Constitution & Polity of India

Gujarat HC sets aside CIC order seeking information on Prime Minister’s MA degree, fines Arvind Kejriwal

Central Information Commission

  • It is constituted under the provision of Section-12 of RTI Act 2005.
  • The Central Information Commission shall consist of the Chief Information Commissioner (CIC) and such number of Central Information Commissioners not exceeding 10 as may be deemed necessary. 
  • The jurisdiction of the Commission extends over all Central Public Authorities.

Appointment

Chief information Commissioner and other commissioners are appointed by the president on the recommendation of a committee for which Section 12(3) of the RTI Act 2005 provides as follows :

(i) The Prime Minister, who shall be the Chairperson of the committee;
(ii) The Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha ; and
(iii) A Union Cabinet Minister to be nominated by the Prime Minister.

Eligibility 

  • The Chief Information Commissioner and Information Commissioners shall be persons of eminence in public life with wide knowledge and experience in law, science and technology, social service, management, journalism, mass media or administration and governance.
  • The Chief Information Commissioner or an Information Commissioner shall not be a Member of Parliament or Member of the Legislature of any State or Union Territory as the case may be , or hold any other office of profit or connected with any political party or carrying on any business or pursuing any profession.

Term of office 

  • The Chief Information Commissioner shall hold office for such term as may be prescribed by the Central Government and shall not be eligible for reappointment
  • No Chief Information Commissioner shall hold office as such after he has attained the age of sixty-five years.
  • Every Information Commissioner shall hold office for such term as may be prescribed by the Central Government or till he attains the age of sixty-five years, whichever is earlier, and shall not be eligible for reappointment as such Information Commissioner. 
  • However, Information commissioners are eligible for appointment as the Chief Information Commissioner .

Removal

  • The Chief Information Commissioner or any Information Commissioner shall be removed from his office only by order of the President on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity. 
  • Removal can be done only after the inquiry report of the Supreme Court ,on a reference made to it by the President.

Powers and functions of Information Commissions

  1. As per the RTI Act 2005, it shall be the duty of the Central Information Commission or State Information Commission, as the case may be, to receive and inquire into a complaint from any person,

(a) Who has been unable to submit a request to a Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer

(b) Who has been refused access to any information requested under this Act

(c) Who has not been given a response to a request for information or access to information within the time limit specified under this Act

(d) Who has been required to pay an amount of fee which he or she considers unreasonable

(e) Who believes that he or she has been given incomplete, misleading or false information under this Act 

(f) In respect of any other matter relating to requesting or obtaining access to records under this Act.

2. Where the Central Information Commission or State Information Commission, as the case may be, is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds to inquire into the matter, it may initiate an inquiry in respect thereof. ( i.e. Suo moto power)

3. The Central Information Commission or State Information Commission, as the case may be, shall, while inquiring into any matter under this section, have the same powers as are vested in a civil court .

Karnataka notifies 10% EWS quota on eve of announcement of poll schedule

Context: 

  • Days after scrapping the 2B Category for Muslims under the OBC quota and on the eve of the announcement of the Assembly elections, the Karnataka government notified the Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category to provide 10% reservation in education and employment.
  • Muslims have been included under this category as per the Cabinet decision taken last week. The order issued on March 28, the day before the model code of conduct came into force, stated that those castes that do not enjoy reservation status provided to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and are not in the list of backward classes and communities transferred to the EWS reservation from the backward classes will be eligible for 10% reservation. The five communities of Brahmins, Arya Vysyas, Mudaliars, Jains, and Nagarathas have been identified to benefit from the EWS reservation in Karnataka. Muslims are the new addition.

Disclaimer: In order to understand the topic as controversial as reservation, We have to wear the veil of ignorance.

The veil of ignorance is a thought experiment proposed by philosopher John Rawls to help individuals think about justice and fairness in society. It asks individuals to imagine that they are behind a veil of ignorance, where they do not know their social status, class, race, gender, or other personal characteristics.
In the case of reservations, the veil of ignorance could help individuals consider the issue from a neutral standpoint, without being influenced by their own personal experiences or biases. By doing so, individuals can think about the issue of reservations solely based on principles of justice and fairness, rather than their own interests or identities.
Wearing the veil of ignorance can help individuals understand the perspectives of both supporters and opponents of reservations, and can help promote a more rational and balanced discussion around the issue. 

Why do we need to cover this? 

  • The debate around reservation is centered on the practice of providing preferential treatment to individuals or groups who have historically faced social, economic, and educational disadvantages. In many countries, including India, the United States, and South Africa, reservations are implemented in education, employment, and political representation.
  • On one hand, supporters of reservations argue that they are necessary to correct historical injustices and provide opportunities for marginalized communities. They argue that without affirmative action programs, members of disadvantaged groups would continue to be excluded from positions of power and influence.
  • On the other hand, opponents of reservations argue that they are discriminatory and violate the principle of meritocracy. They argue that reservations create a system where people are chosen based on their identity rather than their abilities, leading to inefficiencies and lowering the overall quality of institutions.
  • Additionally, there are debates around the efficacy of reservations in achieving their intended goals. Some argue that while reservations may provide temporary relief, they do not address the root causes of social and economic inequality and may even perpetuate the marginalization of certain groups.

Overall, the debate around reservation is complex and multifaceted, with both supporters and opponents presenting valid arguments.

Apart from this, the syllabus of GS Paper II clearly expects us to has a clear understanding of this debate: 

Syllabus: 

General Studies- II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International relations.

  • Indian Constitution—historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.

Hence, we will: 

  • What is reservation? 
  • Constitutional Provisions regarding Reservation 
  • What are the recent debates regarding reservation? 
  • Issues associated with reservation in India:
  • Way Forward

What is reservation? 

  • It is a form of affirmative action whereby a percentage of seats are reserved in the government service and educational institutions for the socially and educationally backward communities and the Scheduled Castes and Tribes who are inadequately represented in these services and institutions.

Constitutional Provisions regarding Reservation 

  • Article 15 (4) allows the State to make any special provision for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes of citizens or for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. This provision was extended to admission in educational institutions by 93rd Amendment Act, 2006 (except minority educational institutions) 
  • Article 16 (4) allows State to make any provision for the reservation of appointments or posts in favour of any backward class of citizens which, in the opinion of the State, is not adequately represented in the services under the State. 
  • Article 16(4A), empowers state to make provisions for reservation in matters of promotion to SC/ST employees. 
  • Article 46 states that the State shall promote with special care the educational and economic interests of the weaker sections of the people, and, in particular, of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, and shall protect them from social injustice and all forms of exploitation. 
  • Article 243D provides reservation of seats for SCs and STs in every Panchayat. 
  • Article 243T provides reservation of seats for SCs and STs in every Municipality. 
  • Article 330 states that seats shall be reserved in the Lok Sabha for the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes. 
  • Article 332 of the Constitution of India provides for reservation of seats for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes in the Legislative Assemblies of the States.

Reservation in India is a complex and controversial issue. While it was introduced as a measure to address historical and structural inequalities, it has also been criticized for creating new forms of inequality and perpetuating caste-based divisions.

What are the recent debates regarding reservation? 

  • Sub categorization of OBC: The idea is to create sub-categories within the larger group of OBCs for the purpose of reservation. OBCs are granted 27% reservation in jobs and education under the central government. This has been a legal debate for other reservation categories too: in September last year, a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court reopened the debate on sub-categorisation of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes for reservations.
  • Dominant castes demanding reservation: Marathas, Patels, Jats, Kapus and others are asking for reservations today, preferably through their recognition as Other Backward Classes. This demand reflects the challenges they are facing on the job market.
  • Reservation to Muslims and Christians: Currently, the constitutional right to reservations in jobs and education as a member of the SC community is extended only to people from Hindu, Sikh or Buddhist faiths, in accordance with the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950.
  • Local reservation in private sector: Haryana State Employment of Local Candidates Act, 2020 was passed reserving 75% of private sector jobs for people of the state.

