting prominent civil society representatives to be part of the SA panel.
Better coordination: Seeks clarifications from the implementing agency about any decision-making, activity, scheme, income and expenditure incurred by the agency
Scrutiny: Consider and scrutinize existing schemes and local activities of the agency.
Database: Access registers and documents relating to all development activities undertaken by the implementing agency or by any other government department.
Independent agency: An agency like the Ombudsman can be set up to look into complaints of local maladministration.
Case Studies:
Social audit in Jharnipalli Panchayat, Agaipur block, Bolangir district, Orissa
In October 2001, the gram sabha members of Jharnipalli Panchayat conducted a one-day social audit of development works carried out in the panchayat over the preceding three years. This audit took place with the active participation of many individuals and agencies, including block and district administration officials
The Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan (MKSS)
It conducted social audits of daily wage earners and farmers on government projects, and more generally, to expose corruption in government expenditure in Rajasthan. They found various irregularities in finance which resulted into right to information movement in Rajasthan.
Context:The government of India plans to register online fact checking platforms of various institutions including big corporates to ensure greater accountability in the digital space. This aspect of registration is expected to be a part of the proposed Digital India Bill and such registration of online fact checking platform could be carried out in different phases.
Classification of Online Fact Checking Platform
The proposed Digital India Bill is expected to classify various types of online intermediaries, including fact-checking portals - One of the major reasons behind the proposed classification of online intermediaries is that the Centre intends to prescribe specific rules for different types of intermediaries. One of the rules may prescribe for registration of online intermediaries or online fact checking portal.
The term “intermediary” has been presently defined in The Information Technology Act, 2000 - “intermediary”, with respect to any particular electronic records, means any person who on behalf of another person receives, stores or transmits that record or provides any service with respect to that record and includes telecom service providers, network service providers, internet service providers, web-hosting service providers, search engines, online payment sites, online-auction sites, online-market places and cyber cafes.
Multiple types of intermediaries in the current digital age comprise e-commerce, digital media, social media, Artificial Intelligence, Over the Top (OTT) Platforms, Online Gaming etc.
Proliferation of Illegal Activities in Digital Space
With increasing proliferation of technology and expansion of digital space at an exponential rate also increases the risks of cyber-frauds and hence needs better regulation.
We are witnessing new innovative ways of online financial fraud and criminal and illegal activity also thrives in other areas of digital space.
New Complex forms of user harms includes –
Catfishing - creation of fictional or fake identity by taking personal details of other persons
Doxxing - a form of cyberbullying that uses sensitive or secret information, statements, or records for the harassment, exposure, financial harm, or other exploitation of targeted individuals.
Cyberstalking - is a technologically-based "attack" on one person who has been targeted specifically for that attack for reasons of anger, revenge or control. Cyberstalking can take many forms, including: harassment, false accusation, defamation, embarrassment or humiliation of the victim.
Cyber trolling - person who posts or makes inflammatory, insincere, digressive, extraneous, or off-topic messages online
Gaslighting – manipulating someone using psychological methods leading to question sanity of the person
Phishing – attackers deceiving people into revealing sensitive information such as credit card numbers, bank information, or passwords etc. or installing malware such as ransomware.
Increasing proliferation of hate speech, disinformation and fake news is another very important reason to register online fact checking platforms.
What does the Proposed Digital India Law intends to Achieve?
According to the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, the proposed Digital India law should evolve through rules that can be updated, and address the tenets of Digital India which includes:
Open Internet
Online Safety and Trust
Accountability and Quality of Service
Adjudicatory mechanism
New Technologies
There is also an urgent need for a specialized and dedicated adjudicatory mechanism for online civil and criminal offences. The adjudicatory mechanism should
be easily accessible
deliver timely remedies to citizens
resolve cyber disputes
develop a unified cyber jurisprudence
enforce the rule of law online
Way Forward
The proposed Digital India Bill should not only provide a global standard cyber laws to act as a catalyst and enabler for $1 trillion digital economy but should also ensure that the digital space is not misused. Hence, the proposed law should also protect citizens’ rights and address emerging technology risks including technological disruptions.
Context: The government will appoint a Finance Commission in the next few months to determine how much of the Centre’s tax revenue should be given away to States (the vertical share) and how to distribute that among States (the horizontal sharing formula).
In the pre-reform period, the Finance Commission recommendations were not that critical because the Centre had other ways to compensate States, or indeed to play favourites, through plan financing and public sector undertaking (PSU) investments. Post-reforms, fresh PSU investments have thinned out and the Planning Commission was abolished in 2014 with the result that the Finance Commission remains virtually the sole architect of India’s fiscal federalism. Its responsibility and influence are, therefore, much larger.
Before going into details of the report which shall be extremely important from the perspective of Mains examination, Let us first understand the need for any such body at the first place? Specially given that states and centre both have been enabled to levy and collect taxes in their domains.
Now finance commission is body to facilitate fiscal balance in the Indian federal structure and hence enabling Fiscal federalism.
What is a Fiscal imbalance?
Fiscal imbalance occurs when the revenues of a unit are not appropriate to carry out the responsibilities allocated to it.
Now there are two kinds of imbalances that can occur in Indian Federalism:
vertical imbalance (between state and centre)
horizontal imbalance (among the states)
FINANCE COMMISSIONS – A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
Vertical and horizontal imbalances are common features of most federations and India is no exception to this.
So why does vertical imbalance (between state and centre) occur?
Because there is a mismatch of responsibilities and revenue sources between the Union and the States?
Now why is that?: mainly because of two reasons
Constitution assigned taxes with a nation-wide base to the Union (which earn higher revenues)
Why was this done?
This was done to make the country one common economic space unhindered by internal barriers to the extent possible.
Constitution assigned functional responsibilities involving high expenditure disproportionate to their assigned sources of revenue
Since the expenditures are incurred mainly in the executive branch, let us see the constitutional scheme for the same:
Legislative responsibility
Executive responsibility
LIST I
Union
Union
LIST II
State
State
LIST III
Both
State
So you can see that states take care of both List 1 and List II
Why was this done?
States being closer to people and more sensitive to the local needs have been assigned
These two factors have resulted in vertical imbalances.
So why does horizontal imbalance (among the states) occur?
Unlike in most other federations, differences in the developmental levels in Indian States are very sharp.
Horizontal imbalances across States are on account of factors, which include historical backgrounds, differential endowment of resources, and capacity to raise resources.
So you can say that the creation of Finance commission is the recognition of the imbalance which exists in the federalism and hence mechanisms under article 280 and 281 have been created to ensure that these imbalances are minimized.
