Context: Press and Registration of Books Act amendments to come into force on Sept. 1
About Press and Registration of Periodicals Act 2023
It seeks to simplify the registration process for periodicals and make it mandatory for digital news platforms to do a “one-time registration” in order to operate.
It replaces the existing Press and Registration of Books (PRB) Act, of 1867, which governs the registration of the print and publishing industry in the country.
The aim is to bring transparency and ease of doing business. It will provide for a simple process that will help small and medium publishers.
Provision of Press and Registration of Periodicals Act 2023
Registration of periodicals: The Act allows for registering newspapers, periodicals, and books, and cataloguing books. The act focuses on registering periodicals containing public news or comments on it, excluding books and academic journals.
Declaration of periodicals: In the 1867 Act, only the district magistrate (DM) could cancel the declaration of a periodical, while the Press Registrar General (PRG) did not have suo motu powers to cancel or suspend the Certificate of Registration granted by it. However, the PRP Act empowers the PRG to suspend/cancel registration.
Foreign periodicals: An exact reproduction of a foreign periodical may be printed in India only with the prior approval of the central government. The manner of registration of such periodicals will be prescribed.
Appellate Authority: It also provides for an appellate authority. The Appellate Board (Press and Registration Appellate Board) will comprise the chairperson, Press Council of India (PCI), and two members of PCI to hear an appeal against the refusal of grant of registration, imposition of any penalty or suspension/cancellation of registration by PRG.
Suspension and cancellation of registration: The act allows the Press Registrar General to suspend a periodical’s registration for a minimum period of 30 days which can extend to 180 days.
Reason for suspension and cancellation of registration: The registration may be suspended due to: (i) registration obtained by furnishing false information, (ii) failure to publish periodicals continuously, and (iii) giving false particulars in annual statements. The Press Registrar General may cancel the registration if the publisher does not correct such defects.
Registration may also be cancelled if: (i) a periodical has the same or similar title as any other periodical, (ii) the owner/ publisher has been convicted of a terrorist act or unlawful activity, or for acting against the security of the state.
Offence: A person who has been convicted by any court for an offence involving a terrorist act or unlawful activity, or having done anything against the security of the state shall not be permitted to bring out a periodical.
Penalties: It waters down the penal provisions of the PRB Act, which made improper declaration of information a punishable offence with a prison term of up to six months. Under the new Act, imprisonment for up to six months is only applicable if a periodical is published without registration, and the publisher continues printing it after a six-month notice from PRG to stop.
Appeal: Any person may appeal against the refusal to issue a registration certificate, suspension/ cancellation of registration or imposition of penalty. Such appeals may be filed before the Press and Registration Appellate Board within 60 days.
Exclusion: Books, which were part of the PRB Act, of 1867, have been taken out of the purview of this act as books as a subject are administered by the Ministry of Education.
Press Registrar General
The Office of the Registrar of Newspapers for India, more popularly known as RNI came into being in 1956, on the recommendation of the First Press Commission in 1953 and by amending the Press and Registration of Books Act 1867.
Functions: The office performs both statutory as well as non-statutory functions.
Statutory functions Compilation and maintenance of a Register of Newspapers containing particulars about all the newspapers published.Issue of Certificate of Registration to the newspapers published under valid declaration;Informing the District Magistrates about availability of titles, to intending publishers for filing declaration;
Non-statutory functions:
Formulation of Newsprint Allocation Policy - Guidelines and issue of Eligibility Certificate to the newspapers to enable them to import newsprint and to procure indigenous newsprint.Assessing and certifying the essential need and requirement of newspaper establishments to import printing and composing machinery and allied materials.
Context: The National Green Tribunal (NGT) has directed the Border Roads Organisation (BRO) to plant at least 10,000 trees within a month in Uttarakhand as part of compensatory tree plantation to make up for hundreds of trees felled during construction of a road from Simli to Gwaldam.
National Green Tribunal:
NGT is a statutory and specialised judicial body that deals with the expeditious disposal of cases related to environmental protection, and the conservation of forestsand other natural resources. It was set up under the National Green Tribunal Act in 2010.
The Tribunal is not bound by procedure under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 or the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and is guided by principles of Natural Justice.
It draws inspiration from Part III of the Constitution of India,Article 21 Protection of life and personal liberty, which assures the citizens of India the right to a healthy environment.
NGT Deals in the following Acts:
The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974
The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Cess Act, 1977
The Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980
The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981
The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
The Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991
The Biological Diversity Act, 2002
Power of NGT:
The Tribunal is vested with the powers of a Civil Court under the Code of Civil Procedure for discharging its functions. NGT is mandated to make disposal of applications within 6 months of the filing of the same.
It can enforce any legal right relating to the environment and order relief and compensation for damages to persons and property.
In a decision of Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai v Ankita Sinha & Others, the Supreme Court of India held that NGT has the power to take suo motu cognizance of environmental issues.
An appeal against the order/decision/ award of the NGT lies to the Supreme Court, generally within ninety days from the date of communication.
In case of non-compliance with any direction issued by the NGT or any of its judgements, a penalty can be imposed in which the person may be given imprisonment for about three years or a fine which may extend to Rs. 10 crores or even both.
Composition of NGT:
The NGT comprises the Chairman, the Judicial Members, and Expert Members. These members are required to hold the office for five years, and they are not eligible for reappointment.
The Chairperson of NGT is appointed by the Central Government in consultation with the Chief Justice of India (CJI).
Challenges of NGT:
Two important Acts – Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 and Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 have been kept out of NGT’s jurisdiction.
Decisions of NGT have also been criticized and challenged due to their repercussions on economic growth and development. The absence of a formula-based mechanism in determining the compensation has brought criticism to the tribunal.
Orders of NGT can be challenged in the court of law, limiting the tribunal's role.
Context: The Election Commission of India (ECI) has become a center of disagreement between the government and the judiciary. The recent conflict revolves around the process of appointing its officials. The Supreme Court ruled that the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (EC) should be appointed by the President based on a committee's advice, including the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha or the largest Opposition party leader, and the Chief Justice of India (CJI). This was a unanimous judgment by a five-judge Bench and aimed to strengthen the ECI's constitutional standing.
However, the government introduced a bill to change this procedure, seeking to remove the Chief Justice of India from the selection committee. The proposed committee would then consist of the Prime Minister (Chairperson), Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha (Member), and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister (Member).
This move reflects the government's desire for more influence in appointing top election officials, potentially undermining the institution's independence.
Various committees and leaders have previously suggested a more representative selection process for ECI members. The idea was to reduce the ruling party's sway and ensure fairer elections. The current bill, introduced by the ruling party (BJP), contradicts its previous stance as an opposition party and aims to increase government control over the ECI.
Despite being respected for its reliability and responsible conduct, the ECI's autonomy and trust have been questioned due to perceived leniency towards the ruling party. The bill highlights the government's pursuit of a tighter grip on the ECI's functioning.
Election Commission of India (ECI) is a constitutional body (under Article-324) vested with the responsibilities of superintendence, direction and control of conduct of elections. It consists of a Chief Election Commissioner and two Election Commissioners.
Article 324 states that the Election Commission shall consist of Chief Election Commissioner and such numbers of other Election Commissioners, if any, as the President may from time to time fix and appointment of CEC and other ECs shall, subject to provisions of any law made in that behalf by the Parliament, be made by the President.
Still, appointments in ECI is associated with various issues:
Lack of security of tenure for Election Commissioners (ECs).
Article 324(5) of the Constitution protects only CEC from removal, except if the manner and grounds of removal are the same as a judge of the Supreme Court. However, ECs can be removed by the government on the recommendation of the Chief Election Commissioner.
The appointment of CEC and other ECs according to the Article 324, shall be done as per the law made by the Parliament in this regard. However, no such law has yet been made which leaves a “gap” and leaves the appointment of such a crucial post solely to the executives.
The constitution has not prescribed the qualifications (legal, educational, administrative, or judicial) of the members of election commission.
The constitution has not debarred the retiring Election commissioner from any further appointment by the government.
There is no clarity regarding the power division between the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners.
Reforming the Election Commission of India: A Concise Action Plan
Legislation for Appointment: Create a clear law outlining how the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners are appointed, ensuring transparency and fair selection.
Qualifications Defined: Specify necessary qualifications and experience for Commissioners, focusing on legal expertise, administrative competence, and integrity.
Secure Tenure: Guarantee secure tenure for all Election Commissioners to prevent arbitrary removals and political influence.
Clear Powers Division: Clearly define roles and responsibilities of Chief Election Commissioner and other Commissioners to prevent conflicts.
Transparent Selection: Form a diverse selection committee including judiciary and civil society to assess candidates fairly.