Issues associated with reservation in India:

  1. Debate around meritocracy: One of the main arguments against reservation is that it goes against the principle of meritocracy, which is the idea that individuals should be rewarded based on their abilities and hard work, rather than their social background. Critics argue that reservation policies favor candidates from certain castes or communities, regardless of their abilities or qualifications, and therefore undermine the concept of meritocracy.
  2. Limited impact: While reservation has been in place for several decades, it has not been able to fully address the issue of caste-based discrimination and inequality. Many argue that it has only benefited a small section of the population, leaving the majority of Dalits and other marginalized groups outside its purview.
  3. Backlash from dominant castes: Reservation has often been met with resistance from dominant castes, who see it as a threat to their own interests and privileges. This has led to tensions and conflicts between different caste groups, and in some cases, even violence.
  4. Political manipulation: Reservation policies have been used by political parties as a tool to gain votes and maintain power. This has led to the creation of new caste-based political alliances and the use of reservation quotas as a bargaining chip in electoral politics.
  5. Inadequate implementation: Despite the existence of reservation policies, many institutions and organizations continue to discriminate against marginalized groups. The implementation of reservation policies has been uneven and often marred by corruption and inefficiency, which has limited their impact.

Way Forward:

Improving the reservation system in India requires a multi-pronged approach that addresses its various shortcomings. Here are some ways in which the reservation system in India could be improved:

  1. Ensure effective implementation: One of the biggest challenges with the reservation system in India is the lack of effective implementation. There is a need to ensure that reservation policies are implemented in a transparent and efficient manner, and that benefits reach the intended beneficiaries.
  2. Expand the scope of reservation: Reservation policies could be expanded to include other marginalized groups such as economically weaker sections, transgender individuals, and people with disabilities, who face discrimination and exclusion.
  3. Address the issue of creamy layer: The creamy layer refers to the affluent sections within reserved categories who benefit from reservation policies and may not necessarily require them. There is a need to exclude the creamy layer from reservation benefits to ensure that the benefits reach the most disadvantaged sections.
  4. Encourage merit-based affirmative action: Reservation policies could be supplemented by other measures that promote merit-based affirmative action. For example, institutions could adopt diversity targets, scholarships, and mentorship programs to support underprivileged students.
  5. Focus on quality education: Improving the quality of education in marginalized communities is critical to reducing the dependence on reservation policies. Investment in quality education infrastructure, teacher training, and curriculum development could go a long way in promoting equality and social mobility.
  6. Promote social awareness and dialogue: Creating a social awareness and dialogue around the issues of caste and reservation is important to promote greater understanding and acceptance of the need for affirmative action policies. This could be done through public education campaigns, media outreach, and community engagement programs.

Overall, reservation in India is a complex issue that needs to be approached with nuance and sensitivity. While it has helped to address some forms of inequality, it has also created new challenges that need to be addressed.

By polls to one Lok Sabha, 4 Assembly seats on May 10

Context: The Election Commission of India has announced by polls for one Lok Sabha seat and four Assembly constituencies, to be held on May 10, with results on May 13.

What is By poll or bye election?

  • In India, a by-election (also known as a by poll or bye-election) is an election held to fill a vacancy in the Lok Sabha (the lower house of the Indian Parliament) or a state legislative assembly. 
  • These vacancies can occur due to various reasons such as the death, resignation or disqualification of a sitting member of parliament or the state assembly. 
  • By-elections are conducted by the Election Commission of India, which is an independent body responsible for organizing and overseeing elections at various levels of government in India. 
  • By-elections are usually held within six months of the vacancy occurring, although this can vary depending on the specific circumstances. 
  • Candidates from various political parties can contest the by-election, and the winner is elected to fill the vacant seat until the next general election. 
  • By-elections are important as they provide an opportunity for citizens to exercise their right to vote and elect a representative to fill a vacant seat in the legislative assembly or parliament. 
  • They also have the potential to impact the balance of power in parliament or the state assembly, as a single seat can sometimes make a significant difference in the overall composition of the house.

About Representation of the People Act, 1951

The provisions for the actual conduct of elections to the Houses of Parliament and to the House or Houses of the Legislature of each State, the qualifications and disqualifications for the membership of these Houses, the corrupt practices and other election offences, and the decision of election disputes were all left to be made in a subsequent measure. In order to provide for these provisions, the Representation of the People Act, 1951 was enacted. 

Broadly speaking, this Act contains provisions relating to the following electoral matters:

  1. Qualifications and disqualifications for membership of Parliament and State Legislatures. 
  2. Administrative machinery for the conduct of elections
  3. Registration of political parties 
  4. Conduct of elections 
  5. Corrupt practices and electoral offences
  6. Bye-elections and time limit for filling vacancies
  7. Barring the jurisdiction of civil courts

Constitutional bodies fighting corruption under attack, says PM Modi

Context: 

  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday launched a scathing attack against what he termed conspiracies by forces within and outside the country to undermine constitutional institutions that were cracking down on corruption and the corrupt. 
  • India is the world's largest democracy and has a well-established constitution that lays down the framework for its governance. Constitutional bodies are an integral part of the Indian democratic system, established to ensure the proper functioning of the government and safeguard the rights of its citizens. 
  • These bodies are independent, autonomous, and have their own powers and functions, which are enshrined in the constitution. From the Election Commission of India to the CAG, these bodies play a crucial role in upholding the principles of democracy, promoting accountability, and ensuring transparency in the functioning of the government. 
  • This write-up will provide a overview of the various constitutional bodies in India, their functions, and their significance in the country's democratic setup.

So it is important for us to cover the constitutional bodies along following items: (EXCEPT GST COUNCIL)

  • Articles in the constitution
  • Appointing authority
  • Tenure & Removal
  • Immunities
  • Eligible for further Appointment. 
  • Powers

Union Public Service Commission

  • It is the …… Well, if you are reading article this far the chances are that you already know what UPSC is. 
  • Articles: 315 – 323
  • Composition: 9 to 11 members
  • Tenure & removal: Presently for 6 years or 65 years (whichever is earlier) whichever is earlier
  • Further Appointment:
    • UPSC Chairman is not eligible for a second term. 
    • Other members are eligible only for an appointment within SPSC and UPSC
  • Powers: Recruitment of All India Services, public services of centrally administered territories, Central services, advisory powers. 

Goods and Services Tax Council (The latest, MOST DIFFERENT and hence the first to be covered)

  • The 101st Amendment Act of 2016 paved the way for the introduction of a new tax regime (i.e. goods and services tax - GST) in the country. 
  • The smooth and efficient administration of this tax requires co-operation and coordination between the centre and the states. 
  • In order to facilitate this consultation process, the amendment provided for the establishment of a Goods and Services Tax Council or the GST Council. 
  • While discharging its functions, the Council is to be guided by the need for a harmonised structure of GST and the development of a harmonised national market for goods and services. Further, the Council has to determine the procedure in the performance of its functions
  • Composition: The Council is a joint forum of the centre and the states and consists of the following members:
    • The Union Finance Minister as the Chairperson
    • The Union Minister of State in-charge of Revenue or Finance
    • The Minister in-charge of Finance or Taxation or any other Minister nominated by each state government

Working of the Council

  • The decisions of the Council are taken at its meetings. One-half of the total number of members of the Council is the quorum for conducting a meeting. Every decision of the Council is to be taken by a majority of not less than three-fourths of the weighted votes of the members present and voting at the meeting. The decision is taken in accordance with the following principles:
    • The vote of the central government shall have a weightage one-third of the total votes cast in that meeting.
    • The votes of all the state governments combined shall have weightage of two-thirds of the total votes cast in that meeting.