Hence let us have a look at the constitutional provisions related to the finance commission as far as constitution of India is concerned:
So as you read in article 280, the report of the Finance Commission has to be submitted for every five years and you also know that the report of the last FC (14th) was applicable for 2015-2020 period, then why did FC 15 not submit the final report for the period 2020-2025?
At the formation of the 15th FC, It was required to submit the report by October 30, 2019 for five years for the period 2020-21 to 2024-25.
However, due to various political and fiscal developments, its term was extended.
So what are the reasons behind the extensions?
Speak: the basic reason is that the reports of the FC are based on the projections of various parameters related to taxation, GDP and deficits. the current state of Indian economy makes it difficult for any panel to successfully do a projection.
So why making medium-term projections in the current scenario would mean serious risks?
Changes in the federal units
the abolition of Statehood to Jammu and Kashmir required the Commission to make an estimation excluding the Union Territory.
Historically low Nominal growth rate
the deceleration in growth and low inflation has substantially slowed down the nominal GDP growth which is the main tax base proxy; making projections of tax revenues and expenditures based on this for the medium term could have posed serious risks.
Issues related to Tax revenues
Poor revenue performance of tax collection more particularly Goods and Services Tax
Also the compensation agreement to the loss of revenue to the States is applicable only till 2022(which means it will cover only two years of the period covered by the Commission’s recommendations hence posing uncertainties)
So these are the factors which have compelled the extension of the term of 15th FC as well as its submission of interim report.
Let us now discuss the highlighting features of the report:
14th FC
15 FC
Remarks
Vertical distribution
42
41
the Fifteenth Finance Commission continued with the recommendation of the previous Commission relating to vertical division of taxes, and adjusted the States’ share to 41% to exclude the share of Jammu and Kashmir.
Horizontal Distribution
Population
1971 (17.5%) 2011(10.0%)
2011(15.0%)
Income Distance
50.0%
45.0%
Area
15.0%
15.0%
Forest cover
7.50%
10.0%
it has used two additional factors — demographic performance and tax effort.
Demographic Performance
NA
12.5%
the inverse of fertility rate hence showing sensitivity to the concerns of these States.
Tax Efforts
NA
2.5%
So how have states fared after overall devolution?
Major observations
In terms of relative shares in tax devolution, among the major States the biggest loser is Karnataka followed by Uttar Pradesh, Kerala, Telangana and Andhra Pradesh.
Kerala and Andhra Pradesh have post-devolution gaps and hence qualify for revenue gap grants.
Karnataka and Kerala have net loss after devolution. Why?
The major reason for Karnataka and Kerala losing on devolution is that their per capita income growth has been faster than most other States.
The difference from the highest per capita income in both Karnataka and Kerala is just about 10% now as compared to 34% and 23%, respectively, for the two States when the Fourteenth Finance Commission made the recommendation.
What are recommendations of the 15th FC regarding Local body grants
Panchayats
Municipalities
Grants
₹60,750 crore
₹29,250 crore₹9,229 – million plus cities ₹20,021 – rest of the cities
Conditions
50% of the grant is tied to improving sanitation and supply of drinking water
50% of the grant is tied to improving sanitation and supply of drinking water
Did 15th FC make any recommendations regarding Disaster management?
For disaster management, a total of ₹28,183 crore has been determined of which the Central contribution will be ₹22,184 crore
The Commission has recommended the creation of Disaster Mitigation Fund at the Central and State levels.
But how is this remaining amount distributed among the states?
Inter-State allocation is made based on past expenditures, area and population and disaster risk index.
Are there any sectoral grants?
Nutrition:
The Commission has worked out a framework for giving some sectoral grants as well. For 2020-21, it has recommended ₹7,735 crore for improving nutrition based on the numbers of children in the 0-6 age group and lactating mothers
Context: Law Commission of India has opined that Section 124A criminalising sedition should be retained. However, with some procedural safeguards.
S. G. Vombatkere Case (Supreme Demands Review of Sedition Law)
The opinion of Law Commission is significant as a Supreme Court bench last year decided to put in abeyance all cases of Sedition and directed Centre & State Governments not register any fresh FIR invoking the offence. (S. G. Vombatkere Case)
The Court also directed the Government for examining the sedition law as it found the sedition law not in tune with current times.
Reasons for demand of repeal of sedition law:
Sedition law has a chilling effect on free speech and expression.
Alleged misuse of sedition law for curbing political dissent.
Vague definition of sedition law leading to erroneous interpretation
Very easy to use this law and lack of checks & safeguards
Overzealous application of this law to please political masters (important particularly in light of lack of police reforms)
Reasons for Retaining Sedition as a Crime
For safeguarding the Unity & Integrity of India:
All organised societies have right to protect itself against attempts to overthrow. It is the chief duty of any government to safeguard State & its institutions against external and internal attack.
Precondition of enjoying freedom is to ensure the security of the State because without such guarantee of stability the rest of the law will be ineffective.
Section 124A provides a prompt and effective mechanism for suppression of disintegrating tendencies and protects & preserves the integrity of Indian State. It is a deterrent for persons who want to commit acts of incitement to violence & acts causing disturbance of public order.
Sedition law can check the proliferation of radicalisation against India, promotion of hatred against Government particularly on the social media.
Sedition is a Reasonable Restriction under Article 19(2)
Critics have argued that Sedition Law is violative of Right to speech and expression under Article 19(2) of Constitution. But arguments against this position are:
Constituent Assembly substituted 'sedition' with 'which undermines the security of, or tends to overthrow the State', as the later phrase had a wider import and was more expansive in meaning.
First Amendment of the Constitution incorporated public order, friendly relations with foreign states and incitement to an offence as reasonable restrictions under Article 19(1)(a). SC in Kedar Nath Singh judgement held that sedition was a constitutional restriction under the ambit reasonable restrictions to speech & expression.
When two interpretations of a law are possible the one rendering it constitutional and the other making it unconstitutional, the former interpretation should prevail.
Existence of counter-terror legislations does not obviate the need for Section 124A:
Critics argue that counter terror laws like UAPA & National Security Act makes the sedition law irrelevant. However, these special laws & anti-terror legislations dealing with national security seek to prevent or punish the commission of offences targeted towards the state.
On the other hand, Sedition law seeks to prevent violent, illegal & unconstitutional overthrow of a democratically elected government established by law. Hence, the existence of counter terror laws does not imply all elements of the offence envisaged under Sedition.
Sedition being a colonial legacy is not a valid ground for its repeal:
Critics argue that sedition law is of a colonial legacy and was used against freedom fighters. However, if we go by this logic then the entire legal system of India should be overthrown as India's legal system is a colonial legacy.
The colonial government acted like a master and treated Indians not a citizens but as its servant.
However, in today's constitutional and democratic set up, Government is based on the will of the people, wherein the government is only a servant of the people as it is elected by the people.