Post-Retirement Rules: Introduce rules preventing retiring Commissioners from taking immediate government positions to prevent conflicts of interest.
Enhance Independence: Consider amending the Constitution to grant the Election Commission greater autonomy from government influence.
Capacity Building: Invest in regular training for Commissioners and staff to improve their understanding of electoral processes and technologies.
Public Awareness: Launch awareness campaigns to educate citizens about their voting rights and the significance of elections.
Ongoing Review: Periodically review and adapt the Commission's functioning to address emerging challenges and maintain electoral integrity.
Implementing these focused reforms will bolster the Election Commission's credibility, efficiency, and impartiality, strengthening India's democratic foundation.
The Basic Structure Doctrine emerged from the Kesavananda Bharati judgment of the Supreme Court, delivered by a majority of 7:6 on April 24, 1973. It held that Parliament could not alter the basic structure of the Constitution by an amendment.
There is no exclusive and definitive list of what the basic features are, for the judiciary decides this on a case-by-case basis. In consequence, as cases accumulate, the list of areas off-limits to the executive gets longer.
This creates a peculiar political environment where frenzied elections generate tall mandates that are undeliverable. The executive remains hamstrung, constrained not just by limited material resources but bound by limited and uncertain legal room to manoeuvre.
The consequence of this gap between parliamentary competence and executive impotence knocks the wind out of the power and capacity of electoral democracy.
The political culture it breeds is known as “cheap talk” in game theory, seen in such emphatic gestures as grandstanding and heady rhetoric followed by inaction, empty rhetoric and costless, non-binding, unverifiable communication between politicians and the electorate.
If you look at the syllabus of GS Paper II:
General Studies- II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International relations.
Indian Constitution—historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.
Mains 2019:
“Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution is a limited power and it cannot be enlarged into absolute power.” In the light of this statement explain whether Parliament under Article 368 of the Constitution can destroy the Basic Structure of the Constitution by expanding its amending power?
But in order to understand the Basic Structure concept, we will have to move sequentially from understanding the:
Amendment procedure
Genesis of the doctrine through various Supreme court judgments
The current ambit of the term
Merits and Demerits of the Basic Structure.
Constitutional amendment:
Like any other written Constitution, the Constitution of India also provides for its amendment in order to adjust itself to the changing conditions and needs. However, the procedure laid down for its amendment is neither as easy as in Britain nor as difficult as in USA. In other words, the Indian Constitution is neither flexible nor rigid but a synthesis of both. Article 368 in Part XX of the Constitution deals with the powers of Parliament to amend the Constitution and its procedure.
It states that the Parliament may, in exercise of its constituent power, amend by way of addition, variation or repeal any provision of the Constitution in accordance with the procedure laid down for the purpose. However, the Parliament cannot amend those provisions which form the ‘basic structure’ of the Constitution. This was ruled by the Supreme Court in the Kesavananda Bharati case1 (1973).
PROCEDURE FOR AMENDMENT
The procedure for the amendment of the Constitution as laid down in Article 368 is as follows: An amendment of the Constitution can be initiated only by the introduction of a bill for the purpose in either House of Parliament and not in the state legislatures.
The bill can be introduced either by a minister or by a private member and does not require prior permission of the president.The bill must be passed in each House by a special majority, that is, a majority of the total membership of the House and a majority of two-thirds of the members of the House present and voting.
Each House must pass the bill separately. In case of a disagreement between the two Houses, there is no provision for holding a joint sitting of the two Houses for the purpose of deliberation and passage of the bill. If the bill seeks to amend the federal provisions of the Constitution, it must also be ratified by the legislatures of half of the states by a simple majority, that is, a majority of the members of the House present and voting. After duly passed by both the Houses of Parliament and ratified by the state legislatures, where necessary, the bill is presented to the president for assent.
The president must give his assent to the bill. He can neither withhold his assent to the bill nor return the bill for reconsideration of the Parliament.
After the president’s assent, the bill becomes an Act (i.e., a constitutional amendment act) and the Constitution stands amended in accordance with the terms of the Act.
Emergence of the basic structure
The question whether Fundamental Rights can be amended by the Parliament under Article 368 came for consideration of the Supreme Court within a year of the Constitution coming into force. In the Shankari Prasad case (1951), the constitutional validity of the First Amendment Act (1951), which curtailed the right to property, was challenged.
The Supreme Court ruled that the power of the Parliament to amend the Constitution under Article 368 also includes the power to amend Fundamental Rights. The word ‘law’ in Article 13 includes only ordinary laws and not the constitutional amendment acts (constituent laws).
Therefore, the Parliament can abridge or take away any of the Fundamental Rights by enacting a constitutional amendment act and such a law will not be void under Article 13.
But in the Golak Nath case (1967), the Supreme Court reversed its earlier stand. In that case, the constitutional validity of the Seventeenth Amendment Act (1964), which inserted certain state acts in the Ninth Schedule, was challenged.
The Supreme Court ruled that the Fundamental Rights are given a ‘transcendental and immutable’ position and hence, the Parliament cannot abridge or take away any of these rights. A constitutional amendment act is also a law within the meaning of Article 13 and hence, would be void for violating any of the Fundamental Rights.
The Parliament reacted to the Supreme Court’s judgement in the Golak Nath case (1967) by enacting the 24th Amendment Act (1971). This Act amended Articles 13 and 368.
However, in the Kesavananda Bharati case3 (1973), the Supreme Court overruled its judgement in the Golak Nath case (1967). It upheld the validity of the 24th Amendment Act (1971) and stated that Parliament is empowered to abridge or take away any of the Fundamental Rights. At the same time, it laid down a new doctrine of the ‘basic structure’ (or ‘basic features’) of the Constitution.
It ruled that the constituent power of Parliament under Article 368 does not enable it to alter the ‘basic structure’ of the Constitution. This means that the Parliament cannot abridge or take away a Fundamental Right that forms a part of the ‘basic structure’ of the Constitution.
The doctrine of basic structure of the constitution was reaffirmed and applied by the Supreme Court in the Indira Nehru Gandhi case (1975).
In this case, the Supreme Court invalidated a provision of the 39th Amendment Act (1975) which kept the election disputes involving the Prime Minister and the Speaker of Lok Sabha outside the jurisdiction of all courts.
The court said that this provision was beyond the amending power of Parliament as it affected the basic structure of the constitution.
Again, the Parliament reacted to this judicially innovated doctrine of ‘basic structure’ by enacting the 42nd Amendment Act (1976). This Act amended Article 368 and declared that there is no limitation on the constituent power of Parliament and no amendment can be questioned in any court on any ground including that of the contravention of any of the Fundamental Rights.
However, the Supreme Court in the Minerva Mills case4 (1980) invalidated this provision as it excluded judicial review which is a ‘basic feature’ of the Constitution.
Applying the doctrine of ‘basic structure’ with respect to Article 368, the court held that: “Since the Constitution had conferred a limited amending power on the Parliament, the Parliament cannot under the exercise of that limited power enlarge that very power into an absolute power.
Indeed, a limited amending power is one of the basic features of the Constitution and, therefore, the limitations on that power cannot be destroyed. In other words, Parliament cannot, under article 368, expand its amending power so as to acquire for itself the right to repeal or abrogate the Constitution or to destroy its basic features. The donee of a limited power cannot by the exercise of that power convert the limited power into an unlimited one”.
Elements of the Basic Structure
The present position is that the Parliament under Article 368 can amend any part of the Constitution including the Fundamental Rights but without affecting the ‘basic structure’ of the Constitution.
However, the Supreme Court is yet to define or clarify as to what constitutes the ‘basic structure’ of the Constitution. From the various judgements, the following have emerged as ‘basic features’ of the Constitution or elements of the ‘basic structure’ of the constitution:
Supremacy of the Constitution.
Sovereign, democratic and republican nature of the Indian polity
Secular character of the Constitution
Separation of powers between the legislature, the executive and the judiciary
Legitimacy of the judgement can be questioned as the verdict was given on a very thin margin (7-6).
Judiciary is "overlooking the letters of the constitution" and "inventing its soul".
It's metaphysical appraoch "Basic Structure" disturbs the separation of power and establishes judicial sovereignty
Judiciary is least representative and most elitist, least accountable hence assuming the role of super legislature is unsuitable for democracy.
Since entire spectrum of BS is undefined, it creates uncertainty and discretion affecting the working of executive.
Arguments in favor:
The fundamental structure concept serves as evidence for the constitutionalist thesis that majority rule by force cannot destroy the core of the COI.