Attorney General of India

  • He is the highest law officer in the country
  • Articles 76, 88
  • Appointment by the president 
  • Important Immunities: 
  • Tenure & Removal: Holds office during the pleasure of the President
  • Eligible for further Appointment. 
  • Powers
    • Privileges of an MP (Right to Speech within Parliament). 
    • Right of an audience in all Indian courts. 
    • Right to attend both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha proceedings without right to vote.  

Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG)

  • He is the head of the Indian Audit and Accounts Department1. He is the guardian of the public purse and controls the entire financial system of the country at both the levels–the Centre and the state.
  • Article 148, 149, 150, 151 
  • Appointment by the president 
  • Important Immunities:
    • His salary and other service conditions are determined by the Parliament.
    • The administrative expenses of the office of the CAG, including all salaries, allowances and pensions of persons serving in that office are charged upon the Consolidated Fund of India. Thus, they are not subject to the vote of Parliament.
  • Tenure & removal: Holds the office for six years or 65 years (whichever comes earlier)
    • Removal is the same as for a judge of the Supreme Court
  • Not eligible for further appointment.
  • Powers
    • Audits accounts concerned with the Contingency Fund, the Consolidated Fund of India and states,  and the Public Accounts Fund of the states and centre.
    • Advisory function with respect to accounts to the country’s President

Election Commission

  • It  is a permanent and an independent body established by the Constitution of India directly to ensure free and fair elections in the country
  • Article: 324
  • Appointment by the president 
  • Composition: CEC/Chief Election Commissioner, Other Election Commissioners
  • Tenure & removal: Presently for 6 years or 65 years, whichever is earlier
  • Eligible for further appointment. 
  • Powers
    • Conduct of free and fair elections in India
    • Political parties’ registration
    • Overseeing elections

Finance Commission

  • It is constituted by the president of India every fifth year or at such earlier time as he considers necessary
  • Article: 280
  • Appointment by the President 
  • Composition: Chairman, Four members
  • Eligible for further appointment
  • Powers
    • Decides the basis for sharing the divisible taxes by the centre and the states
    • Any matter in the interest of sound finance can be referred to the President evaluates the rise in the Consolidated Fund of a state in order to affix the resources of the state Municipalities and Panchayats
    • FC has the powers of a civil court

National Commission for Scheduled Castes (Similarly for tribes and OBC)

  • It is an Indian constitutional body established with a view to provide safeguards against the exploitation of Scheduled Castes and Anglo Indian communities to promote and protect their social, educational, economic and cultural interests, special provisions were made in the Constitution. 
  • Articles 338
  • Composition
    • Chairman, Vice-chairman, 3 other members
    • Tenure & removal: 3 years
  • Eligible for further appointment
  • Powers
    • It is a quasi-judicial body
    • Monitoring and reporting about the implementation of constitutional safeguards for Scheduled Castes
    • It has a civil court’s powers

Special officer for Linguistic Minorities

  • Articles 350 B
  • Composition Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner, Assistant Commissioner
  • Tenure and removal: Pleasure of the President
  • Further appointment: Yes
  • Powers: Monitoring and reporting the working of constitutional safeguards for linguistic minorities

CEC in Assam: Delimitation, NRC can be simultaneous processes

Context: Various political parties in Assam had submitted to Election commission of India (ECI) to hold the delimitation exercise, till the conclusion of National Register of Citizen (NRC) process. In response to this chief election commissioner said that delimitation and NRC are “different issues” and there is no legal bar on carrying them out separately.

Delimitation Commission

The Delimitation Commission is established by Parliament under Article 82 to determine allocation of seats in the House of the People to the States based on 1971 Census and divide states into territorial constituencies based 2001 Census.

Delimitation means the act or process of fixing limits or boundaries of territorial constituencies in a country or a province having a legislative body. In India, the job of delimitation has been assigned to a high power body known as Delimitation Commission or Boundary Commission.

Four Delimitation Commission have been constituted since independence

1952 – under Delimitation Commission Act, 1952

1963 -  under Delimitation Commission Act, 1962

1973 - under Delimitation Commission Act, 1972

2002 - under Delimitation Commission Act, 2002

Orders of Delimitation Commission cannot be called in question before any Court of law. 

The copies of its orders are laid before the House of People and the State Legislative Assembly concerned, but no modifications are permissible therein by them. 

The Central Government shall constitute a Commission to be called the Delimitation Commission which shall consist of three members as follows: 

(a) one member, who shall be a person who is or has been a Judge of the Supreme Court, to be appointed by the Central Government who shall be the Chairperson of the Commission; 

(b) the Chief Election Commissioner or an Election Commissioner nominated by the Chief Election Commissioner, ex officio: 

(c) the State Election Commissioner of concerned State, ex officio. 

The Commission shall determine its own procedure and shall, in the performance of its functions, have all the powers of a civil court under the Code of Civil Procedure. 

Role played by delimitation commission 

  • Balance of representation to achieve the ideals of ‘One Vote One Value’ 
  • Ensure adequate representation to vulnerable sections including SC/ST. 
  • Fair division of geographical areas for adequate representation of diverse communities. 

Challenges 

  • Delimitation exercise is restricted by Constitution 84th and 87th Amendment. 
  • This has frozen the seats in Lok Sabha and State Assemblies till 2026. 
  • Seats reserved for SC and ST population also remains frozen and increasing population of vulnerable section is not accounted for. 

Thus the need of the hour is to develop a National consensus exercise for undertaking delimitation along with 2031 census to ensure adequate representation of states and vulnerable sections of India. 

National Register of Population (NRC)

  • The National Register of Citizens (NRC) is the register containing names of Indian citizens. The only time that a National Register of Citizens (NRC) was prepared was in 1951 when after conduct of the Census of 1951, the NRC was prepared by recording particulars of all the persons enumerated during that Census.
  • It was only done by the state of Assam , though it was mandated for all the states. However, recently Home Ministry has expressed, that it is planning to do this process for entire country.
  • Citizenship being a subject of the Union List, policy decisions, guidelines and funds for NRC updation are provided by the Central Government but its implementation is done through the State Government machinery under the guidance of the Registrar General of India who functions as the Registrar General of Citizen Registration under Rule 15 of Citizenship Rules, 2003 as amended in 2009 and 2010.
  • The provisions governing NRC updation are The Citizenship Act, 1955, and The Citizenship (Registration of Citizens and Issue of National Identity cards) Rules, 2003 (prepared under The Citizenship Act, 1955).

Amid protests, Finance Bill approved by both Houses

Context: The government has completed its budgetary exercise for 2023­24 (Like every year), with both Houses of Parliament approving the Finance Bill, 2023, along with a fresh amendment introduced by Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman to rectify an error in the Securities Transaction Tax rates on option contracts in the earlier version of the Bill.

Money bills and Finance bills are interrelated. A financial bill (I) is a bill that contains not only any or all the matters mentioned in Article 110, but also other matters of general legislation.

So if we understand the Money Bill, we can understand the Finance Bill. Hence, Article 110 and Article 111 (Which contain the provisions related to Money Bill) is of utmost importance for comprehending the provisions related to Budget. 

What is a Money Bills? 

