Constitution & Polity of India

Politicization of Bureaucracy

Context: Recently, a circular by Central government has asked the Senior Civil Servants to act as “rath prabharis” to highlight the achievements of Central government in past 9 years.

Politicization of Bureaucracy: It refers to the process by which Civil Service become influenced and controlled by political considerations and partisan interests, rather than being driven by the principles of neutrality, professionalism, and public service.

Ideally, Civil Servants are expected to be politically neutral and objectively serve elected governments coming from various shades of political spectrum with equal commitment.

Civil servants as citizens can have political choices and viewpoints but as a key functionary of the executive wing, he/she is expected to follow elected governments with equal commitment.

Norms with respect to Political Executive-Bureaucrat relationship

  • Being impersonal and apolitical is one of the foundational values of Civil Services in India.
  • The Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules 1964 and The All-India Services (Conduct) Rules, 1968 explicitly direct to maintain political neutrality and prohibit association with any political party, political canvassing or furthering of political interests of any party by Civil Servants.

Reasons for politicization of bureaucracy:

  • Patronage based appointments: While the recruitment is done based on open competitive examination, the power of transfer and posting rests with political executive.
  • High degree of discretion: Civil servants enjoy high degree of discretion with no oversight. This leads to lack of answerability makes civil servants susceptible to poetical pressure.

Outcome of politicization of bureaucracy:

Individual level:

  • Undermines the principle of neutrality and impartiality: The foundational principles of political neutrality and impartiality is violated.
  • Harassment: Leads to individual arm twisting and harassment of honest officers.
  • Integrity: It compromises the integrity of honest civil servants.
  • Erosion of independence in decision-making.
  • Attitude: It blocks the passage for attitudinal change which leads to nepotism and non-responsive conduct in civil servants.
  • Insecurity and low morale: When civil servants are appointed based on political considerations, it leads to reduced morale and motivation.
  • Fuels political ambitions: Lure of post-retirement benefits also compromises the values of honesty and integrity.

Organizational level:

  • Against Conduct rules: Central Civil Services Conduct rules 1964 explicitly prohibits Civil Servants from taking part in political activity.
  • Undermining Rule of Law: Politicization can undermine the rule of law as the bureaucracy is used to bypass legal procedures to implement decisions that are not in accordance with the law.
  • Creation of lobbies: Leads to creation of various lobby groups an interest groups amongst the civil servants which eye for offices of profit, rewards, and post-retirement benefits.
  • Weakened Public Institutions: A politicized bureaucracy weaken public institutions and undermine their credibility, erosion of trust in public institutions creates long-term negative impact for governance.
  • Impacts principle of separation of power: Taking partisan roles impacts the principle of separation of executive from partisan politics.
  • Inefficiency and lack of accountability: When civil servants start taking political sides, it is observed that they do not hold themselves accountable to organization’s hierarchy.
  • Rules centricity is compromised: They adhere to the political orders rather than duty and rule bound decision making.
  • Independence: Civil servants are supposed to function irrespective of political considerations, politicization leads to biased decision making.

Societal level:

  • Leads to a sense of apathy in civil servants.
  • Perpetuates social inequality: Politicized civil service leads to influenced decisions which serve a specific social group instead of serving the overall society.
  • Leads to corruption: Politicization of bureaucracy leads to a culture of collusive corruption, ultimately compromising with the quality of governance.
  • Lack of transparency in decision making: Leads to decisions based on political consideration and not on objective standards.
  • Loss of public trust on civil services: Politicized bureaucracy starts serving the interests of political masters instead of public leading to loss of public trust.

Suggestions and way forward

  • Civil Services board: Constituting civil services board at Center and States to regulate transfer and postings of senior civil servants as per TSR Subramaniyan case.
  • Fixed tenure: Fixing tenure at senior position to at least 2 years to insulate civil services from political interference.
  • Cool off period: No civil servant should be allowed to join any political party and hold a political office, including a ministerial position or Governorship within at least four years from the date of his retirement on superannuation. However, those civil servants who still have five or more years to superannuate may be permitted to join any political party after a cooling-off period of two years.
  • No Pension: Civil service members who are willing to waive their pension are not required to observe the above cooling-off period.
  • Independent Constitutional body for selection of senior civil servants: Selection of civil servants for various regulatory bodies and other statutory/constitutional positions should be done through an independent constitutional body whose members cannot be removed by the political executive and such members must be selected and appointed to such positions when they still have at least three years to superannuate.
  • No Extension of service: No Civil Servant shall be given any extension of service under any circumstances.
  • Appointment as Governors: The practice of appointing Civil Servants as Governors/Lt Governors should either be discouraged or only civil servants with exceptional integrity and no involvement in active politics be appointed as Governors/Lt. Governors.

Investigations in India

Context: Supreme Court in case of Rajesh and Another v. State of Madhya Pradesh acquitted three persons who were alleged to have been involved in the murder and related offence on the ground of illegalities in investigation.

Argument by Court for Their Acquittal 

The Court argued that a person could not be said to be in police custody till he was formally arrested, as he did not figure as an accused person in the First Information Report (FIR) and was not accused of any offence till his arrest.

The Court emphasising on seeking compliance under Section 100(4) and Section 100(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) called out many irregularities in the investigation.

Police Custody 

When a person is arrested by police for charges of committing a heinous crime or on suspicion, he is detained in police custody. 