“Parliament too is a creature of the Constitution”. Therefore, it can only have such powers that are expressly vested on it. If those powers are seen as unlimited, Parliament, the Court found, “would cease to be an authority under the Constitution”; it would instead “become supreme over it, because it would have power to alter the entire Constitution including its basic structure”. In other words, the principle that Parliament is proscribed from changing the Constitution’s essential features is rooted in the knowledge that the Constitution, as originally adopted, was built on an intelligible moral foundation.
Because it serves as a check on constituent power, the fundamental concept preserved Indian democracy; otherwise, unchecked parliamentary power may have turned India into a totalitarian state.
Retaining the fundamental principles of our constitution, which our founding fathers so painstakingly crafted, is beneficial.
It gave citizens fundamental rights that no state organ can alter by restricting the legislative branch's ability to amend laws.
Being dynamic in nature, it is more progressive and open to changes in time unlike the rigid nature of earlier judgements.
It's important to note that the doctrine's implications and future depend on legal, political, and societal developments. Hence:
The courts will need to maintain their independence and commitment to upholding the Constitution's core values. Upholding the doctrine will require judges to have a deep understanding of constitutional principles and an unbiased approach to evaluating amendments.
The courts must ensure that the doctrine is not misused to stifle legitimate amendments that aim to enhance democratic governance.
As society and legal thinking continue to evolve, the doctrine's interpretation may also adapt. The judiciary should consider contemporary challenges and contexts when applying the doctrine.
Citizens need to understand the importance of safeguarding the Constitution's core principles and how the Basic Structure Doctrine plays a role in that protection.
Comparative analysis can help refine the Basic Structure Doctrine and adapt it to India's unique constitutional context.
While the doctrine primarily concerns the judiciary, it's crucial for the other branches to respect the Constitution's core principles.
Over time, it might be beneficial to assess whether the existing procedure for amending the Constitution is suitable or if any modifications are needed to balance the need for change with the need to protect the Constitution's core.
Remember that the evolution and future of the Basic Structure Doctrine will be influenced by various factors, including legal developments, political dynamics, societal changes, and the commitment of stakeholders to uphold the Constitution's values.
Context: The Union government introduced a Bill in the Rajya Sabha that proposed the selection panel for appointing the Election Commission.
CEC and other EC (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Bill, 2023
It repeals the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of EC and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991.
Important Provisions of the Bill
Composition of Election Commission
The Election Commission shall consist of— (a) Chief Election Commissioner (CEC); and (b) such number of other Election Commissioners (EC) as the President may fix from time to time.
The CEC and other EC shall be appointed by the President by warrant under his hand and seal.
Qualification
The CEC and other EC shall be appointed from amongst persons who are holding or have held a post equivalent to the rank of Secretary to the Government of India and shall be persons of integrity, who have knowledge of and experience in management and conduct of elections.
Search Committee
A Search Committee headed by the Cabinet Secretary and comprising of two other members not below the rank of Secretary to the Government of India, having knowledge and experience in matters relating to elections, shall prepare a panel of five persons for consideration of the Selection Committee, for appointment as the CEC and other EC.
Selection Committee
The CEC and other EC shall be appointed by the President on the recommendation of a Selection Committee consisting of
Prime Minister—Chairperson.
Leader of Opposition in the House of the People—Member.
a Union Cabinet Minister to be nominated by the Prime Minister—Member.
In the House of the People, where the Leader of Opposition has not been recognised as such, the leader of the single largest party in opposition of the Government in the House of the People shall be deemed to be the Leader of Opposition.
The appointment of the CEC and other EC shall not be invalid merely by reason of any vacancy in or any defect in the constitution of the Selection Committee.
Power of Selection Committee to Regulate its Own Procedure
Selection Committee shall regulate its own procedure in a transparent manner for selecting the CEC or other EC.
Selection Committee may also consider any other person than those included in the panel by the Search Committee.
Term of Office
The CEC and other EC shall hold office for a term of six years from the date on which he assumes his office or till he attains the age of sixty-five years, whichever is earlier.
The CEC and other EC shall not be eligible for re-appointment.
Where an Election Commissioner is appointed as CEC, his term of office shall not be more than six years in aggregate as the Election Commissioner and the CEC.
Salary
The salary, allowances and other conditions of service of the CEC and other EC shall be the same as those of the Cabinet Secretary.
Resignation and Removal
The CEC or an Election Commissioner may, at any time, by writing under his hand addressed to the President, resign his office.
The CEC and other EC shall not be removed except in accordance with the provisions contained in the first and second provisos respectively of clause (5) of article 324 of the Constitution.
Disposal of Business
The Election Commission may, by unanimous decision, regulate the procedure for transaction of its business as also allocation of its business amongst the CEC and other EC.
All business of the Election Commission shall, as far as possible, be transacted unanimously, and if the CEC and other EC differ in opinion on any matter, such matter shall be decided according to the opinion of the majority.
Supreme Court Judgement in Anoop Baranwal Vs Union of India
In this case Supreme Court declared that the appointment of CEC and ECs shall be made by the President based on advice tendered by a Committee consisting of the Prime Minister, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha and the Chief Justice of India.
The court also added that the aforesaid judgment that the said norm provided by the Supreme Court will continue to hold good till a law is made by the Parliament.
Changes Introduced
Election Commission (Conditions of Service of EC and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991.
CEC and other EC (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Bill, 2023
The act provides for appointment of CEC and ECs as President may decide.
It adds that the CEC and other ECs will be appointed by the President on the recommendation of a Selection Committee.
The act does not provide for any selection committee for appointment of CEC and ECs
It provides for a selection committee consisting of (i) the Prime Minister as Chairperson, (ii) the Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha as member, and (iii) a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister as member.
The act does not provide for any search committee for appointment of CEC and ECs.
It provides for a search committee headed by a Cabinet Secretary.
The act does not provide for qualification of a person to be appointed as CEC and EC.
The bill provides that Such persons must have expertise in managing and conducting elections.
The act provides that the salary of the ECs will be equal to that of a Supreme Court judge.
The Bill provides that salary, allowance, and service conditions of the CEC and other ECs will be the same as that of the Cabinet Secretary.
The bill does not have any provision about reappointments.
Under the Bill, the CEC and other ECs will not be eligible for re-appointment.
Issues with the new bill
Constitutional Question: Article 324(5) says that the terms of service of the CEC and ECs will be as enacted by Parliament provided that the removal of the CEC will be as the removal of the Supreme Court judges and ECs can be removed on the recommendation of the CEC by the President of India. These provisions cannot be amended by ordinary law of Parliament. It will need an amendment of the Constitution by Parliament.
Independence: The selection committee which has the majority of the government questions the independence of selection committee as being independent and impartial in the appointing process.
Downgrade in Condition of Service: The bill also downgrades the status and standing of the CEC and two ECs in case of salary and allowances from that equivalent to a Supreme Court judge to that of the Cabinet secretary.
Issue Remains: the issue that a CEC was not holding office for six years remains as the provision made under bill that combine tenure of the ECs cannot be more than 6 years, retirement age of 65 years for CEC leaves the possibility tenure being less than 6 years.
Arguments in favour of the Bill
Constitutional Mandate: Constitution provides that subject to the provision of the parliament law president can determine the condition of service of CEC and ECs.
In line with Judgement: According to the Supreme Court the direction given was subject to the law made by the parliament, so the bill agrees with the judgement.
Provide for Qualification: the proposed bill provides for the qualification which reduces the ambiguity and discretion of executive in appointment.
Constitution of Search and Selection Committees: the bill provides for the constitution of these bodies to streamline the process of selecting and appointing an individual.
Clarity about Reappointment: initially the act does not have clear provision about the reappointment, the bill tries to remove the ambiguity and clearly states that there cannot be any reappointment which ensure the independence of the election commission of India.
Election Commission of India was envisaged by the constitutional makers an independent body to conduct free and fair election in India. While old system of appointment had some inherent problems with it, it has also given us CEC like Sukumar Sen, T.N. Seshan etc. the bill introduced to fill the loopholes in the old act has some positive aspect and some issue associated with it which need further deliberation and debate in the Parliament.
Context: The article discusses the significant legal implications of the 'Lily Thomas v Union of India' case in relation to the disqualification of convicted lawmakers in India. In the past, Section 8(4) of the Representation of People Act (RPA) allowed a three-month window before the disqualification of convicted legislators came into effect, during which they could appeal their convictions. However, this provision was deemed unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in 2013, leading to a critical change in the way disqualifications are implemented. The case, brought forward by lawyer Lily Thomas and an NGO, aimed to cleanse Indian politics by preventing convicted politicians from participating in elections or holding office. The subsequent court ruling raised complex questions about the timing of disqualification, the role of the President of India, and the impact on lawmakers' careers. This article delves into the details of the case, its implications, and the ongoing debate surrounding the disqualification of convicted legislators.