Article 110 of the Constitution deals with the definition of money bills. It states that a bill is deemed to be a money bill if it contains ‘only’ provisions dealing with all or any of the following matters:

  1. The imposition, abolition, remission, alteration or regulation of any tax;
  2. The regulation of the borrowing of money by the Union government;
  3. The custody of the Consolidated Fund of India or the contingency fund of India, the payment of money into or the withdrawal of money from any such fund;
  4. The appropriation of money out of the Consolidated Fund of India;
  5. Declaration of any expenditure charged on the Consolidated Fund of India or increasing the amount of any such expenditure;
  6. The receipt of money on account of the Consolidated Fund of India or the public account of India or the custody or issue of such money, or the audit of the accounts of the Union or of a state; or
  7. Any matter incidental to any of the matters specified above.

However, a bill is not to be deemed to be a money bill by reason only that it provides for:

  1. the imposition of fines or other pecuniary penalties, or
  2. the demand or payment of fees for licenses or fees for services rendered; or
  3. The imposition, abolition, remission, alteration or regulation of any tax by any local authority or body for local purposes. 

If any question arises whether a bill is a money bill or not, the decision of the Speaker of the Lok Sabha is final. His decision in this regard cannot be questioned in any court of law or in the either House of Parliament or even the president. When a money bill is transmitted to the Rajya Sabha for recommendation and presented to the president for assent, the Speaker endorses it as a money bill.

What is the procedure for passing of money bill in parliament?

  • The Constitution lays down a special procedure for the passing of money bills in the Parliament. A money bill can only be introduced in the Lok Sabha and that too on the recommendation of the president. Every such bill is considered to be a government bill and can be introduced only by a minister. 
  • It cannot reject or amend a money bill. It can only make the recommendations. It must return the bill to the Lok Sabha within 14 days, whether with or without recommendations. The Lok Sabha can either accept or reject all or any of the recommendations of the Rajya Sabha.
  • If the Lok Sabha accepts any recommendation, the bill is then deemed to have been passed by both the Houses in the modified form. If the Lok Sabha does not accept any recommendation, the bill is then deemed to have passed by both the Houses in the form originally passed by the Lok Sabha without any change.
  • If the Rajya Sabha does not return the bill to the Lok Sabha within 14 days, the bill is deemed to have been passed by both the Houses in the form originally passed by the Lok Sabha. Thus, the Lok Sabha has more powers than Rajya Sabha with regard to a money bill. On the other hand, both the Houses have equal powers with regard to an ordinary bill.

Finally, when a money bill is presented to the president, he may either give his assent to the bill or withhold his assent to the bill but cannot return the bill for reconsideration of the Houses. Normally, the president gives his assent to a money bill as it is introduced in the Parliament with his prior permission. 

Difference between Money Bill and Ordinary Bill 

S.N.Money BillOrdinary Bill
1.It can be introduced in the Lok Sabha only not in the Rajya SabhaIt can be introduced in either house of parliament. 
2.It can be intruded in the Lok Sabha only by a minister.It can be introduced either by a minister or by a private member
3.It can be introduced only of the recommendation of the president.Recommendation of president is not required.
4.It can’t be amended or rejected by the Rajya Sabha. The Rajya Sabha should return the bill with or without recommendations, which may be rejected or accepted by the Lok Sabha.It can be amended or rejected by the Rajya  Sabha. 
5.It can be detained by the Rajya Sabha for a maximum of 14 days only.Rajya Sabha can detain it for a maximum of 6 months.
6.It requires the certification of Lok Sabha speaker when transmitted to Rajya Sabha.If it is originated in the Lok Sabha, it does not require approval of speaker when transmitted to Rajya Sabha.
7.It is sent for approval of president even if it approved by the Lok Sabha only. There is no provision of joint sitting of both houses in this regard.It is sent to the president only when it is passed by the both houses of parliament. In case of deadlock between two houses, a joint sitting of both the houses can be called by the president.
8.If this bill is defeated in the Lok Sabha, then the entire council of ministers has to resign.Its defeat in the Lok Sabha may lead to the resignation of the government if it is introduced by a member.
9.It can be rejected or accepted but can’t be returned for reconsideration by the president (because earlier permission is taken from him).It can be rejected, accepted or returned for reconsideration by the president.

What are Finance Bills and How are they different or similar from Money Bills?

Financial Bills (I)

  • A financial bill (I) is a bill that contains not only any or all the matters mentioned in Article 110, but also other matters of general legislation.
    • For instance, a bill that contains a borrowing clause, but does not exclusively deal with borrowing. 
  • Similarities:In two respects, a financial bill (I) is similar to a money bill–
    • Both of them can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha and not in the Rajya Sabha, and 
    • Both of them can be introduced only on the recommendation of the president. In all other respects, a financial bill (I) is governed by the same legislative procedure applicable to an ordinary bill.
  • Hence, it can be either rejected or amended by the Rajya Sabha (except that an amendment other than for reduction or abolition of a tax cannot be moved in either House without the recommendation of the president i.e., the recommendation of the president is not required for moving an amendment making provision for the reduction or abolition of a tax). 
  • In case of a disagreement between the two Houses over such a bill, the president can summon a joint sitting of the two Houses to resolve the deadlock. When the bill is presented to the President, he can either give his assent to the bill or withhold his assent to the bill or return the bill for reconsideration of the Houses.

Financial Bills (II)

  • A financial bill (II) contains provisions involving expenditure from the Consolidated Fund of India, but does not include any of the matters mentioned in Article 110. 
  • It is treated as an ordinary bill and in all respects, it is governed by the same legislative procedure which is applicable to an ordinary bill. 
  • The only special feature of this bill is that it cannot be passed by either House of Parliament unless the President has recommended to that House the consideration of the bill. Hence, financial bill (II) can be introduced in either House of Parliament and recommendation of the President is not necessary for its introduction. In other words, the recommendation of the President is not required at the introduction stage but is required at the consideration stage. 
  • It can be either rejected or amended by either House of Parliament. In case of a disagreement between the two Houses over such a bill, the President can summon a joint sitting of the two Houses to resolve the deadlock. When the bill is presented to the President, he can either give his assent to the bill or withhold his assent to the bill or return the bill for reconsideration of the Houses.

Differing views emerge on MP disqualification

Context: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi’s conviction and sentencing in a 2019 defamation case by a court in Gujarat has put a question mark over his continuation as a Lok Sabha MP. Experts have differing views on whether the conviction and sentencing means immediate disqualification or the Wayanad MP gets time if he appeals.

So this particular raises two issues which are extremely pertinent in Indian context: 

  • Disqualification of elected members of the houses. 
  • Criminal Defamation and its utility in democratic India. 

So the following discussion will have two components: 

  • Disqualification
    • Disqualification and Its importance
    • Constitutional provisions 
    • Lily Thomas Case 
  • Defamation
    • What is defamation all about?
    • Defamation is an exception to the Right to Freedom of Speech
    • Why is defamation a crime? 
    • Why defamation should remain a criminal offence?

Disqualification and Its importance: 

  • The disqualification procedure in India is an important mechanism for maintaining the integrity of the electoral process and ensuring that elected representatives meet certain standards of conduct and eligibility.
  • Under the Constitution of India, certain criteria have been laid down (See below) for the eligibility of candidates contesting elections to the Lok Sabha (lower house of parliament) and the state legislative assemblies. These criteria include age, citizenship, and lack of criminal convictions, among others. If a person is found to be ineligible based on these criteria, they can be disqualified from holding elected office.
  • Similarly, if an elected representative violates certain rules or engages in behavior that is deemed unethical or illegal, they can be disqualified from their position.
    • For example, under the Representation of the People Act, an elected representative can be disqualified for offenses such as corrupt practices, electoral malpractices, or holding an office of profit.
  • The disqualification procedure is important because it ensures that those who are elected to public office are held to high standards of conduct and behavior. It also helps to prevent individuals who are ineligible or have engaged in unethical or illegal activities from holding elected office and making important decisions on behalf of the people.
  • Overall, the disqualification procedure in India plays a crucial role in maintaining the integrity of the electoral process and ensuring that elected representatives are held accountable for their actions.