Constitution provides ample space and liberty to people to indulge in healthy & constructive criticism of their government in a democratic set up.
However, there is a need to penalise pernicious tendency to incite violence or cause public disorder in the guise of right to freedom of speech & expression.
Realities differ in every jurisdiction:
The argument that just because some countries have repealed sedition from law books means India should also repeal sedition means turning a blind eye to the glaring ground realities & security concerns existing in India.
Even the countries which have repealed sedition law, mere cosmetic changes have been made in the law of sedition without taking away the core of law of sedition or merely merged their sedition law with counter terror laws.
Recommendations of Law Commission on Sedition
Incorporation of ratio of Kedar Nath Judgement of Section 124A of IPC: Supreme Court laid down in Kedar Nath Singh that unless the words used or actions in question
Do not tend to incite violence or
Cause public disorder or
Cause disturbance to public peace
Procedural Guidelines for Preventing any Alleged Misuse of Section 124A of IPC
To prevent any alleged misuse of Section 124A of IPC, the Law Commission has suggested certain procedural safeguards to be undertaken prior to registration of FIR with respect to commission of an offence of Sedition.
These procedural safeguards can be introduced by issuance of guidelines by central government or an amendment in Section 154 of CrPC (dealing with filing of FIR for cognizable offence).
A FIR for an offence of Sedition can be filed only after a police officer not below the rank of inspector conducts a preliminary inquiry. Based on this preliminary report, the Central or State Government should grant permission for registering a FIR.
Removal of Oddity in Punishment Prescribed for Section 124A of IPC: Currently, the punishment prescribed for sedition is either life imprisonment or imprisonment for three years, but nothing in between. There is a need to reform the punishment prescribed for sedition under IPC to allow courts greater room to award punishment for sedition in line with scale and gravity of act committed.
Proposed definition of Sedition
Current Definition of Sedition
Proposed Definition of Sedition
Medium of Sedition
By words, either spoken or written By signsBy visible representationOtherwise
By words, either spoken or written By signsBy visible representationOtherwise
What Qualifies as Sedition?
Attempts to bring into hatred or contempt or excites or attempts to excite disaffection towards the Government established by law.Expression of 'disaffection' includes disloyalty & all feelings of enmity.
Attempts to bring into hatred or contempt or excites or attempts to excite disaffection towards the Government established by law, with a tendency to incite violence or cause public disorder (new addition).Tendency means mere inclination to incite violence or cause public disorder rather than proof of actual violence or imminent threat to violence. Expression of 'disaffection' includes disloyalty & all feelings of enmity.
What is not Sedition?
Comments expressing disapprobation of measures of Government with a view to obtain their alteration by lawful means, without exciting or attempting to excite hatred, contempt or disaffection. Comments expressing disapprobation of administrative or other action of Government without exciting or attempting to excite hatred, contempt or disaffection.
Comments expressing disapprobation of measures of Government with a view to obtain their alteration by lawful means, without exciting or attempting to excite hatred, contempt or disaffection. Comments expressing disapprobation of administrative or other action of Government without exciting or attempting to excite hatred, contempt or disaffection.
Punishment for Sedition
Life imprisonment to which fine may be added, orImprisonment which may extend to three, or with fine.
Life imprisonment to which fine may be added, orImprisonment for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine.
Context: Kerala Governor Arif Mohammed Khan took exception to the State government’s move to reissue ordinances instead of getting the executive orders ratified by the Assembly.
The government had sent Mr. Khan 11 ordinances for re-promulgation. They included the controversial Kerala Lok Ayukta, 1999, amendment ordinance, and the Kerala Cooperative Societies Act, 2022, amendment ordinance.
In India, the central and state legislatures are responsible for law making, the central and state governments are responsible for the implementation of laws and the judiciary (Supreme Court, High Courts and lower courts) interprets these laws. However, there are several overlaps in the functions and powers of the three institutions. For example, the President has certain legislative and judicial functions and the legislature can delegate some of its functions to the executive in the form of subordinate legislation.
Ordinance making is one such provision which diffuses the line between legislature and executive. They enable the government to take immediate legislative action in desperate times. Article 123 of the Indian Constitution grants the President of India certain Law making powers i.e. to Promulgate Ordinances when either of the two Houses of the Parliament is not in session which makes it impossible for a single House to pass and enact a law. Ordinances may relate to any subject that the parliament has the power to make law, and would be having the same limitations.
But executive (Both central and state) have often misused this power. Nothing epitomises the re-promulgation of the ordinances better than the famous “Bihar case”. Which was about the promulgation of 256 ordinances between 1967 and 1981 in Bihar. This included 11 ordinances that were kept alive for more than 10 years and famously dubbed as ordinance raj.
So instances like these clearly indicate the misuse of legislative powers by the executive which were meant to be used only rarely and under limited circumstances. So in this regard we will understand the following:
Article 123 and Article 213 confers power to promulgate ordinance on the President and the Governor respectively.
Under the Constitution, limitations exist with regard to the Ordinance making power of the executive:
Legislature is not in session: The President can only promulgate an Ordinance when either of the two Houses of Parliament is not in session.
Immediate action is required: The President cannot promulgate an Ordinance unless he is satisfied that there are circumstances that require taking ‘immediate action’.
Parliamentary approval during session: Ordinances must be approved by Parliament within six weeks of reassembling or they shall cease to operate. They will also cease to operate in case resolutions disapproving the Ordinance are passed by both the Houses.
Why frequent resorting to Ordinance Route?
Reluctance to face the legislature on particular issues.
Lack of majority in the Parliament.
Repeated and wilful disruption by opposition parties.
Issues
The executive’s power to issue ordinances, goes against the Philosophy of Separation of powers between the Legislature, Executive and Judiciary
It bypasses the democratic requirements of argument and deliberation.
Re-promulgation defeats the constitutional scheme under which a limited power to frame ordinances has been conferred on the President and the Governors.
It poses threat to the sovereignty of Parliament and the state legislatures which have been constituted as primary lawgivers under the Constitution. The Constitution has provided for Separation of Power where enacting laws is the function of the legislature. The executive must show self-restraint and should use ordinance making power only as per the spirit of the Constitution and not to evade legislative scrutiny and debates
Important Cases related to Ordinance
RC Cooper vs. Union of India, 1970: SC held that the President’s decision could be challenged on the grounds that ‘immediate action’ was not required; and the Ordinance had been passed primarily to by-pass debate and discussion in the legislature.
AK Roy vs. Union of India, 1982: SC argued that the President’s Ordinance making power is not beyond the scope of judicial review. Later in case of Venkata Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1985) Supreme court over ruled its own decision and held that the Satisfaction of the President cannot be called in question.