Section 8(4) of the RPA said that the disqualification takes effect only “after three months have elapsed” from the date of conviction. Within that period, the convicted lawmaker could have filed an appeal against the sentence before a higher court.
However, this provision was struck down as “unconstitutional” in the Supreme Court’s landmark 2013 ruling in ‘Lily Thomas v Union of India’.
What is Lily Thomas case?
In 2005, a PIL was filed before the Apex Court by a Kerala-based lawyer Lily Thomas and NGO Lok Prahari, through its General Secretary SN Shukla, challenging Section 8(4) of the RPA as “ultra vires” to the Constitution, which protects convicted legislators from disqualification on account of their appeals pending before the higher courts.
This plea sought to clean Indian politics of criminal elements by barring convicted politicians from contesting elections or holding an official seat. It drew attention to Articles 102(1) and 191(1) of the Constitution. Article 102(1) lays down the disqualifications for membership to either House of Parliament and Article 191(1) lays down the disqualifications for membership to the Legislative Assembly or Legislative Council of the state. The plea argued that these provisions empower the Centre to add more disqualifications.
Before this judgment, convicted MPs could easily file an appeal against their conviction and continue holding their official seats.
What did the SC decide?
On July 10, 2013, a bench of Justices AK Patnaik and SJ Mukhopadhaya of the Apex Court held that “Parliament had no power to enact sub-section (4) of Section 8 of the Act and accordingly sub-section (4) of Section 8 of the Act is ultra vires the Constitution.”
The Court also held that if any sitting member of Parliament or State Legislature is convicted of any offence under sub-section (1), (2), and (3) of Section 8, RPA, then “by virtue of such conviction and/or sentence” they will be disqualified. The court added that a convicted parliamentarian or legislator’s membership will no longer be protected by Section 8 (4), as was previously the case.
The Court on an examination of other provisions in the Constitution that deal with disqualification of a lawmaker held that the Constitution “expressly prohibits” Parliament to defer the date from which a disqualification would come into effect.
Before this ruling, the law didn't result in an instant disqualification of sitting legislators. However, following the striking down of Section 8(4), some experts believed that a legislator would now be disqualified as soon as a court pronounced a conviction and sentence under Section 8(3) of the Representation of People Act. The Supreme Court stated that Article 102(1) treated sitting members and candidates the same in terms of disqualification, denying Parliament the authority to exempt sitting members for three months. Consequently, the Court declared Section 8(4) unconstitutional.
This change meant that only Section 8(3) remained in the Act for disqualifying those convicted and sentenced to two or more years in prison. This section specified that a person convicted and sentenced to at least two years in prison would be disqualified starting from the conviction date, without explicitly stating that the disqualification occurs immediately upon conviction.
This led to questions about the legal basis of Rahul Gandhi's instant disqualification, as the language implied an official declaration of disqualification was necessary.
The author's viewpoint suggested that the President of India, under Article 103, could have the authority to declare a sitting legislator disqualified. This perspective differed from the Supreme Court's stance in the Lily Thomas case. Another case, Consumer Education & Research ... vs Union Of India & Ors (2009), argued that a declaration by the President under Article 103 was essential for confirming disqualification.
Under Section 8(3), it seemed that a sitting member convicted and sentenced to two or more years' imprisonment would be disqualified from the conviction date. This disqualification would be executed by the President.
The legislative house's Secretariat lacked the authority to declare immediate disqualification upon a court's conviction.
A legal question arose regarding whether a stay of sentence alone could lift disqualification or if a stay of conviction was required.
Different High Courts had varied opinions on this matter. In Rahul Gandhi's case, the Supreme Court stayed the conviction but didn't address whether a stay of conviction was also necessary or if disqualification could be suspended.
The severity of disqualification hinged on the imprisonment length (two or more years), rather than just the conviction. The recent order in Rahul Gandhi's case emphasized this point. Disqualification wasn't directly related to conviction but to the sentence's duration.
The Lily Thomas judgment's impact on politicians' criminal behavior wasn't significantly evident. Politicians in power might secure rapid stays of conviction, saving themselves from immediate disqualification, unlike others who might have to wait and seek intervention from higher courts. It's suggested that Section 8(4) should be reinstated constitutionally to protect legislators' careers from sudden disruptions due to court orders lacking careful consideration.
Context: Union Home Minister introduces the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill 2023, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita Bill, 2023 and the Bharatiya Sakshya Bill, 2023 in the Lok Sabha.
Proposed Changes
Old Code
Proposed Code
Altered Provisions
Indian Penal Code, 1860
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill, 2023
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita will have 356 sections instead of the earlier 511 sections. 175 sections have been changed, 8 new sections have been added and 22 sections have been repealed.
Criminal Procedure Code, 1898
Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita Bill, 2023
Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita has 533 sections.160 sections of old law have been changed, 9 new sections have been added and 9 sections have been repealed
Indian Evidence Act, 1872
Bharatiya Sakshya Bill, 2023
Bharatiya Sakshya, will now have 170 sections instead of the earlier 167.23 sections have been changed, 1 new section has been added and 5 have been repealed.
Objective
To protect all the rights given to Indian citizens by the constitution, and not to punish the subjects but give justice to citizen.
The codes were based on the ideas of Victorian morality, made during the time of the British across all the departments now they are to be align in accordance with today's time and in the interest of the Indian society.
To address the new emerging challenges in jurisprudence that were not present in the 19th century e.g., use of technology in the criminal justice system.
Proposed Provisions in the Bills:
Definition of Document: The law expands the definition of documents to include electronic or digital records, e-mails, server logs, computers, smart phones, laptops, SMS, websites, locational evidence, mails, messages on devices.
Use of technology: Provision has been made in this law to digitize the entire process from FIR to case diary, case diary to charge sheet and charge sheet to judgement.
Videography has been made compulsoryat the time of search and seizure which will be part of the case and will not implicate innocent citizens.
Without such a recording by the police no charge sheet will be valid.
Effective Forensic: Provision to set up the National Forensic Science University to promote forensic science in a bid to increase the conviction ratio.
After three years, every year 33,000 forensic science experts and scientists will be available in the country;the target has been set in the law to take the conviction ratio above 90%.
The visit of the forensic team is being made compulsory on the crime scene of crimes having provision for punishment of 7 years or more, through this, the police will have scientific evidence, after which the chances of acquittal of the culprits in the court will be very less.
Sexual Harassment: The statement of the victim has been made compulsory in the cases of sexual violence and the video recording of the statement has also been made compulsory in the cases of sexual harassment.
Status of Complaint: It will be compulsory for the Police to give the status of the complaint in 90 days and thereafter every 15 days, to the complainant.
Limited Government:No government will be able to withdraw a caseof imprisonment of 7 years or more without listening to the victim, this will protect the rights of the citizens.
Summary Trial: Scope of summary trial has been increased in petty cases, now crimes punishable up to 3 years will be included in summary trial, with this provision alone, over 40% of cases in sessions courts will end.
Defined Time Limit:
A time limit of 90 days is fixed for filing the charge sheet and depending on the situation, the court can further give permission for 90 more days, the investigation will have to be completed within 180 days and trial should begin.
Courts will now be bound to give notice of framing of charge to the accused person within 60 days, The Honorable Judge, must deliver the verdict within 30 days following the conclusion of arguments, ensuring prompt resolution instead of prolonged delays, and the order will have to be made available online, within 7 days.
Government must decide on permission within 120 days for trial against civil servant or police officer else it will be treated as deemed permission and trial will be started.
Declared offenders: A provision has been brought for attachment of property of declared offenders; a new provision of harsh punishment against inter-state gangs and organized crimes is also being added to this law.
False Promise: Sex on the pretext of false promise of marriage, employment, promotion and false identity has been made a crime.
Petty Crimes: There was no provision for snatching of mobile phone or chain from women earlier but now a provision has been made for the same.
Limit the Pardon: The death penalty can only be changed to life imprisonment, life imprisonment to a minimum of 7 years and 7 years to a minimum of 3 years.
Sedition Repealed: India is a democracy, and everyone has the right to speak, the Bill is going to repeal sedition law completely.
New Definition: Earlier there was no definition of terrorism, now crimes like armed insurgency, subversive activities, separatism, challenging the unity, sovereignty and integrity of India have been defined in this law.
Fugitive Offenders: A historic decision regarding trial in absentia has been taken, a person declared fugitive by a Sessions Court judge will be tried and sentenced in his absence.
if the fugitive has to appeal against punishment, he will have to follow Indian law.