Disqualifications specified in the Constitution of India for Members of Parliament: 

Text, letter

Description automatically generated
Text, letter

Description automatically generated

Disqualifications specified in the Constitution of India for Members of Legislative Assembly: 

Text

Description automatically generated
xJSSWl k4jFLXuwTaBA69aGmLjrt09qUcgbx98Kt1cCmC0FhqZ blYUNOLoI3NFa2N3CQc9bla mZ2RAAgeW

(Lily Thomas Case 2013) Immediate Disqualification of Convicted MPs and MLAs 

  • In 2013, the Supreme Court held that charge sheeted Members of Parliament and MLAs, on conviction for offences, will be immediately disqualified from holding membership of the House without being given three months’ time for appeal, as was the case before.
  • The concerned Bench of the Court struck down as unconstitutional Section 8 (4) of the Representation of the People Act (1951) that allows convicted lawmakers a three-month period for filing appeal to the higher court and to get a stay of the conviction and sentence. The Bench, however, made it clear that the ruling will be prospective and those who had already filed appeals in various High Courts or the Supreme Court against their convictions would be exempt from it.
  • The Bench said: “A reading of the two provisions in Articles 102 and 191 of the Constitution would make it abundantly clear that Parliament is to make one law for a person to be disqualified for being chosen as, and for being, a Member of either House of Parliament or Legislative Assembly or Legislative Council of the State. Parliament thus does not have the power under Articles 102 and 191 of the Constitution to make different laws for a person to be disqualified for being chosen as a member and for a person to be disqualified for continuing as a Member of Parliament or the State Legislature.”
  • The Bench said: “Section 8 (4) of the Act which carves out a saving in the case of sitting members of Parliament or State Legislature from the disqualifications under the Act or which defers the date on which the disqualification will take effect in the case of a sitting member of Parliament or a State Legislature is beyond the powers conferred on Parliament by the Constitution.”
  • The Bench held: “Looking at the affirmative terms of Articles 102 and 191 of the Constitution, we hold that Parliament has been vested with the powers to make law laying down the same disqualifications for person to be chosen as a member of Parliament or a State Legislature and for a sitting member of a House of Parliament or a House of a State Legislature. We also hold that the provisions of Article 101 and 190 of the Constitution expressly prohibit Parliament to defer the date from which the disqualification will come into effect in case of a sitting member of Parliament or a State Legislature. Parliament, therefore, has exceeded its powers conferred by the Constitution in enacting sub-section (4) of Section 8 of the Act and accordingly sub-section (4) of Section 8 of the Act is ultra vires the Constitution.”

In order to nullify the above ruling of the Supreme Court, the Representation of the People (Second Amendment and Validation) Bill, 2013 was introduced in the Parliament. However, the Bill was later withdrawn by the Government.

BASED ON HIGH COURT OR SUPREME COURT’S ORDER

When Disqualification ContinuesWhen Disqualification Ends
If the Higher Court on appeal stays the operation of only the execution of sentence of imprisonment passed by the trial Court >>> then such stay on the execution of sentence given by the Higher Courts will not have any effect on the person’s disqualification --- So, the disqualification continues.Disqualification will be suspended where the Higher Court stays both the conviction and the operation of sentence.  

Defamation:

So this has again brought the limelight on defamation issue. 

  • What is defamation all about?
  • Defamation is an exception to the Right to Freedom of Speech
  • Why is defamation a crime? 
  • Why defamation should remain a criminal offence?

What is defamation all about?

  • Defamation is the general term for a legal claim involving injury to one's reputation caused by a false statement of fact and includes both libel (defamation in written or fixed form) and slander (spoken defamation). The crux of a defamation claim is falsity. Truthful statements that harm another's reputation will not create liability for defamation (although they may open you up to other forms of liability if the information you publish is of a personal or highly private nature).
  • Defamation refers to the act of publication of defamatory content that lowers the reputation of an individual or an entity when observed through the perspective of an ordinary man. If defamation occurs in spoken words or gestures (or other such transitory form) then it is termed as slander and the same if in written or printed form is libel. Defamation in India is both a civil and a criminal offence.

Defamation is an exception to the Right to Freedom of Speech

  • Article 19 of the Constitution grants various freedoms to its citizens.
  • However, Article 19(2) has imposed reasonable exemption to freedom of speech and expression granted under Article 19(1) (a). Contempt of court, defamation and incitement to an offence are some exceptions.

Legal Provisions 

  • Sections 499 and 500 OF IPC
    • Sections 499 and 500 in the IPC deal with criminal defamation. While the former defines the offence of defamation, the latter defines the punishment for it.
    • Section 499: Whoever, by words either spoken or intended to be read, or by signs or by visible representations, makes or publishes any imputation concerning any person intending to harm, or knowing or having reason to believe that such imputation will harm, the reputation of such person, is said, except in the cases hereinafter expected, to defame that person.
  • Section 500:
    • Whoever defames another shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both.

Why is defamation a crime? 

  • Reputation is an asset to each and every one. Any damage to such asset can be legally dealt with. Defamation laws have been enacted to prevent person maliciously using their right to freedom of speech and expression. The Indian law has rightly not made any distinction between libel and slander. Otherwise there could have been chances for committing slander and escaping from the laws that there is no written publication of matter.

Why defamation should remain a criminal offence?

Arguments ‘In favor’:

  • Income inequality
    • Defamation should remain a penal offence in India as the defamer may be too poor to compensate the victim in some cases.
  • Anonymity provided by Internet
    • Since there is no mechanism to censor the Internet from within, online defamation could only be adequately countered by retaining defamation as a criminal offence.
  • Article 21
    • Also, criminalization of defamation is part of the state’s “compelling interest” to protect the right to dignity and good reputation of its citizens.
  • Changes have been made from time to time
    • Sections 499 and 500 have 10 exceptions. 
    • These exceptions clearly exclude from its ambit any speech that is truthful, made in good faith and/or is for public good.

Arguments ‘Against’:

  • Against the global trend
    • Many countries worldwide are in favor of treating defamation as a civil wrong, not as a criminal offence. 
    • Also, in 2011, the Human Rights Committee of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights called upon states to abolish criminal defamation, noting that it intimidates citizens and makes them shy away from exposing wrongdoing.
  • Misuse by “Influential”
    • The misuse of law as an instrument of harassment is also pervasive in India. 
    • Often, the prosecutor’s complaint is taken at face value by courts, which send out routine notices for the appearance of defendants without any preliminary examination whether the offending comments or reports come under one of the exceptions spelt out in Section 499. 
    • Thus, the process itself becomes the punishment.
      • Criminal defamation has a pernicious effect on society: for instance, the state uses it as a means to coerce the media and political opponents into adopting self-censorship and unwarranted self-restraint.
      • The law can also be used by groups or sections claiming to have been hurt or insulted and abuse the process by initiating multiple proceedings in different places.
  • Public order concerns taken care by other sections
    • Defamatory acts that may harm public order are covered by Sections 124, 153 and 153A, and so criminal defamation does not serve any overarching public interest. Even though Section 499 provides safeguards by means of exceptions, the threat of criminal prosecution is in itself unreasonable and excessive.

Guillotine, in Parliament

Context: Lok Sabha passed the Demands for Grants for Budget 2023-24 and the Appropriation Bill by a voice vote without any discussion. Speaker applied guillotine and put demands for grants of all ministries to vote.