DC Wadhwa vs. State of Bihar, 1987: SC said that the legislative power of the executive to promulgate Ordinances is to be used in exceptional circumstances and not as a substitute for the law making power. It was examining a case where a state government repromulgated a total of 259 Ordinances and some of them for as long as 14 years.
Krishna Kumar Singh vs. State of Bihar, 2017: Supreme Court held that the failure to place an ordinance before the legislature constitutes abuse of power and a fraud on the Constitution. It makes mandatory for an ordinance to be tabled in the legislature for its approval.
Way forward
In Nagraj Judgment, SC has observed “The power to issue an ordinance is not an executive power but it’s the power of the executive to legislate on the grounds provided for in article 123”.
Context: Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud said the independence of judiciary depends on the freedom of each and every individual judge to function in office without the pulls of political pressure, social compulsions, and inherent bias.
“The independence of the Supreme Court is integral to the maintenance of a democratic way of life and rule of law. It is not very difficult for a nation which is a democracy having a Constitution to slip into chaos, into just the opposite of democracy,” Justice Joseph said.
Syllabus:
General Studies- II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International relations:
Rule of Law and its relation with Independence of Judiciary?
It would be appropriate to discuss the views of Dicey, as he is known to be the main exponent of the concept of rule of law.
According to Dicey’s theory, rule of law has three pillars based on the concept that “a government should be based on principles of law and not of men”, these are-
Supremacy of Law;
Equality before the Law; and
Predominance of Legal spirit.
According to Dicey, for the prevalence of the rule of law there should be an enforcing authority and that authority he found in the courts. He believed that the courts are the enforcer of the rule of law and hence it should be free from impartiality and external influence.
The rule of law provides two basic protections against arbitrary or discriminatory government action.
It provides that the rule applied to a particular case must be reasonably predictable.
And it provides that the rule must be predictable without regard for the identity of the parties.
Judicial independence ensures, in particular, that judges are free to conclude that actions taken, or decisions made by the Government (or even by others) are in breach of the law, and that they are in particular in breach of individual's rights, including of course their fundamental, or human, rights - and to decide on the appropriate remedy.
Why the Judiciary needs to be Independent?
Independence of Judiciary is sine qua non of democracy. In a democratic polity, the supreme power of state is shared among the three principal organs. The constitutional task assigned to the Judiciary is no way less than that of other functionaries, legislature and executive.
Indeed it is the role of the Judiciary to carry out the constitutional message and it is its responsibility to keep a vigilant watch over the functioning of democracy in accordance with the dictates, directives, and imperative commands of the constitution by checking excessive authority of other constitutional functionaries.
Our Constitution does not strictly adhere to the doctrine of separation of powers but it does provide for distribution of power to ensure that one organ of the government does not trench on the constitutional powers of other organs.
The concept of distribution of powers assumes the existence of judicial system free from external as well as internal pressures. Under our constitution, the Judiciary has been assigned the onerous task of safeguarding the fundamental rights of our citizens and upholding the Rule of Law. Perhaps the most important power of the Supreme Court is the power of judicial review.
Judicial Review means the power of the Supreme Court (or High Courts) to examine the constitutionality of any law if the Court arrives at the conclusion that the law is inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution, such a law is declared as unconstitutional and inapplicable. The term judicial review is nowhere mentioned in the Constitution.
However, the fact that India has a written constitution and the Supreme Court can strike down a law that goes against fundamental rights, implicitly gives the Supreme Court the power of judicial review. Together, the writ powers and the review power of the Court make judiciary very powerful. In particular, the review power means that the judiciary can interpret the Constitution and the laws passed by the legislature.
Many people think that this feature enables the judiciary to protect the Constitution effectively and also to protect the rights of citizens. The practice of entertaining PILs has further added to the powers of the judiciary in protecting rights of citizens.
Since the courts are entrusted the duty to uphold the constitution and the laws, it very often comes in conflict with the state when it tries to enforce orders. Therefore, the need for an independent and impartial Judiciary manned by persons of sterling quality and character, underlying courage and determination and resolution impartiality and independence who would dispense Justice without fear or favor, ill will or affection, is the cordial creed of our constitution and a solemn assurance of every Judge to the people of this great country.
The Judiciary cannot remain a mere bystander or spectator but it must become an active participant in the judicial process ready to use law in the service of social justice through a proactive goal oriented approach. But this cannot be achieved unless we have judicial cadres who share the fighting faith of the constitution and are imbued with constitutional values.
Judicial independence ensures, in particular, that judges are free to conclude that actions taken, or decisions made by the Government (or even by others) are in breach of the law, and that they are in particular in breach of individual's rights, including of course their fundamental, or human, rights - and to decide on the appropriate remedy.
Independence of Indian Judiciary
The constitution of India adopts diverse devices to ensure the independence of the judiciary in keeping with both the doctrines of constitutional and Parliamentary sovereignty.
Elaborated provision are in place for ensuring the independent position of the Judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts.
Firstly, the judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts have to take an oath before entering once that they will faithfully perform their duties without fear, favour, affection, ill-will, and defend the constitution of India and the laws. Recognition of the doctrine of constitutional sovereignty is implicit in this oath.
Secondly, the process of appointment of judges also ensures the independence of judiciary in India. The judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts are appointed by the President. The constitution of India has made it obligatory on the President to make the appointments in consultation with the highest judicial authorities. He, of course, takes advice of the Cabinet. The constitution also prescribes necessary qualifications for such appointments. The constitution tries to make the appointments unbiased by political considerations.
Thirdly, the Constitution provides for the Security of Tenure of Judges. The judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts serve “during good behavior” and not during the pleasure of the President, as is the case with other high Government officials. They cannot be arbitrarily removed by the President. They may be removed from office only through impeachment. A Judge can be removed on the ground of proved misbehavior or incapacity on a report by both Houses of the Parliament supported by a special majority.
Fourthly, the salaries and allowances of judges are charged upon the Consolidated Fund of India. Further, the salaries and allowances of Judges of Supreme court and High courts cannot be reduced during their tenure, except during a financial emergency under Article 360 of the Constitution.
Fifthly, the activities of the Judges cannot be discussed by the executive or the legislature, except in case of their removal.
Sixth, the retirement age is 65 years for Supreme Court judges and 62 years for High court judges. Such long tenure enables the judges to function impartially and independently.
Independence of judiciary and rule of law are the basic features of the Constitution and cannot be abrogated even by constitutional amendments as observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in S.P. Gupta v Union of India; AIR 1982.