Death penalty for gang rape of minor: The Bill allows death penalty for gang rape of women below 18 years of age.
Benefits
Special Consideration for Vulnerable: Special care under the law has been taken of women and children, it has been ensured that criminals are punished, and the police cannot misuse their powers against vulnerable sections.
Holistic Coverage of Issue: In the proposed bill on one hand, laws like sedition have been repealed, on the other hand, provision of punishment for heinous crimes like exploiting women by cheating and mob lynching have been made, provisions also made for crack down on organized crimes and terrorism.
Collaborative Effort: 18 States, 6 Union Territories, the Supreme Court, 16 High Courts, 5 Judicial Academies, 22 Law Universities, 142 Members of Parliament, around 270 MLAs and the public have given their suggestions on these new laws.
Defined Procedure: Proposed bills provide for time limits from filing of charge sheets to disposal of cases. It also provides the definition of many offences like terrorism, insurgency etc. to bring clarity in the jurisprudence.
Issues
Redressing: Many experts have criticised the bill saying that most of these bills retain the same existing provisions under new names.
Wide Power to Police: New offences added such as acts endangering sovereignty, organised crime, mob lynching, terrorism, rape by false promise to marry which may ends up giving the police unreasonably wide powers of arrests.
New Version of Sedition: The sedition law has been replaced by another in the new bill which punishes "acts endangering sovereignty, unity and integrity of India" this is really an expanded definition of sedition itself.
Missed Opportunity:
The bills overlook certain crucial aspects e.g., Marital rape has not been criminalised despite India having tough laws to deter sexual violence against women.
The bills should have also revisited the other offences to reduce the vagueness e.g., offences relating to religion and blasphemy, some of which are still very vague and ambiguous to even qualify as criminal provisions.
Ambiguous Terms: Loosely defined terminology can create ambiguity. E.g., the terminology of "modesty" employed in the code for the offence of "outraging the modesty of a woman" can have variable interpretation.
Practical Limitations: A provision that mandates a minimum sentence of seven years in prison, life imprisonment, or even the death penalty for every individual within a mob a gathering of five or more people found guilty of committing murder put a practical limit in execution of the sentences given.
Institutional challenges: The bill proposes that every crime scene must undergo forensic investigation which put a tremendous pressure on India's forensic system and create infrastructural challenges.
The Parliamentary Standing Committee in its 111th and 128th reports had stressed upon the need to reform and rationalise the criminal law of the country by introducing a comprehensive legislation in Parliament rather than bringing about piecemeal amendments in respective acts. While government should adhere to the recommendation, special attention should be given to reduce the discretion of executives, decrease the ambiguities in the words and debate and deliberation should be done to include the pressing issues marital rape, blasphemy provisions etc.
Context: Manipur Assembly failed to hold a Special Session to discuss the ethnic violence in the State as the Raj Bhavan did not issue a notification to convene it despite a recommendation from the State Cabinet. As per the official statement of the State Cabinet, it had recommended the Governor to summon the fourth session of the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly on August 21. This followed a similar request from the government on July 27. The previous session of the Assembly was adjourned sine die in March, more than a month before the clashes started on May 3. The next session has to be held before 2nd September according to Article 174.
Article 174 - Sessions of the State Legislature, prorogation and dissolutionThe Governor shall from time to time summon the House or each House of the Legislature of the State to meet at such time and place as he thinks fit, but six months shall not intervene between its last sitting in one session and the date appointed for its first sitting in the next session.
Governor has power to summon the house as per Article 174 of the Indian Constitution
SC referred Constituent Assembly debates and noted that the framers of the Constitution expressly and consciously did not grant exclusive power to the Governor to summon or dissolve the House.
SC discussed that Article 153 of the Draft Constitution (which later became Article 174 in the present constitution), dealt with the powers of the Governor, was substantially altered to indicate that the constitution framers did not want to give Governors the discretion in summoning of the Assembly.
After debating the intention of the framers, the court concluded that “the Constitution makers altered their original contemplation and consciously decided not to vest discretion with the Governor, in the matter of summoning and dissolving the House, or Houses of the State Legislature.
Thus, the Supreme Court in Nabam Rebia judgment decided that Governor can summon, prorogue and dissolve the House, only on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers with the Chief Minister as the head. And not at his own.
Nabam Rebia & Bamang Felix v Deputy Speaker (Arunachal Pradesh)
Speaker Rebia petitioned that the Governor’s act of interfering in the functioning of the State legislature fell outside the scope of Article 161 and Article 163(2).
Quashed Governor’s Order to Prepone the Assembly Session -The Constitution Bench quashed the Governor's order dated 9.12.2015 preponing the 6th session of the Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly by a month without consulting the Chief Minister, Council of Ministers, or the Speaker, for violating Article 174.
Governor's authority to call, dissolve, and advance a session is subject to judicial review –
Governor’s Power under Article 174 not a discretionary power - Governor can summon, prorogue and dissolve the House, only on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers with the Chief Minister as the head. And not at his own under Article 174.
Powers of the Governor are not absolute – Referring to Article 163,the Court noted that the Governor does not have vast discretionary powers and is necessarily bound by the constitutional framework. According to Article 163, the Governor may only exercise this power with the assistance of the Council of Ministers and Chief Minister.
Speaker cannot disqualify members when a motion of removal is pending against him - Speaker's decision to disqualify rebelled MLAs under Article 179(c) amounted to an attempt to circumvent the votes of "all the then members", and as such, the Speaker's decision was unconstitutional.
President’s Rule Unconstitutional - Supreme Court reinstalled the previous government and declared all of the Governor's actions that led to the implementation of President's Rule unconstitutional. The Court also ordered a floor test to determine the Government's majority, restoring the floor test's credibility.
The Court also overruled the verdict of the Guwahati High Court which found that the Governor's notice was unconstitutional because it breached Article 163 read with Article 174 of the Indian Constitution.
Nebam Rebia Judgment has been referred to Seven Judge Constitution Bench
In the case of Subhash Desai v Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra & Ors, CJI’s Bench while hearing the Shiv Sena political crisis issue referred the Five Judge Constitution Bench Judgment of Nebam Rebia to a larger Seven Judge Bench based on the following reasons:
First, according to Kihoto Hollohan v Zachillhu (1992), the Court cannot interfere in the interlocutory stage of disqualification proceedings as per the Tenth Schedule. As per Nabam Rebia, disqualification proceedings would be stopped if a notice of intention to remove the Speaker was filed. This would amount to interference.
Second, the Bench in Nabam Rebia failed to consider the possible misuse of this decision. MLAs undergoing disqualification would simply file a notice of intention against the Speaker and stop the proceedings.
Third, disabling the speaker would take away the role of the Speaker as a Tribunal under the Tenth Schedule. It would disrupt the functioning of the Speaker, and therefore the Tribunal, in hearing disqualification proceedings. It would then create a ‘constitutional hiatus’.
Context: Rajya Sabha Chairman referred complaints related to the privilege of the House to the privileges committee.
“Privilege and Immunity” Under Constitution
In part V of the Constitution under the title “Powers, Privileges and Immunities of Parliament and its Members” constitution define the following:
Article 105: Powers, privileges, etc., of the Houses of Parliament and of the members and committees thereof:
Subject to the provisions of this Constitution and to the rules and standing orders regulating the procedure of Parliament, there shall be freedom of speech in Parliament.
No member of Parliament shall be liable to any proceedings in any court in respect of anything said or any vote given by him in Parliament or any committee thereof, and no person shall be so liable in respect of the publication by or under the authority of either House of Parliament of any report, paper, votes or proceedings.
In other respects, the powers, privileges and immunities of each House of Parliament, and of the members and the committees of each House, shall be such as may from time to time be defined by Parliament by law, and, until so defined, shall be those of that House and of its members and committees immediately before the coming into force of section 15 of the Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978.
The provisions of clauses (1), (2) and (3) shall apply in relation to persons who by virtue of this Constitution have the right to speak in, and otherwise to take part in the proceedings of, a House of Parliament or any committee thereof as they apply in relation to members of Parliament.
In part VI of the Constitution under the title “Powers, Privileges and Immunities of State Legislatures and its Members” constitution define the following:
Art 194: Powers, privileges, etc., of the Houses of Legislatures and of the members and committees thereof:
Subject to the provisions of this Constitution and to the rules and standing orders regulating the procedure of the Legislature, there shall be freedom of speech in the Legislature of every State.
No member of the Legislature of a State shall be liable to any proceedings in any court in respect of anything said or any vote given by him in the Legislature or any committee thereof, and no person shall be so liable in respect of the publication by or under the authority of a House of such a Legislature of any report, paper, votes or proceedings.