Guillotine in the context of Indian legislature

  • Discussion on a matter of general public importance can take place only when motion made with the consent of the presiding officer.
  • Guillotine is a type of motion which falls under the category of closure motion.

Closure Motion 

It is a motion moved by a member to cut short the debate on a matter before the House. If the motion is approved by the House, debate is stopped forthwith and the matter is put to vote. 

Types of closure motions  

(a)Simple Closure: It is one when a member moves that the ‘matter having been sufficiently discussed be now put to vote’. 

(b)Closure by Compartments: In this case, the clauses of a bill or a lengthy resolution are grouped into parts before the commencement of the debate. The debate covers the part as a whole and the entire part is put to vote. 

(c)Kangaroo Closure: Under this type, only important clauses are taken up for debate and voting and the intervening clauses are skipped over and taken as passed. 

(d)Guillotine Closure: It is one when the undiscussed clauses of a bill or a resolution are also put to vote along with the discussed ones due to want of time (as the time allotted for the discussion is over). 

In legislative parlance, to “guillotine” means to bunch together and fast-track the passage of financial business. It is a common procedural exercise in Lok Sabha during the Budget Session.

Procedure 

  • Parliament goes into recess of three weeks after the presentation of the budget. This recess allows Standing committees of the house to examine the demands for grants and presenting its report for the same.
  • After the reassembly of the Parliament , Business Advisory committee (BAC) prepares a schedule for the discussion on demands for grant , but due to paucity of time BAC picks up few selected ministries for the discussion.
  • Once the House is done with these debates, the Speaker applies the “guillotine”, and all outstanding demands for grants are put to vote at once. This usually happens on the last day earmarked for the discussion on the Budget. The intention is to ensure timely passage of the Finance Bill, marking the completion of the legislative exercise with regard to the Budget.

The forecast after a fake news campaign in Tamil Nadu

Recently India witnessed an incidence of spread of fake news and subsequent law and order situation in the state of Tamilnadu. As most of the information in India is consumed through social media sources , fake news and its propagation poses biggest threat to democracy as well as internal security of India. 

Regulations abroad

  • The European Union (EU) – It has come up with the Code of Practice on Disinformation 2022. Some of the strengthened initiatives of the EU Code include transparency in political advertising, empowerment of fact­checkers and researchers, tools to flag disinformation, and measures to reduce manipulative behaviour. 
  • The United Kingdom - It has proposed enacting an Online Safety Bill which will expect social media platforms (intermediaries) to actively monitor problematic content. 
  • China - China has some of the strictest laws in the world when it comes to misinformation.
  • France – It passed a legislation in November 2018; this legislation provides for definition of “Fake News”. The legislation gives authorities the power to remove fake content spread via social media and even block the sites that publish it.
  • Germany - It Has a law, titled  (NetzDG), which forces online platforms to remove “obviously illegal” posts within 24 hours or risk fines of up to €50 million.

Regulations in India

  • India does not have a robust and exclusive framework for curbing the menace of the fake news.
  • However government by the use of Section 69A of the Information technology Act, 2000, has granted itself greater power to strike down any unpalatable content. 
  • Government has come up with the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 , or IT Rules, 2021 to regulate content by online publishers of news and social media intermediaries.
  • The recent draft amendments to the IT Rules, 2021, empowers the Press Information Bureau, which functions under the Union Ministry of Information and Broadcasting to ‘flag inaccurate and fake news related to government bodies on social media platforms’ amounts to disinformation.

Supreme Court judgement
In Tehseen S. Poonawalla vs Union of India (2018)  case, Supreme Court held that it is duty of central and state governments to take steps for curbing the dissemination of fake/ objectionable content.

INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (INTERMEDIARY GUIDELINES AND DIGITAL MEDIA ETHICS) RULES, 2021

Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MEITY) has notified the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics) Rules, 2021 to regulate IT intermediaries such as Twitter, Facebook and digital media outlets. While many IT intermediaries have complied to these rules Twitter has failed to comply with them.

NEED FOR REGULATING IT INTERMEDIARIES

  • IT intermediaries and social media sites have come to play a prominent role in the globalised era as it provides a forum for citizens across the globe to share information and ideas in real time.
  • IT intermediaries contend that the information posted by users on them is by citizens and they do not have any liability as the information posted is so large pool of people and from across the globe.
  • Communications Decency Act of USA gives immunity to social media platforms for content posted on them. In India, the IT (Intermediary Guidelines) Rules, 2011 gave this immunity to social media platforms.
  • The present rules update the earlier rules and introduce a soft touch self-regulatory mechanism for use of the social media.

This is justified since:

(a) Similar protection is not available for newspapers, magazines or websites. Social media companies have argued that they do not have editorial control to regulate control. However, social media companies have increasingly carrying out interventions to regulate content. E.g., Banning posts of President Trump of USA.

(b) Freedom of speech under the constitution is subject to reasonable restriction Article 19(2). Thus, social media platforms too can be regulated under the Constitutional scheme.

(c) Due to growing importance of social media platforms, they can be considered as a public utility serving a public function. Hence, some sort RIGHTS & RESERVATIONS of regulation is necessary from security point of view.

(d) To check the misuse and protection of citizens.

(e) Right of the sovereign to regulate communications.

CONCERNS HIGHLIGHTED ON IT RULES

  • Privacy versus National Security - The rules only make superficial attempts at balancing privacy and security interests as security interests are being given primacy over both civil liberty interests as well as economic interests.
  • Breaking End-to-end Encryption - The traceability obligation in the new rules is problematic as it would amount to breaking end-to-end encryption provided for all users on platforms such as WhatsApp. This will give greater powers of surveillance to state over personal affairs of citizens and tantamount to interference in right to privacy.
  • Data Theft & Hacking - Breaking of end-to-end encryption will increase chances of data theft and hacking.
  • Traceability clause capable of misuse - The rule as it’s currently drafted is vague and this allows the government to use traceability power in a broad way and therefore open to misuse. Thus, to use traceability powers, court must clarify the grounds and circumstances for its use by state authorities.
  • Guidelines against law on Subordinate Legislation - Ability to issue rules under a statute or law, to frame subordinate legislation, is by its nature a limited and constrained power. The current rules go beyond the realm of Information Technology Act, and thus in the garb of rulemaking, government has rather come up with primary set of legislation.
  • Rules have created new term in the Parent Act: Executive has created new term “significant social media intermediaries” which has not been defined in the Information Technology Act, 2000.
  • Limited Purview of IT Act - Regarding digital news and media portals, the purview of the Information Technology Act, 2000, is limited. It only extends to the blocking of websites and intermediary liabilities framework but does not extend to content authors and creators.
  • Rules have added New Chapter on Registration of Digital News Sites before the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting. Such provisions are absent in the parent Act.Pressure on Tech Companies - Platforms can also be arm-twisted into building in what’s called weakness by design into their product.

National party tag: Election Commission holds hearings with NCP, CPI, TMC

Context: Election commission is reviewing the status of National parties , which has been accorded to various political partis under the exercise of powers described under The Election Symbols (Reservation And Allotment) Order, 1968.

The Election Symbols (Reservation And Allotment) Order, 1968

  • Para 6A deals with Conditions for recognition as a State Party ; 
  • Para 6B deals with the Conditions for recognition as a National Party 
  • Para 6C delas with Conditions for continued recognition as a National or State party.