Certainly, let's expand on each of the mentioned aspects concerning threats to judicial independence in India:
Retirement Age (Different for HC and SC Judges): The disparity in retirement ages for judges of the High Court (HC) and the Supreme Court (SC) can create a situation where judges might be influenced by the prospect of elevation to the higher court before reaching the retirement age. This could potentially compromise their independence as judges may be tempted to make decisions that align with the preferences of those in power.
Post-Retirement Appointments: The practice of judges accepting post-retirement appointments, especially in government commissions, tribunals, or other quasi-judicial bodies, raises concerns about potential conflicts of interest. Judges may be inclined to rule favorably for the government during their tenure in the hope of securing a lucrative post-retirement position, impacting their impartiality.
Appointment of Chief Justice of India: The appointment process of the Chief Justice of India (CJI) has faced criticism for lacking transparency. The influence of the executive and political considerations in the appointment process may compromise the independence of the judiciary, as the CJI plays a crucial role in determining the course of the judicial system.
CJI as Master of the Roster: The CJI being the master of the roster implies that they have the authority to allocate cases to different benches of the court. This power, if not exercised judiciously, can lead to the manipulation of cases to favor certain outcomes or to assign cases selectively. Such discretion can be a potential threat to the impartiality of the judicial system.
The Collegium System: The Collegium system, while intended to safeguard judicial independence, has faced criticism for being opaque and lacking accountability. The process of appointment and transfer of judges through the Collegium system might be susceptible to external pressures, potentially compromising the independence of the judiciary.
Judicial Delays: Prolonged delays in the disposal of cases can undermine public confidence in the judiciary. The backlog of cases can be exploited by powerful individuals or entities to their advantage, and the perception of delayed justice might impact the credibility of the judiciary, thereby affecting its independence.
Code of Conduct for Judges: While a code of conduct for judges exists, the effectiveness of its enforcement is crucial. Weak enforcement mechanisms can render the code toothless, allowing judges to engage in misconduct without facing adequate consequences, thus jeopardizing the integrity of the judiciary.
Code of Ethics for Judges: The code of ethics is essential for maintaining the ethical standards of judges. However, the absence of a comprehensive and enforceable code, along with potential loopholes, may create opportunities for unethical behavior. This can undermine public trust and confidence in the judiciary.
The constitution provides for a judiciary, which is independent. Independence of judiciary is important for the purpose of fair justice. There should be no interference by the legislature or the executive in the proceedings of the judiciary so that it may pass a judgment that seems reasonably fair. In case of intervention, there may be an element of bias on the part of the judges in taking a fair decision. It is difficult to suggest any other way to make the Indian courts more self-reliant and keep them away from the influence of the other two organs.
Context: A five judge bench of the Supreme Court upheld the amendments made by Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra and Karnataka to the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (PCA) Act of 1960. These amendments allowed the bull taming sports like Jallikattu, Kambala and bullock cart races.
What is Jallikattu?
Jallikattu is a traditional bull-taming sport that is primarily practiced in the Indian state of Tamil Nadu. The word "Jallikattu" is derived from the Tamil words "Jalli" (meaning gold or silver coins) and "Kattu" (meaning a bundle). The sport involves the running of bulls in an open field, and participants attempt to grab the bull's hump and hold on to it for a certain distance or time to win prizes, which are usually tied to the bull's horns.
What is the controversy surrounding Jallikattu?
Controversy surrounding Jallikattu stems from concerns related to animal welfare and the treatment of the bulls involved.
Animal rights activists argue that the sport inflicts unnecessary harm and cruelty on the bulls.
They claim that the bulls are often subjected to physical abuse, including being prodded, poked, and harassed by the participants, which can lead to injuries and distress.
Activists also highlight instances where the bulls are reportedly force-fed alcohol or chili powder to agitate them before the event.
How the Supreme Court has seen this case so far?
In 2014,the Supreme Court of India banned Jallikattu, citing animal welfare concerns. The court observed that the bulls used in the sport are often subjected to unnecessary pain and suffering.
The ban sparked protests in Tamil Nadu, where Jallikattu is deeply rooted in the cultural and social fabric. Supporters of Jallikattu argue that it is an integral part of Tamil tradition and should be preserved as a cultural heritage.
They claim that proper regulations and safeguards can be implemented to ensure the welfare of the animals without completely banning the sport.
The controversy surrounding Jallikattu intensified in 2017 when widespread protests erupted in Tamil Nadu against the ban. The protests gained momentum, with people demanding the revival of the sport and a reversal of the court's decision.
Eventually, in 2017, the Tamil Nadu government passed an amendment to the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, which exempted Jallikattu from the ban and allowed its practice under certain regulations. This move received mixed reactions, with some celebrating it as a victory for tradition and others expressing disappointment over what they perceived as a compromise on animal welfare.
What happened after the 2014 ban by the Supreme Court?
The Supreme Court over-ruled its 2014 judgement, which had essentially outlawed sports like Jalikattu, Kambala and Bullock Cart race.
In 2017, the Tamil Nadu government amended the PCA act thereby allowing jallikattu in the state. The state government sought exemption on grounds to preserve the cultural heritage of Tamil Nadu and to ensure survival and well-being of native breeds of bulls.
Following the Tamil Nadu, Karnataka government amended the PCA Act in Jan- 2017 to pave the way for Kambala.
In July-2017, Mahrashtra government also followed the suit.
What is the latest Supreme Court judgement all about?
Tamil Nadu Amendment Act is not a piece of colourable legislation.
2017 amendment act minimises cruelty to animals in the concerned sports.
The sports will not come under the definition of cruelty defined in the 1960 Act.
2017 amendment does not violate Article 51-A (g) and 51-A(h), which imposes duties of Indian citizen to protect the environment and develop scientific temper.
The amendment does not violate Article 14 and 21.
What is doctrine of colourable legislation?
The doctrine of colourable legislation is a legal principle used to determine the constitutional validity of a law or legislation. It refers to a situation where a law appears to be valid on its face, but its true purpose is to circumvent constitutional limitations or deceive the courts or the public.
The term "colourable" means something that appears to be true or genuine but is, in fact, false or deceptive. In the context of legislation, it refers to a law that is enacted under the pretense of exercising a valid legislative power, but its actual purpose is to achieve an unconstitutional objective.
What is Kambala?
Kambala is a traditional sport that originated in the southern coastal region of Karnataka, India. It is a form of buffalo racing that has been practiced for centuries in rural communities.
Kambala is usually held in the months of November to March during the harvest season.
In Kambala, two buffalo racers called "jockeys" run through a muddy paddy field while holding onto a wooden plow. The jockeys are typically barefoot and are often seen wearing colorful attire.
The buffaloes used in the race are specially bred and trained for this purpose. They are typically guided by the jockey, who tugs at the plow to urge the buffaloes to run faster.