In other respects, the powers, privileges and immunities of a House of the Legislature of a State, and of the members and the committees of a House of such Legislature, shall be such as may from time to time be defined by the Legislature by law, and, until so defined, shall be those of that House and of its members and committees immediately before the coming into force of section 26 of the Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978.
The provisions of clauses (1), (2) and (3) shall apply in relation to persons who by virtue of this Constitution have the right to speak in, and otherwise to take part in the proceedings of, a House of the Legislature of a State or any committee thereof as they apply in relation to members of that Legislature.
Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha
Under the above rules in Chapter XX named “Privileges” Lok Sabha deals with the “Questions of Privileges”
Rule 222: Consent of the speaker
A member may, with the consent of the Speaker, raise a question involving a breach of privilege either of a member or of the House or of a committee thereof.
Rule 223: Notice of question of privileges
A member wishing to raise a question of privilege shall give notice in writingto the Secretary-General on the day the question is proposed to be raised. If the question raised is based on a document, the notice shall be accompanied by the document.
Rule 224: Admissibility of questions of Privileges
The right to raise a question of privilege shall be governed by the following conditions, namely
Not more than one question shall be raised at the same sitting.
The question shall be restricted to a specific matter of recent occurrence.
The matter requires the intervention of the House.
Rule 225: Mode of raising questions of privilege
The Speaker, if gives consent under rule 222 and holds that the matter proposed to be discussed is in order, shall call the member concerned, who shall rise in one’s own place and, while asking for leave to raise the question of privilege, make a short statement relevant thereto.
Where the Speaker has refused to give consent under rule 222 or is of opinion that the matter proposed to be discussed is not in order,the Speaker, if thinks necessary, may read the notice of question of privilege and state that the consent is refused or the notice of question of privilege is not in order: Provided further that the Speaker may, on being satisfied about the urgency of the matter, allow a question of privilege to be raised at any time during the course of a sitting after the disposal of questions.
If objection to leave being granted is taken, the Speaker shall request those members who are in favour of leave being granted to rise in their places, and if not less than twenty-five members rise accordingly, the Speaker shall declare that leave is granted. If less than twenty-five members rise, the Speaker shall inform the member that such member has not the leave of the House.
Rule 226: Questions of privilege to be considered by House or Committee.
If leave under rule 225 is granted, the House may consider the question and come to a decision or refer it to a Committee of Privileges on a motion made either by the member who has raised the question of privilege or by any other member.
Rule 227: Reference of questions of privilege to Committee by Speaker
Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, the Speaker may refer any question of privilege to the Committee of Privileges for examination, investigation or report.
Rule 228: Power of Speaker to give directions
The Speaker may issue such directions as may be necessary for regulating the procedure in connection with all matters connected with the consideration of the question of privilege either in the Committee of Privileges or in the House.
Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Rajya Sabha
Under these rules in Chapter XVI Rajya Sabha deals with the “Questions of Privileges”
Rule 187: Question of Privileges
Subject to the provisions of these rules, a member may, with the consent of the Chairman, raise a question involving a breach of privilege either of a member or of the Council or of a committee thereof.
Rule 188: Notice
A member wishing to raise a question of privilege shall give notice in writing to the Secretary-General, before the commencement of the sitting on the day the question is proposed to be raised. If the question proposed to be raised is based on a document, the notice shall be accompanied by the document.
Rule 189: Conditions of admissibility
The e shall be governed by the following conditions, namely:
The question shall be restricted to a specific matter of recent occurrence.
The matter requires the intervention of the Council.
Rule 190: Mode of raising a question on privileges
The Chairman, if he gives consent under rule 187 and holds that the matter proposed to be discussed is in order, shall, after the questions and before the list of business is entered upon, call the member concerned, who shall rise in his place and while asking for leave to raise the question of privilege make a short statement relevant thereto.
Where the Chairman has refused his consent under rule 187 or is of opinion that the matter proposed to be discussed is not in order, he may, if he thinks it necessary, read the notice of question of privilege and state that he refuses consent or holds that the notice of question of privilege is not in order: Provided further that the Chairman may, if he is satisfied about the urgency of the matter, allow a question of privilege to be raised at any time during the course of a sitting after the disposal of questions.
If objection to leave being granted is taken, the Chairman shall request those members, who are in favour of leave being granted to rise in their places and if not less than twenty-five members rise accordingly, the Chairman shall intimate that leave is granted. If less than twenty-five members rise the Chairman shall inform the member that he has not the leave of the Council.
Rule 191: Reference to committee of privileges
If leave under rule 190 is granted, the Council may consider the question and come to a decision or refer it to the Committee of Privileges on a motion made either by the member who has raised the question of privilege or by any other member.
Rule 192: constitution of committee of privileges
The Chairman shall, from time to time, nominate a Committee of Privileges consisting of ten members.
The Committee nominated under sub-rule (1) shall hold office until a new Committee is nominated.
Casual vacancies in the Committee shall be filled by the Chairman.
Rule 193: Chairman of Committee
The Chairman of the Committee shall be appointed by the Chairman from amongst the members of the Committee.
If the Chairman of the Committee is for any reason unable to act, the Chairman may similarly appoint another Chairman of the Committee in his place.
If the Chairman of the Committee is absent from any meeting, the Committee shall choose another member to act as Chairman of the Committee for that meeting.
Rule 194: Quorum
The quorum of the Committee shall be five.
Rule 195: Examination of the question
The Committee shall examine every question referred to it and determine with reference to the facts of each case whether a breach of privilege is involved and, if so, the nature of the breach, the circumstances leading to it and make such recommendations as it may deem fit.
Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (1) of this rule, the report may also state the procedure to be followed by the Council in giving effect to the recommendations made by the Committee.
Rule 196: Power to take evidence or call for papers, records or documents
The Committee of Privileges shall have power to require the attendance of persons or the production of papers or records, if such a course is considered necessary for the discharge of its duties:
Provided that if any question arises whether the evidence of a person or the production of a document is relevant for the purposes of the Committee, the question shall be referred to the Chairman, whose decision shall be final:
Provided further that Government may decline to produce a document on the ground that its disclosure would be prejudicial to the safety or interest of the State.
Subject to the provisions of this rule, a witness may be summoned by an order signed by the Secretary-General, and shall produce such documents as are required for the use of the Committee.
It shall be in the discretion of the Committee to treat any evidence tendered before it as secret or confidential.
Rule 197: Sitting of the Committee
As soon as may be, after a question of privilege has been referred to the Committee of Privileges, the Committee shall meet from time to time and shall make a report within the time fixed by the Council:
Provided that where the Council has not fixed any time for the presentation of the report, the report shall be presented within one month of the date on which reference to the Committee was made:
Provided further that the Council may at any time, on a motion being made, direct that the time for the presentation of the report by the Committee be extended, to a date specified in the motion.
Reports may be either preliminary or final.
The report shall be signed by the Chairman of the Committee on behalf of the Committee:
Provided that in case the Chairman of the Committee is absent or is not readily available, the Committee shall choose any other member to sign the report on behalf of the Committee.
Rule 198: Presentation of report
The report of the Committee of Privileges shall be presented to the Council by the Chairman of the Committee or in his absence by any member of the Committee.
Rule 199: Motion of consideration of report
As soon as may be, after the report has been presented, a motion in the name of the Chairman of the Committee or any member of the Committee may be put down that the report be taken into consideration.
Rule 200: Amendments to motion for consideration of report
Any member may give notice of amendment to the motion for consideration of the report referred to in rule 199 in such form as may be considered appropriate by the Chairman: Provided that an amendment may be moved that the question be re-committed to the Committee either without limitation or with reference to any particular matter.
Rule 201: Motion after consideration of report
After the motion for consideration of the report has been carried, the Chairman or any member of the Committee or any other member, as the case may be, may move that the Council agrees, or disagrees, or agrees with amendments, with the recommendations contained in the report.
Rule 202: Regulation of procedure
The Chairman may issue such directions as he may consider necessary for regulating the procedure in connection with all matters connected with the consideration of the question of privilege either in the Committee or in the Council.
Rule 203: Power of Chairman to refer a question of privilege to Committee
Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, the Chairman may refer any question of privilege to the Committee of Privileges for examination, investigation and report.
Context: Rajya Sabha suspended some of its Member of Parliament (MP) under Rule 256.
Suspension of the Member from the Houses
Provisions for Suspension of a Member
Rule of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha
Rule 373: Withdrawal of a Member
Under this rule the Speaker, if is of the opinion that the conduct of any member is grossly disorderly, may direct such member to withdraw immediately from the House, and any member so ordered to withdraw shall do so forth with and shall remain absent during the remainder of the day’s sitting.