Conditions for recognition as a State Party (6A)

A political party shall be eligible for recognition as a State party in a State, if, and only if, any of the following conditions is fulfilled 

  1. At the last general election to the Legislative Assembly of the State, the candidates set up by the party have secured not less than six percent of the total valid votes polled in the State; and, in addition, the party has returned at least two members to the Legislative Assembly of that State at such general election; or 
  2. At the last general election to the House of the People from that State, the candidates set up by the party have secured not less than six percent of the total valid votes polled in the State; and, in addition, the party has returned at least one member to the House of the People from that State at such general election; or 
  3. At the last general election to the Legislative Assembly of the State, the party has won at least three percent of the total number of seats in the Legislative Assembly, or at least three seats in the Assembly, whichever is more; or 
  4. At the last general election to the House of the People from the State, the party has returned at least one member to the House of the People for every 25 members or any fraction thereof allotted to that State;] or 
  5. At the last general election to the House of the People from the State, or at the last general election to the Legislative Assembly of the State, the candidates set up by the Party have secured not less than eight percent of the total valid votes polled in the State.

Conditions for recognition as a National Party (6B)

A political party shall be eligible to be recognized as National party, if, and only if, any of the following conditions is fulfilled 

  1. The candidates set up by the party, in any four or more States, at the last general election to the House of the People, or to the Legislative Assembly of the State concerned, have secured not less than six percent of the total valid votes polled in each of those States at that general election; and, in addition, it has returned at least four members to the House of the People at the aforesaid last general election from any State or States; or 
  2. At the last general election to the House of the People, the party has won at least two percent of the total number of seats in the House of the People, and the party’s candidates have been elected to that House from not less than three States; or 
  3. The party is recognized as State party in at least four States.

Conditions for continued recognition as a National or State party (6C)  

If a political party is recognised as a State party under paragraph 6A, or as a National party under paragraph 6B, the question whether it shall continue to be so recognised after any subsequent general election to the House of the People or, as the case may be, to the Legislative Assembly of the State concerned, shall be dependent upon the fulfilment by it of the conditions specified in the said paragraphs on the results of that general election.

As per the Election Commission of India at present there are seven political parties which are the status of recognised National Parties. 

  1. All India Trinamool Congress
  2. Bahujan Samaj Party
  3. Bharatiya Janata Party
  4. Communist Party of India
  5. Communist Party of India (Marxist)
  6. Indian National Congress
  7. Nationalist Congress Party

Significance of being recognised as National or State Parties

  • Apart from those recognised as state or national party , the other parties are simply declared as registered-unrecognised parties.
  • RPA allows political parties to accept contributions voluntarily offered to it by any person or company other than a government company.
  • Candidates of registered parties get preference in allotment of election symbols. Other Candidates are identified as independents and do not get preference in symbol allocation.
  • If a party is recognised as a State Party’, it is entitled for exclusive allotment of its reserved symbol to the candidates set up by it in the State in which it is so recognised.
  • If a party is recognised as a `National Party’ it is entitled for exclusive allotment of its reserved symbol to the candidates set up by it throughout India.
  • Recognised `State’ and `National’ parties need only one proposer for filing the nomination and are also entitled for two sets of electoral rolls free of cost at the time of revision of rolls and their candidates get one copy of electoral roll free of cost during General Elections.
  • They get broadcast/telecast facilities over Akashvani/Doordarshan during general elections. 
  • A recognized National or State party can have a maximum of 40 “Star campaigners” and a registered un-recognised party can nominate a maximum of 20 ‘Star Campaigners”. The travel expenses of star campaigners are not to be accounted for in the election expense accounts of candidates of their party.

Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council

Context: Amidst sub-zero temperatures, people are protesting to bring attention to Ladakh's susceptibility to climate change and its connection to the Sixth Schedule rights. With the looming threat of climate change, the ongoing demonstrations aimed at preserving Ladakh's identity under the Sixth Schedule take on even greater significance and urgency.

More on the news:

The Ladakh region is highly vulnerable to climate change, with retreating glaciers and villages forced to relocate due to lack of water.

People in Ladakh has been protesting in freezing temperatures to highlight this vulnerability and advocate for the implementation of the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution, which empowers autonomous councils to administer rights over land, forest, sanitation, and employment to safeguard cultural and indigenous identities. 

About Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council:

The Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council Act 1995 was enacted in response to the demands of the Ladakhi people who sought to create a separate Indian Union Territory due to their distinct religious and cultural identity, which differed from the rest of Jammu and Kashmir.

The creation of the Autonomous Hill Councils in Ladakh represented an important step towards recognizing the unique identity and aspirations of the region's people.

The council provided a platform for participatory democracy, enabling the people to take charge of their own development and governance while also ensuring that their distinctive cultural and religious identity is preserved.

Composition of council:

The total number of seats, in the Council to be filled by persons chosen by direct election on the basis of adult suffrage from territorial constituencies shall be twenty-six.

The Governor may nominate not more than four persons from amongst the principal religious minorities and women in the district to be members of the Council.

The members of the Council shall at its first meeting after a general election elect from amongst the elected members one member to be the Chairman.

The Executive council:

There shall be an Executive Council consisting of – (a) the Chairman who shall be the Chief Executive Councillor; and (b) four members to be nominated by the Chief Executive Councillor from amongst the members of the Council: Provided that at least one member shall be nominated from amongst the principal religious minorities in the district. The Executive Council shall be collectively responsible to the Council.

Powers and Functions of Council:

Subject to the provisions of 1995 Act the Council shall have executive powers in the district in relation to:

  1. Allotment, use and occupation of land vested in the Council by the Government under this Act.
  2. Formulation of development programme for the district in respect of District Component Schemes as notified by the Government and Centrally Sponsored Schemes and indicate priorities for various schemes and consider issues relating to the speedy development and economic upliftment of the district.
  3. Laying down guidelines for implementation of schemes at gross root level and Promotion of co-operative institutions.
  4. Special measures for employment generation and the alleviation of poverty and Management of undemarcated forests.
  5. Supervision and constitution of notified area committees and Formulation of periodical and annual plans for the district.
  6. Promotion of languages and culture of the area, Tourism, Vocational training, Education, Fisheries.
  7. Public health and sanitation, hospitals and dispensaries and Construction and maintenance of roads except highways.
  8. Preservation, protection and improvement of livestock and prevention of animal diseases.
  9. To collect within the district such taxes payable under any law as may be prescribed by the Government and credit the same to the Consolidated Fund.

What is the Sixth Schedule?

The Sixth Schedule, outlined in Article 244, allows for the establishment of self-governing administrative entities known as Autonomous District Councils (ADCs) within a state.

These councils possess some legislative, judicial, and administrative powers and can operate autonomously in certain areas. ADCs consist of up to 30 members who serve a five-year term and have the authority to create laws, regulations, and policies concerning various matters, such as land, forest, water, agriculture, village councils, health, sanitation, policing at the village and town level, inheritance, marriage and divorce, social customs, and mining.

The Sixth Schedule is applicable to the north-eastern states of Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram (with three councils each), and Tripura (with one council).

Why Ladakh is demanding sixth schedule?

The creation of the Union Territory of Ladakh, which had initially been met with enthusiasm in the Buddhist-dominated region, has soured due to the absence of a legislative assembly and concerns over changes in the domicile policy in Jammu and Kashmir. While there are two Hill councils in Leh and Kargil, their powers are limited and the administration of the region is completely in the hands of bureaucrats. Due to the limited powers conferred on the councils, there is growing demand for inclusion into the sixth schedule. Ladakh's inclusion under the Sixth Schedule, which would enable the preservation of its distinct culture and the restriction of land acquisition by outsiders, has been recommended by the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes.

Government’s response to Ladakh’s demand for sixth schedule:

Home Ministry official has stated that the Constitution only permits the Sixth Schedule for the Northeast, and the Fifth Schedule applies to tribal areas in the rest of the country. The government has the option to amend the Constitution to allow for Ladakh's inclusion.