Kambala is not only a sporting event but also a significant cultural celebration in the region. The races are often accompanied by traditional music and dance performances, and the entire community comes together to participate in the festivities. Kambala is seen as a way to honor and showcase the agricultural heritage of the region.
What is Bullock Cart race festival of Maharashtra?
Bullock cart racing starts from November and lasts till May.
It is a cultural activity and popular amongst farming community in Alibag Taluka in Maharashtra.
Local Bullock art owners and farmers arrange this race mostly in their villages. Bullock cart owners pay obeisance to Shri Nageshwar during Vaikunth Chaturdashi Yatra at Awas.
The Maharashtrian version of bullock cart racing was known as Bailgada Sharyat, a 450-year-old tradition of the farmers of Konkan, western Maharashtra and Marathwada.
These cattle races formed an integral part of the Jatras or village fairs that were held between Makar Sankranti and the Monsoon months, a time when the farmers were not busy in the fields.
The money that is raised by the races is utilized for the betterment of the village and for the renovation of the local temples. In this manner, cattle racing in India is an adventure sport that also helped to raise funds for social causes.
Context: The Supreme Court on Tuesday cautioned the Enforcement Directorate (ED) against creating an “atmosphere of fear”, after the Chhattisgarh government alleged that the Central agency was “running amok” in the State to “implicate” Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel in a money laundering case linked to a ₹2,000crore liquor scam.
The Directorate of Enforcement
The Directorate of Enforcement is a multi-disciplinary organization mandated with investigation of offence of money laundering and violations of foreign exchange laws. the Directorate is under the administrative control of Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance, Government of India.
Evolution of directorate
The origin of this Directorate goes back to 1st May, 1956, when an ‘Enforcement Unit’ was formed in the Department of Economic Affairs for handling Exchange Control Laws violations under Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947 (FERA ’47). There were 02 branches – at Bombay and Calcutta.
In the year 1957, this Unit was renamed as ‘Enforcement Directorate’, and another branch was opened at Madras. In 1960, the administrative control of the Directorate was transferred from the Department of Economic Affairs to the Department of Revenue.
With the passage of time, FERA’ 47 was repealed and replaced by FERA, 1973. Presently, the Directorate is under the administrative control of Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance, Government of India.
With the onset of the process of economic liberalization, FERA, 1973, which was a regulatory law, was repealed and in its place, a new law viz. the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA) came into operation w.e.f. 1st June 2000. Further, in tune with the International Anti Money Laundering regime, the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA) was enacted and ED was entrusted with its enforcement w.e.f. 1st July 2005.
Recently, with the increase in number of cases relating to economic offenders taking shelter in foreign countries, the Government has passed the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, 2018 (FEOA) and ED is entrusted with its enforcement with effect from 21st April, 2018.
Statutory Functions
The statutory functions of the Directorate include enforcement of following Acts:
1.The Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA): It is a criminal law enacted to prevent money laundering and to provide for confiscation of property derived from, or involved in, money-laundering and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. ED has been given the responsibility to enforce the provisions of the PMLA by conducting investigation to trace the assets derived from proceeds of crime, to provisionally attach the property and to ensure prosecution of the offenders and confiscation of the property by the Special court.
2. The Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA): It is a civil law enacted to consolidate and amend the laws relating to facilitate external trade and payments and to promote the orderly development and maintenance of foreign exchange market in India. ED has been given the responsibility to conduct investigation into suspected contraventions of foreign exchange laws and regulations, to adjudicate and impose penalties on those adjudged to have contravened the law.
3. The Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, 2018 (FEOA): This law was enacted to deter economic offenders from evading the process of Indian law by remaining outside the jurisdiction of Indian courts. It is a law whereby Directorate is mandated to attach the properties of the fugitive economic offenders who have escaped from the India warranting arrest and provide for the confiscation of their properties to the Central Government.
4. The Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 (FERA): The main functions under the repealed FERA are to adjudicate the Show Cause Notices issued under the said Act upto 31.5.2002 for the alleged contraventions of the Act which may result in imposition of penalties and to pursue prosecutions launched under FERA in the concerned courts.
5. Sponsoring agency under COFEPOSA: Under the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA), this Directorate is empowered to sponsor cases of preventive detention with regard to contraventions of FEMA.
Structure of Directorate of Enforcement
It is headed by Director of Enforcement and it is headquartered in New Delhi.
It has five regional offices headed by Special Directors and are located in Mumbai , Chennai , Kolkata, Chandigarh and New Delhi.
Further it has 10 zonal and 11 sub zonal offices headed by Deputy Directors and Assistant Directors respectively.
►EXTENDING TENURE OF ED CHIEF Central Vigilance Commission (Amendment) Act, 2021 has extended the tenure of Director of Enforcement Directorate one year at a time, maximum up to five years. The Amendment provides that in public interest, the tenure of Director of ED can be extended up to 1 year at a time on the recommendation of the Committee in writing. The bill extends the tenure up to a maximum period of 5 years in total including the period mentioned in the initial appointment. This means that the Director apart from his fixed tenure of two- years, can get three extensions of 1 year each by the central government.
Jurisdiction
Both FEMA or PMLA applies to the whole India including Jammu and Kashmir. So, the Enforcement Directorate can take action against any person on which this act applies.
The agency has jurisdiction over a person or any other legal entity who commits a crime whether he is a politician or a businessman. All the public servants come under the jurisdiction of the agency if they are involved in any offence related to the money laundering.
Reporting Matter to ED
A person cannot directly approach Enforcement Directorate. If someone wants to report a matter related to the violation of FEMA or PMLA act, he has to register a complaint with any other agency or Police than ED.
ED cannot take an action suo motu. One has to complaint to any other agency or Police first and then ED will investigate the matter and will identify the accused.
Functioning of ED under The Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 ( PMLA )
The PMLA was brought in 2002, but was enacted only in 2005. The objective was to prevent parking of the money outside India and to trace out the layering and the trail of money.
So as per the Act, the ED got its power to investigate under Sections 48 (authorities under act) and 49 (appointment and powers of authorities and other officers).
If money has been laundered abroad, the PMLA court (constituted as per the Act) has the right to send a letter of rogatory under Section 105 (reciprocal arrangements regarding processes) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The said government can then share the documents and evidence needed by the agency.
Whenever any offence is registered by a local police station, which has generated proceeds of crime over and above ₹1 crore, the investigating police officer forwards the details to the ED.
Alternately, if the offence comes under the knowledge of the Central agency, they can then call for the First Information Report (FIR) or the chargesheet if it that has been filed directly by police officials. This will be done to find out if any laundering has taken place.
The ED carries out search (property) and seizure (money/documents) after it has decided that the money has been laundered, under Section 16 (power of survey) and Section 17 (search and seizure) of the PMLA.