Rule 374: Suspension of the Member
The Speaker, may, if deems it necessary, name a member who disregards the authority of the Chair or abuses the rules of the Houseby persistently and wilfully obstructing the business thereof.
If a member is so named by the Speaker, the Speaker shall, on a motion being made forthwith put the question that the member (naming such member) be suspended from the service of the House for a period not exceeding the remainder of the session: Provided that the House may, at any time, on a motion being made, resolve that such suspension be terminated.
A member suspended under this rule shall forthwith withdraw from the precincts of the House.
Rule 374A: Automatic Suspension of a Member
This rule talks about the automatic suspension of a member:
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in rules 373 and 374, in the event of grave disorder occasioned by a member coming into the well of the House or abusing the Rules of the House persistently and wilfully obstructing its business by shouting slogans or otherwise, such member shall, on being named by the Speaker, stand automatically suspended from the service of the House for five consecutive sittings or the remainder of the session, whichever is less:
Provided that the House may, at any time, on a motion being made, resolve that such suspension be terminated.
(2) On the Speaker announcing the suspension under this rule, the member shall forthwith withdraw from the precincts of the House.
Suspension of Members in Rajya Sabha
Rule of Procedures and Conduct of Business in the Council of State (Rajya Sabha) provides for the suspension of the Rajya Sabha member under the following rules:
Rule of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Lok Sabha
Rule 256: Suspension of the Member
The Chairman may, if he deems it necessary, name a member who disregards the authority of the Chair or abuses the rules of the Council by persistently and willfully obstructing the business thereof.
If a member is so named by the Chairman he shall forthwith put the question on a motion being made, no amendment, adjournment or debate being allowed, that the member (naming him) be suspended from the service of the Council for a period not exceeding the remainder of the Session: Provided that the Council may, at any time, on a motion being made, resolve that such suspension be terminated.
A member suspended under this rule shall forthwith quit the precincts of the Council.
Rule 266: Residuary Powers
All matters not specifically provided for in these rules and all questions relating to the detailed working of these rules shall be regulated in such manner as the Chairman may, from time to time direct.
Overview of the Rules
They are meant to clear obstruction in the House so that business can be conducted without obstruction
They have an element of punishment in them, on suspension, the member is required to immediately leave the House, or he will be forcefully removed.
The right to punish a member is vested in the House only, and not in the Chair. So, if the motion is not passed by the House, the member is not suspended.
The maximum period of suspension is until the end of that session.
The rules provide for the termination of suspension at any time.
The member is temporarily disqualified in as much as he is not allowed to attend the meetings of the House or any meeting of the committees of which he may be a member, during his suspension.
The member won’t be allowed to give any notice of questions, motions or resolutions, he is compelled to remain a non-member during the period of such suspension.
Ambit of the Rules
Power of Presiding officer
It refers to a blatant and shocking defiance of the Chair persistently by the member.
Under the rules, disregarding the authority of the Chair does not mean that the Chair can name a member for lack of cooperation.
The rules apply when there is a very aggravated form of defiance and obstruction that leaves the Chair with no option other than suspension of the member.
Period of Suspension
The nature of suspension is a temporary punishment that can be revoked anytime.
Even when a member is suspended for the remainder of the session it can be revoked within a day or two.
The basic principle is that the House needs the uninterrupted services of all its members, who are the representative of the people, suspension is to be a last resort.
Case of Pending Investigation
Suspension pending investigation is done only in the case of government employees because the rules permit it, but in the case of members of parliament, there is no such rule.
Constitutional Mandate of Rulemaking Powers of Houses
Article 118: Rules of Procedure
Each House of Parliament may make rules for regulating, subject to the provisions of this Constitution, its procedure and the conduct of its business.
Until rules are made under clause (1), the rules of procedure and standing orders in force immediately before the commencement of this Constitution with respect to the Legislature of the Dominion of India shall have effect in relation to Parliament subject to such modifications and adaptations as may be made therein by the Chairman of the Council of States or the Speaker of the House of the People, as the case may be.
The President, after consultation with the Chairman of the Council of States and the Speaker of the House of the People, may make rules as to the procedure with respect to joint sittings of, and communications between, the two Houses.
At a joint sitting of the two Houses the Speaker of the House of the People, or in his absence such person as may be determined by rules of procedure made under clause (3), shall preside.
Overview of Constitutional Mandate
The rules of the Houses of Parliament are framed under Article 118 of the Constitution, and these should operate only subject to the provisions of the Constitution.
The Houses are required to regulate their activities only in accordance with these rules, suspension of a member can, therefore, be done only in accordance with the rules (374 and 256).
Residuary powers (Rule 266 of the Rajya Sabha) can be invoked only when the House is dealing with matters that are not explicitly provided in the rules.
Court Cases
Ashish Shelar vs Maharashtra Legislative Assembly (2022)
The Supreme Court held that if the resolution passed by the House was to provide for suspension beyond the period prescribed under the said rule, it would be substantially illegal, irrational and unconstitutional.
Context: Tamil Nadu government said it would move the Supreme Court over its due share of Cauvery water from Karnataka, as the neighbouring State has refused to share the water with Tamil Nadu.
About Cauvery River
The river has a total length of around 802 km, and a catchment area of 81,155 sq. km, of which 2,866 sq.km. lie in Kerala, 34,273 sq.km. in Karnataka and 44,016 sq.km. in Tamil Nadu.
Flow of Cauvery
Cauvery, the Ganga of the South, rises at Thalakaveri, in the Brahmagiri range of hills of the Western Ghats, in Karnataka.
It receives the Harangi which has been dammed North-West of Mysore.
Two other tributaries-Hemavathy and Lakshmana-theertha join the Cauvery into the Harangi reservoir.
The main river continues to flow Eastwards up to Sreerangapatnam and then changes its course South-East wards.
Then it receives Kabini, an important tributary that originates in the Wyanad district of Kerala.
Then, it joins with Suvarnavathy and takes a North-Easterly direction, passing the Eastern Ghats at Sivasamudram.
At Sivasamudram, after flowing through a very narrow gorge, it continues its East-ward journey and forms the boundary between the States of Karnataka and Tamil Nadu for about 64km.
Below Sivasamudram, it receives the Shimsha, and then Arkavathy, just before entering the territory of Tamil Nadu.
In Tamil Nadu, the river Cauvery continues to flow Eastwards up to Hogenakal Falls and takes a Southerly course and enters the Mettur reservoir.
It leaves the Eastern Ghats below Mettur and is joined by Bhavani downstream.
Cauvery takes a more Easterly course after that and is joined by Noyil, and then by Amaravathy.
Amaravathy, an important tributary of the Cauvery, has its origin in Kerala, where it is known as Pambar, and carries rich flows in Kerala.
Below Tiruchirappalli, the Cauvery splits into two branches, which are controlled by the Upper Anicut.
The Northern branch, called the Coleroon flows in a North-Easterly direction to enter the Bay of Bengal near Porto Novo.
The Southern branch, however, continues to trek under the name of Cauvery itself. It further divides into Cauvery and Vennar below the Grand Anicut.
The Cauvery branch descends into the Bay at Pompuhar, North of Tranqobar as an insignificant stream.
The Dispute between Karnataka and Tamil Nadu
The Cauvery water sharing dispute, dating back to the British Raj, remains a contentious issue between Karnataka and Tamil Nadu. Many of the districts in both states are dependent on the Cauvery for irrigation.
The Cauvery water dispute emerged in 1892 between British-ruled Madras Presidency and the princely state of Mysore over water sharing.
In 1910, the two states began conceptualising the idea of constructing reservoirs to store the river water.
The 1924 agreement presided over by the British gave Madras Presidency and the Mysore state the right to use surplus water from river Cauvery.
As per the agreement in 1924, Tamil Nadu and Puducherry would get 75% of the surplus water, while Karnataka would get 23%. The remaining would go to Kerala.
There were also restrictions on how much land could be irrigated.
Post-Independence
The challenge of water sharing escalated following the state reorganization in 1956:
Through the late 20th century, Tamil Nadu was opposed to the construction of dams on the river by Karnataka.
Karnataka contended that the 1924 agreement's 50-year term expired in 1974, freeing the state from adhering to the regulations, especially since the river originated in the state.
Between 1960 and late 1980s, Karnataka built four dams on Cauvery – Hemavati, Harangi, Kabini and Suvarnavathy.
This became a problem for Tamil Nadu as the state had become dependent on Cauvery water especially huge area of agricultural land in the delta area.