Benefits of inclusion into sixth schedule:

  1. The district and regional councils have jurisdiction over specific areas and can create laws regarding topics such as land, forests, canal water, village administration, inheritance of property, marriage and divorce, social customs, and shifting cultivation. 
  2. Within their territories, the district and regional councils can establish village councils or courts to adjudicate disputes between tribes and hear appeals. 
  3. The district council can manage primary schools, dispensaries, markets, ferries, fisheries, and roads within its district. It can also regulate money lending and trading by non-tribals. 
  4. The district and regional councils have the authority to collect land revenue and impose specified taxes. 
  5. Acts of Parliament or state legislature do not apply to autonomous districts and regions, or they may apply with modifications and exceptions. 
  6. The Governor has the power to appoint a commission to investigate matters related to the administration of autonomous districts or regions. He can also dissolve a district or regional council based on the commission's recommendation.

Way Forward:

It is essential to engage in constructive dialogue with people of Ladakh and take into account the interests and aspirations of all stakeholders, while also ensuring the region's sustainable and equitable development.

Reverse the hostility

Prelims: Position of Speaker in Britain, Role of the Speaker in India.

Mains: Importance of Speaker, Issues associated with the speaker.

Adversarial relations between the ruling party and the Opposition are inevitable in a democracy and, in a way, such relations that bring strong differences of opinion and contentious views to the fore are critical. Democracy flourishes when there is reconciliation through legislative debate. Yet, adversarial relations resulting in confrontation following the lack of discourse over differences on issues of public import, speak poorly of legislative conduct.

This holds true of Kerala, where legislative business has come to a standstill after a severe deterioration in relations between the ruling coalition and the Opposition.

What began as an issue of the Speaker repeatedly disallowing discussion on Rule 50 notices by the Opposition United Democratic Front last week has grown into a full-blown confrontation, with legal cases being filed against legislators after incidents that resulted in a ruckus in the Assembly. 

Securing the neutrality of the Speaker is a question that experts in India have been grappling with for 60-plus years. A watchful Parliament forms the foundation of a well-functioning democracy. The presiding officers of Parliament are the key to securing the effectiveness of this institution. The MPs look to them to facilitate debate, protect their rights and uphold the dignity of Parliament. 

The primary challenge before any Speaker is to conduct the proceedings of the Lok Sabha free from disruptions.

To do so, the Speaker will have to earn the trust of the Members of Parliament: One way to earn the trust of MPs will be by being neutral, both in practice and perception while running the House. Securing the neutrality of the Speaker is a question that experts in India have been grappling with for 60-plus years.

Why is the role of speaker so important? 

  • Securing the neutrality of the Speaker is a question that experts in India have been grappling with for 60-plus years.  A watchful Parliament forms the foundation of a well-functioning democracy. The presiding officers of Parliament are the key to securing the effectiveness of this institution. The MPs look to them to facilitate debate, protect their rights and uphold the dignity of Parliament. 
  • The primary challenge before the any Speaker is to conduct the proceedings of the Lok Sabha free from disruptions. To do so, the Speaker will have to earn the trust of the Members of Parliament: One way to earn the trust of MPs will be by being neutral, both in practice and perception while running the House.
  • Securing the neutrality of the Speaker is a question that experts in India have been grappling with for 60-plus years.

How is the position of Speaker in Britain?

  • In Britain, the promise of continuity in office for many terms is used to ensure the Speaker’s impartiality.
  • By convention, political parties (usually) do not field a candidate against the Speaker at the time of general elections. And the Speaker can continue in office, until deciding otherwise. By convention, the Speaker also gives up the membership of his/her political party.

What is the role of the Speaker in India?

In India, the Speaker of the Lok Sabha (lower house of parliament) holds several powers like: 

  • Presiding Officer: The Speaker presides over the meetings of the Lok Sabha, maintains order and decorum in the House, and ensures that the proceedings are conducted in accordance with the rules and procedures.
  • Decision-making: The Speaker decides on the admissibility of questions, motions, and amendments, and also decides on the allocation of time for discussions and debates.
  • Committee Formation: The Speaker appoints the members and chairpersons of various parliamentary committees, such as the Committee on Public Accounts, the Committee on Estimates, and the Committee on Privileges.
  • Casting Vote: In case of a tie during a voting, the Speaker has the power to cast the deciding vote.
  • Disqualification of members: The Speaker has the power to disqualify a member of the Lok Sabha on the grounds of defection, misconduct, or violation of parliamentary rules.
  • Maintenance of Order: The Speaker has the power to suspend or expel a member who violates the rules of the House or behaves in a disorderly manner.
  • Parliamentary Affairs: The Speaker is responsible for the administration of the Lok Sabha, including the preparation of the annual budget, allocation of funds, and the recruitment of staff.

Hence we can see that the Speaker of the Lok Sabha plays a crucial role in ensuring the smooth functioning of the parliament and maintaining the integrity of the democratic process in India.

What are the mechanisms to ensure the neutrality of Speaker in India?

  • His salaries and allowances are fixed by Parliament. They are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India 
  • His work and conduct cannot be discussed and criticised in the Lok Sabha except on a substantive motion.
  • Powers of regulating procedure or conducting business or maintaining order in the House are not subject to the jurisdiction of any Court. 
  • Only exercise a casting vote in the event of a tie. This makes the position of Speaker impartial. 
  • He is given a very high position in the order of precedence. He is placed at seventh rank, along with the Chief Justice of India

Issues associated with speaker 

  • With no security in the continuity of office, the Speaker is dependent on his or her political party for re-election.
  • This makes the Speaker susceptible to pulls and pressures from her/his political party in the conduct of the proceedings of the house. 
  • The persistence of allegations of prejudice can be attributed to the issue of partisanship resulting from the way the Speaker is appointed and the duration of their tenure.
    • There has been a tradition of appointing the Speaker from the majority party and the Deputy Speaker from the opposition side, which has led to structural problems.
  • There is no convention of Speakers relinquishing their party membership and hence they are often perceived as being partisan. 
  • It is common for Indian Speakers to have occupied ministerial roles shortly before or after their term. As a result, even if there is no evidence to substantiate such allegations, it is not unexpected for Speakers in India to be accused of partisanship.
  • The challenge posed by coalitions is twofold.
    • Firstly, the growing number of parties has led to a reduction in the amount of time each party has to articulate its interests during discussions. 
    • Secondly, there has been a decline in the frequency of annual sittings of Parliament/Legislatures.
    • Rise in the number of political parties and varied political interest has made it harder for the Speaker to find consensus between members on use of disciplinary powers 
  • Unparliamentary conduct: Members seek to use unparliamentary means such as disruptions etc. for attaining the indulgence of the Speaker.
  • The Anti-Defection Law assigns the responsibility of deciding whether a member should be disqualified to the Speaker, who has significant discretion. However, this discretion has often been exploited by the ruling party to eliminate dissenting voices.
  • Determination of money bill: It has been criticised for certifying bills such as Aadhaar Bill etc. as Money Bill, though it may not have met the strict criteria laid out in the Constitution.

Way forward

  • The responsibility of the Speaker in dealing with defections, splits, and mergers should be assigned to an impartial entity such as the Election Commission or a neutral body outside the legislature.
  • To ensure a smooth and uncontested re-election process, it is recommended to establish a tradition of re-electing the Speaker without any opposition.
  • During parliamentary discussions and question hour, efforts should be made to allocate time to members based on party strength and also to accommodate those who wish to express diverse concerns or viewpoints.
  • In order to enhance trust in the Speaker's decision-making process, it is advisable to increase transparency by making the Speaker's decisions publicly available.
  • The reluctance of Speakers to take action against disorderly members could be mitigated if the media plays a constructive role in highlighting instances of misconduct and their negative impact on the House's performance.