On the basis of that, the authorities will decide if arrest is needed as per Section 19 (power of arrest). Under Section 50 (powers of authorities regarding summons, production of documents and to give evidence etc), the ED can also directly carry out search and seizure without calling the person for questioning. It is not necessary to summon the person first and then start with the search and seizure.
If the person is arrested, the ED gets 60 days to file the prosecution complaint (chargesheet) as the punishment under PMLA doesn’t go beyond seven years. If no one is arrested and only the property is attached, then the prosecution complaint along with attachment order is to be submitted before the adjudicating authority within 60 days.
Context: The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has taken suo motu cognisance of a media report that cited a 250-300% increase in the circulation of child sexual abuse material (CSAM) on social media in India. The NHRC said the content is of foreign origin, and Indian investigation agencies have not come across any Indian-made child sexual abuse material so far.
Why are we covering it?
Because UPSC main syllabus has this line
Since NHRC is an important statutory body, we should cover it.
Also, it is always in news because of its functioning. More often than not we see it as an enervated organization unable to serve the primary objective: Protection of human Rights.
This can be substantiated by following instances:
In June 2016, the current chair of the NHRC and former chief justice of India, HL Dattu, described this institution over which he presided as “a toothless tiger.
In 2017, the Supreme Court of India seemed to support Justice Dattu’s remarks while dealing with the alleged extra-judicial killings of 1,528 persons in Manipur by police and armed forces.
So it behoves us to prepare the Issues and challenges plaguing NHRC (Mains perspective). As far as prelims perspectives is concerned, that is straight forward and you can find it in Prelims Pointer and/or PDF.
What is NHRC?
The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) of India was established on 12 October, 1993. The statute under which it is established is the Protection of Human Rights Act (PHRA), 1993 as amended by the Protection of Human Rights (Amendment) Act, 2006.
It is in conformity with the Paris Principles, adopted at the first international workshop on national institutions for the promotion and protection of human rights held in Paris in October 1991, and endorsed by the General Assembly of the United Nations by its Regulations 48/134 of 20 December, 1993.
The NHRC is an embodiment of India’s concern for the promotion and protection of human rights.
Section 2(1)(d) of the PHRA defines Human Rights as the rights relating to life, liberty, equality and dignity of the individual guaranteed by the Constitution or embodied in the International Covenants and enforceable by courts in India.
Composition Of The Commission
The Commission consists of a Chairperson, five full-time Members and seven deemed Members. The statute lays down qualifications for the appointment of the Chairperson and Members of the Commission.
There are four other members. These are:
There should be one Member who is, or has been, a Judge of the Supreme Court.
There should be one Member who is, or has been, the Chief Justice of the High Court.
Two other members should be there who have the knowledge or practical experience in matters related to human rights.
The ex officio members of the Commission can be:
The Chairpersons of the National Commission for Minorities,
The Chairpersons of the National Commission for Women,
The Chairperson of the National Commission for Scheduled Castes, and
The Chairperson of the National Commission for Scheduled Tribe.
Appointment of the members
On the recommendation of a committee, the President of India appoints the chairperson and the members of the National Human Rights Commission. The committee consists of the following members:
Prime Minister of India [CHAIRPERSON]
Home Minister of India
Speaker of Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition [Lok Sabha]
Leader of Opposition [Rajya Sabha]
Deputy Chairperson of Rajya Sabha
The Commission shall, perform all or any of the following functions, namely:-
Inquire, on its own initiative or on a petition presented to it by a victim or any person on his behalf, into complaint of-
violation of human rights or abetment oR
negligence in the prevention of such violation, by a public servant;
intervene in any proceeding involving any allegation of violation of human rights pending before a court with the approval of such court;
visit, under intimation to the State Government, any jail or any other institution under the control of the State Government, where persons are detained or lodged for purposes of treatment, reformation or protection to study the living condition of the inmates and make recommendations thereon;
review the safeguards by or under the Constitution or any law for the time being in force for the protection of human rights and recommend measures for their effective implementation;
review the factors, including acts of terrorism that inhibit the enjoyment of human rights and recommend appropriate remedial measures;
study treaties and other international instruments on human rights and make recommendations for their effective implementation;
Issues and challenges of NHRC
Autonomy of the NHRC
The Commission is supposed to be completely independent in its functioning, even though the Protection of Human Rights Act, (PHRA), 1993 does not say so.
In fact, there are provisions in the Act which underscore the dependence of the Commission on the government.
For example:
Section 11 of the Act makes it dependent on the government for its manpower requirements.
Section 32 of the Act makees it financially dependent on the central government:
Central govt. shall pay to the Commission by way of grants such sums of money as it may consider fit.
Thus, in respect of the two most important requirements i.e. human resources and money, the Commission is not independent.
Even the limited finds are not being used for human rights related functions
Large chunks of the budget of commissions go in office expenses, leaving disproportionately small amounts for other crucial areas such as research and rights awareness programmes.
Lacks enforcing powers
NHRC does not have the backing of the Protection of Human Rights Act to penalise authorities which do not implement its orders hence maming it impossible for NHRC’s recommendations do not reach to the ground level as the
The Act does not categorically empower the NHRC to act when human rights violations through private parties take place.
Lacks specialized persons who have dealt in Human rights issues
The Act requires that three of the five members of a human rights commission must be former judges but does not specify whether these judges should have a proven record of human rights activism or expertise or qualifications in the area.
Regarding the other two members, the Act is vague, saying simply: “persons having knowledge and experience of human rights.
Bureaucratic style of functioning of govt staff :
On top of that, as human rights commissions primarily draw their staff from government departments – either on deputation or reemployment after retirement – the internal atmosphere is usually just like any other government office.
Strict hierarchies are maintained, which often makes it difficult for complainants to obtain documents or information about the status of their case.
As non-judicial member positions are increasingly being filled by ex-bureaucrats, credence is given to the contention that the NHRC is more an extension of the government, rather than an independent agency exercising oversight.
Delay in disposal of cases
Expectations from the commission was to keep a tight grip on its disposal, so that pendency was not allowed to increase.
Unfortunately, this did not happen and the number of cases pending with the Commission has been increasing sharply every year.
Under staffed:
Either the Commission needs to get its staff strength increased or change methods of disposal so that the backlog of accumulated undisposed cases does not become heavy.
Low level of awareness about the Human rights in populace
Among general populace
An awareness of rights is not institutionalized in our curriculum.
It is limited both in geography and knowledge as far as the public is concerned.
Among Lawenforcers (Primary violators)
Eighty per cent of the training of a policeman in India is devoted to regimentation and a very little time was left to develop forensic skills or human rights awareness.
Knowledge of the laws and one’s interpretation are limited to small groups of people who are educated and legally literate.