Involvement of Supreme Court (SC) and Tribunal
Tamil Nadu argued that being the lower riparian state put them in a precarious situation and approached the Supreme Court (SC).
Karnataka government’s arguments
Karnataka argued that river water sharing should follow international norms to divide the water in equal proportions.
Karnataka proposed a 47% water allocation for each state, with the remaining divided equally between Kerala and Puducherry.
Tamil Nadu government’s arguments
Tamil Nadu wanted to stick to the 1924 agreement.
In 1986, Tamil Nadu's farmers urged the SC for a tribunal to address water sharing.
In 1990, the SC directed the Centre to establish a tribunal for inter-state water distribution.
The Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal (CWDT) assessed 1980-1990 water inflow to Tamil Nadu.
In 1991, it ordered Karnataka to provide 205 tmcft annual water and cease irrigated land expansion.
Karnataka rejected the tribunal’s award and sought an annulment in the Supreme Court.
The SC struck down the state’s ordinance attempting to nullify the award and went on to uphold the tribunal’s order.
After which Karnataka said that the state was facing drought and hence could not release water.
The 1998-formed Cauvery River Authority (CRA), which included the Prime Minister as Chairperson and the Chief Ministers from four states as members, enforced CWDT's interim order.
Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal in 2007 gave out its final award.
CWDT directed Karnataka to release 192 tmcft annually, including 182 tmcft for Tamil Nadu with 10 tmcft for environment, at Billingundlu border.
In a distress year, allocated shares shall be proportionately reduced among Kerala, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and Puducherry.
Constitutional provisions
Part XI of the constitution under the title Relations between the Union and the States provides for Disputes relating to Waters.
Article 262: Adjudication of disputes relating to waters of inter-State rivers or river valleys.
Parliament may by law provide for the adjudication of any dispute or complaint with respect to the use, distribution or control of the waters of, or in, any inter-State river or river valley.
Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution, Parliament may by law provide that neither the Supreme Court nor any other courtshall exercise jurisdiction in respect of any such dispute or complaint as is referred to in clause (1).
Seventh Schedule
Entry 56 of List I: Regulation and development of inter-State rivers and river valleys to the extent to which such regulation and development under the control of the Union is declared by Parliament by law to be expedient in the public interest.
Entry 17 of List II: Water, that is to say, water supplies, irrigation and canals, drainage and embankments, water storage and water power subject to the provisions of entry 56 of List I.
Provision used by Courts
Tamil Nadu filed a preliminary complaint in 2001 of Article 131, in which it stated that interim measures were not effectively regulated.
The States of Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and Kerala, disturbed by the decision of the Cauvery Water Dispute Tribunal in 2007, have applied for a special permit pursuant to Article 136. The Supreme Court accepts them.
Article 131: Original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court
Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Supreme Court shall, to the exclusion of any other court, have original jurisdiction in any dispute
Between the Government of India and one or more States;
Between the Government of India and any State or States on one side and one or more other States on the other;
Between two or more States
Art 136: Special leave to appeal by the Supreme Court
Notwithstanding anything in this Chapter, the Supreme Court may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any court or tribunal in the territory of India.
Nothing in clause (1) shall apply to any judgment, determination, sentence or order passed or made by any court or tribunal constituted by or under any law relating to the Armed Forces.
Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956
In Pursuant to the power conferred by the Constitution under Article 262, Parliament has enacted the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956. Following are Its main features:
Filing of dispute: A State Government which has a water dispute with another State Government requests the Central Government to refer the dispute to a tribunal for adjudication.
Scope for negotiations: The Central Government, if it is of the opinion that the dispute cannot be settled by negotiation, refer the dispute to a Tribunal.
Tribunal and its composition: As laid down by the act It consists of a chairman and two other members, nominated by the Chief Justice of India from among persons who, at the time of such nomination, are Judges of the Supreme Court or High Court.
Appointment of Assessor: Central government in consultation with the Tribunal can appoint assessors to advise it in the proceedings before it.
Investigation and Report: With the reference being made by the Central Government, the Tribunal investigates the matter and makes its report, embodying its decision. The decision is to be published by the centra government and is to be final and binding on the parties.
Bar on Courts: Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court and other courts, in respect of the dispute referred to the Tribunal, is barred.
Formulation of scheme: Central Government may frame a scheme, providing for all matters necessary to give effect to the decision of the Tribunal. It can provide for establishing an authority for implementing the scheme. (Section 6A)
Dissolution of Tribunal: The Central Government dissolves the Tribunal after it has forwarded its report and the Central Government is satisfied that no further reference to the Tribunal would be necessary.
The River Boards Act 1956
The River Boards Act, 1956, provides for the establishment of River Boards, for the regulation and development of inter-State rivers and river valleys.
Establishment: The Central Government can establish a Board for “advising the Government of state”when a request is received from a State Government or otherwise.
Establishment: The established board deals in relation to matters concerning the regulation or development of an inter-State river or river valley, or any specified part as notified by the Central Government.
Different Boards may be established for different inter-State rivers or river valleys.
The Board consist of the Chairman and such other members as the Central Government thinks fit to appoint.
The appointed member must have special knowledge and experience in irrigation, electrical engineering, flood control, navigation, water conservation, soil conservation, administration or finance.
Functions of the Board: As set out in the Act, they are very wide, covering conservation of the water resources of the inter-State river, schemes for irrigation and drainage, development of hydro-electric power, schemes for flood control, promotion of navigation, control of soil erosion and prevention of pollution.
All functions of the Board are advisory and not adjudicatory.
The Board is directed to consult all the Governments concerned and to secure agreement among such governments, as far as possible. (Section 14(3))
Formulation of scheme: The Board is empowered to frame schemes, obtain comments from the interested Governments and finalise a scheme. (Section 15(2)).
The schemes so framed are not mandatory to implement, they are of an advisory nature. (Section 15(5)).
Central Assistance: The Central Government can “assist the state Governments interested”, in taking such steps as may be necessary, for execution of the scheme. (Section 15(6))
Arbitration: The act provides for arbitration in the listed matters where any dispute or difference arises between two or more Government interested. (Section 22)
Context: The Kerala Assembly passed a resolution urging the Centre to rename the state as “Keralam” in the Constitution and all office records.
Arguments by Kerala Government to change the name
The name of the State is Keralam in Malayalam language.
The need to unite Kerala for the Malayalam-speaking communities has been strongly evident since the time of the national freedom struggle and even reflected in the linguistic reorganisation of the states.
Origin of the name
The earliest epigraphic record that mentions Kerala is emperor Asoka’s Rock Edict II of 257 BC. The inscription refers to the local ruler as Keralaputra (Sanskrit for “son of Kerala”).
About ‘Keralam’, it is believed to have originated from ‘Cheram’.
The origin of the term Cheram could possibly be from the root ‘cher’, which means to join. This clears the meaning in the compound word ‘Cheralam’, in which alam means region or land.
Constitutional Provisions
According to constitution of India parliament has the power to change the name of a state under Article 3.
Article 3 of the constitution
Formation of new States and alteration of areas, boundaries or names of existing States:
Parliament may by law—
Form a new State by separation of territory from any State or by uniting two or more States or parts of States or by uniting any territory to a part of any State
Increase the area of any State
Diminish the area of any State
Alter the boundaries of any State
Alter the name of any State
- Provided that no Bill for the purpose shall be introduced in either House of Parliament except on the recommendation of the President and unless, where the proposal contained in the Bill affects the area, boundaries or name of any of the States.
- Provided the Bill has been referred by the President to the Legislature of that State for expressing its views thereon within such period as may be specified in the reference or within such further period as the President may allow and the period so specified or allowed has expired.
- According to Article 4 which deals with Laws made under articles 2 and 3 to provide for the amendment of the First and the Fourth Schedules and supplemental, incidental and consequential matters provides that law made under Article 2 and 3 shall not be deemed to be an amendment of this Constitution for the purposes of article 368.
Procedure to change the name of a state
A bill with the intent to change the name of the state can be presented in Parliament or State Legislative Assembly of the concerned state for such alterations.
In Parliament, the bill cannot be presented without a recommendation from the President.
The bill should be represented to the Legislative Assembly of the state concerned to present its views on the bill within the prescribed time period. This Consultative mechanism provided helps in maintaining the spirit of federalism
The views or suggestions of the State Legislature are not binding to the President or The Parliament. After receiving the suggestions of the State Legislative Assembly or after the expiration of the limited time period the bill goes back to Parliament. Then the bill gets further deliberated upon in Parliament.
The bill, like any ordinary bill, must be passed with a simple majority.
The bill is next sent for assent to the President.
After the approval is given by the President. The Act will be enforced, and the name of the state will be changed.