Delay in publication of reports:
Delay in publication of annual reports by two or three years has been a constant problem. Annual reports for calendar years should be put online as soon as possible and no later than March of the succeeding year.
The hard copy of the report should also be published at the same time.
Constrained against armed forces
Since a very large number of complaints of human rights violations are directed against the members of the “armed forces”, the Act obviously weakens the NHRC’s effectiveness in providing redress to the public in such cases.
All that the Commission, under Section 19 of the Act can do is to call for reports from the central government in such cases and then make recommendations to the government or not “proceed with the complaint” at all. Under the Act, the Commission has no power to enforce its decisions. The Act must be amended to make the Commission a strong, and vibrant institution, supporting democracy and good governance.
Preventing the NHRC from independently investigating complaints against the military and security forces not only compounds the problems but also furthers impunity.
So, NHRC has to develop a strong image as a protector of the poor, marginalised and vulnerable groups. But that will not be possible without substantial changes in the legal framework itself.
Context: Ministry of Ports, Shipping & Waterways has secured 2nd position among 66 ministries in the Data Governance Quality Index.
Data Governance Quality Index 2023
Data Governance Quality Index (DGQI) survey aims to measure the maturity level of administrative data systems and their use in decision-making of various Ministries & Departments on the implementation of Central Sector Schemes and Centrally Sponsored Schemes.
Also identifies reforms to reach the frontier of seamless data exchange and its synergistic use within the ministry, while defining clear pathways to achieve these goals.
This index is published by Development Monitoring & Evaluation Office (DMEO) under Niti Aayog.
Methodology of Data Governance Quality Index
Data Generation: Measures ability of respective ministries/departments to efficiently generate data for program implementation.
Data Quality: Covers processes of scientifically and statistically evaluating data to determine whether they meet quality benchmarks.
Use of Technology: Assesses if emerging technologies are being utilised to improve data robustness.
Data Analysis, Use & Dissemination: Covers if collected data is being analysed and used for evidence creation and decision making.
Data Security & Human Resource Capacity: Assesses if antivirus updates and internal audit systems are in place to ensure data is not corrupted or prone to areas.
Case Studies: Focuses on any intervention at Ministry/Department level or any innovative approach can be highlighted as case studies.
Significance of Data driven governance
Enables policymakers to identify trends, opportunities and areas for improvement accurately.
Enables policymakers to make informed decisions that lead to better outcomes for citizens.
Data driven decision making leads to economies and cost-effective solutions.
Enhances transparency and makes it easier to track the progress of schemes and policies.
Context: Five years ago, a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court advised the Centre, acting through the Lieutenant Governor, and the Delhi government led by Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal to follow the path of “collaborative federalism”. The term, coined by the court in its July 2018 judgment, merely meant that the Centre and the Delhi government should lay aside their differences, show mature statesmanship in their relationship. The five judge Bench had held that the two powers —Centre and Delhi government — were “interdependent”.
ADMINISTRATION OF DELHI
• Delhi State Legislative Assembly having a Chief Minister came into being in 1952 under Government of Part-C States Act, 1951. (Chief Commissioners Province)
• The States Reorganisation Act, 1957, conferred UT status on Delhi, to be administered by an Administrator appointed by President.
• Limited representative government was provided by the Delhi Administration Act, 1966.
• Constitution 69thAmendment added Article 239AA & Article 239AB which was gave constitutional status and the National Capital Territory of Delhi (GNCT) Act, 1991 was enacted based on recommendations of Balakrishnan Committee Report.
• Election Commission under Article 324 conducts elections to Legislative Assembly of Delhi.
ARTICLE 239AA - SPECIAL PROVISIONS WITH RESPECT TO DELHI
Provides that Legislative Assembly of Delhi can legislate on matters in State & Concurrent List except – State List: Entry 1–Public Order; Entry 2 – Police; Entry 18 – Land.
DELHI HIGH COURT JUDGMENT – 2016
It declared Delhi as a UT, with LG as administrative head having discretionary powers.
SC JUDGMENT – 2018
• Reversed Delhi HC Order - stated that Article 239AA provides for representative government with Council of Ministers to aid and advice the LG except on matters he refers to the president.
• Court Focussed on Collaborative Federalism – “The Union government and the State governments should endeavour to address the common problems with the intention of arriving at a solution by showing statesmanship, combined action and sincere cooperation. In collaborative federalism, the Union and the State governments should express their readiness to achieve the common objective and work together for it.”
• If difference arises on any matter, LG has to send it to the President.
• However, LG cannot refer every matter to the President as Article 239AA (4) mentions about “any matter”.
SALIENT FEATURES OF GOVT. OF NCT DELHI ACT, 1991
• Special address by Lieutenant Governor: At the first session after election of Legislative assembly and at the first session of each year.
• Matters in which Lieutenant Governor to act in his discretion, which falls outside purview of powers of Legislative Assembly; matters in which powers or functions are entrusted or delegated to LG by the President; where LG under any law is required to act in his discretion, where LG is to exercise any judicial or quasi-judicial functions.
• President shall make rules for procedure to be adopted in the case of a difference of opinion between the Lieutenant Governor and the Council of Ministers or a Minister.
• All executive action of the Lieutenant Governor shall be expressed to be taken in the name of the Lieutenant Governor.
• Duties of Chief Minister: To communicate to LG all decisions of Council of Ministers relating to administration of the Capital and proposals for legislation, to furnish such information relating to the administration of the Capital and proposals for legislation as LG may call for & if the Lieutenant Governor so requires, to submit for the consideration of Council of Ministers any matter on which a decision has been taken by a Minister but which has not been considered by the Council.
PROVISION IN CASE OF FAILURE OF CONSTITUTIONAL MACHINERY IN NCT OF DELHI (ARTICLE 239AB)
• President after receiving report of LG may suspend the operation of Article 239AA or any law made under Article 239AA for one year.
• President’s order under Article 239AB shall expire at the end of one year from the date of issue of the order and the provisions of clauses (2) and (3) of Article 356 shall apply to such order as they apply to a Proclamation issued under clause (1) of Article 356.
GOVERNMENT OF NCT DELHI AMENDMENT (2021)
• The term “government” referred in any law made by Legislative Assembly will imply LG of Delhi.
• Rules regulating procedure and conduct of business in Delhi Assembly to be consistent with Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha.
• Prohibits Delhi Assembly from making any rule to enable itself or its committees to: (i) consider matters of day-to-day administration of NCT of Delhi (ii) conduct any inquiry in relation to administrative decisions.
• The Amendment adds that on certain matters, as specified by the LG, his opinion must be obtained before taking any executive action on the decisions of the Minister/ Council of Ministers.