Judicial Custody 

When a person is kept in custody by a magistrate, it is called judicial custody. Unlike police custody, here a person is kept in jail on the orders of the magistrate for a certain temporary period.

Challenges with Investigation in India 

  • Budgetary Constraints: Dismal budget allocation by the state government affects many areas such as lack of skills, insufficient training, appropriate or insufficiency of equipment, and logistic support affecting their operational capacity. 
  • Dual responsibility of Maintaining order and investigation are two different responsibilities of the police officers, which in turn lead to suboptimal investigation.
  • Excessive workload due to inadequacy of manpower and long working hours even on holidays and the absence of a shift system.
  • Forensic Science: Lack of technology and research in forensic results in the faulty fingerprint, footprints etc. at the scene of crime compromising the investigation. 
  • Lack of Public Cooperation: Many times, eyewitnesses are reluctant to give statements to the police officers decreasing efficiency of investigation.
  • Political Interference: Investigations, particularly in cases where high-profile people are involved, get compromised due to direct or indirect political interference.
  • Transfer of police officers by the government during an investigation delays the investigation as new officers need to understand the case from the scratch.
  • During investigation, the media while disseminating news sometimes help the culprit in compromising evidence and can also help the criminals in executing plans e.g., 26/11 Mumbai attack.
  • Witnesses may be influenced, coerced, unduly remunerated by the culprit or others and may turn hostile halting the investigation.
  • Lack of coordination with other sub-system of the Criminal Justice System in crime prevention, control, and search for truth.
  • Uneven compliance with the recommendation of committees or court directives e.g., 17 states have taken steps to separate law and order and investigation wings.

Malimath Committees Recommendation

  • Establish an independent complaints authority to investigate complaints against police officers so that the process is fair and unbiased.
  • Set up a National Police Commission to oversee the functioning of the police and to ensure that they are working effectively and efficiently.
  • Improve the forensic capabilities and training of the police to help them collect and analyse evidence.
  • Introduce a witness protection program to ensure their safety, and their identities should be kept confidential to prevent retaliation.
  • Increase the use of technology in the justice system and allow the prosecution to rely on electronic evidence to prove its case.
  • Recommended that the investigation wing should be separate from that of the law-and-order wing.

Law Commission’s Recommendation Under Report 239 

  • Networking of all police stations to establish a link with all the courts.
  • Digital videography to be installed at police stations. At the time of receiving an FIR/complaint, videography should be made compulsory.
  • Each Police Station should be provided with secure interrogation rooms, with simultaneous audio-visual recording facilities.
  • At least, all District Headquarters should be provided with mobile forensic vans which should accompany the homicide teams to the place of occurrence.

Exclusion of Meitei Community from the Schedule Tribes List 

Context: A proposal on the inclusion of the Meitei community in the Scheduled Tribes list has been examined and rejected twice over the last four decades as accessed by The Hindu under the Right to Information Act, 2005.

The Process of Inclusion or Exclusion From the Scheduled Tribes or Schedule Castes list

StepsProcessAbout
1Initiation at the State or Union Territory Level It begins with a State or Union Territory government or administration expressing the desire to include or exclude a particular community from the SC or ST list. 
2State Government Recommendation State governments can recommend specific communities for addition or subtraction from the SC or ST lists based on their discretion.  These recommendations may be informed by studies or research, as seen in the case of the Hatti community in Himachal Pradesh. 
3Proposal Submission to Union Ministry The State government sends its proposal to the Union Ministry of Tribal Affairs, which proceeds with its own internal deliberations. 
4Examination by the Ministry of Tribal Affairs The Ministry of Tribal Affairs examines the proposal and, upon approval, forwards it to the Registrar General of India (RGI). 
5RGI Approval Once the RGI approves the proposal, it is then submitted to the National Commission for Scheduled Castes or National Commission for Scheduled Tribes for further consideration. 
6Union Government Approval Following the review by the respective National Commissions, the proposal is returned to the Union government. It undergoes inter-ministerial deliberations and is sent to  the Cabinet for final approval.
7Legislative Amendment The inclusion or exclusion of any community in the SC or ST lists only takes effect when a Bill amending the Constitution (SC) Order of 1950 and the Constitution (ST) Order of 1950 is passed by the Parliament.
These orders initially provided the complete list of SCs and STs after India's independence through a presidential order, and any alterations to this list must be passed by Parliament by law.
8Presidential Notification The final decision lies with the President's office, which issues a notification detailing the changes.  The President exercises these powers under Articles 341 and 342 of the Indian Constitution.
image 80

Meitei Community of Manipur

  • The Meitei community of Manipur is the dominant community in the state and is mostly located in the city of Imphal. 
  • The community consists of Hindus, and forms more than 50% of the entire population of Manipur, according to the 2011 census data of India.
    • 8% of the Meiteis are Muslims called Meitei Pangals.
  • The Meities are mostly settled in the plains of Manipur but certain sections can also be found in the hills. 
  • The Meitei community is fighting for the right to be included in the ST list in Manipur, which has caused a rift between them and the Naga and Kuki communities.

Naga and Kuki Scheduled Tribal Community of Manipur 

  • The Naga and Kuki tribes make up about 40 percent of the population of Manipur, and fall into the ‘Scheduled Tribes’ category.
  • They enjoy certain benefits such as land-owning rights in the hills and forests, and the make-up of the majority of the people living in the hills.

Constitutional Provisions with Respect to Schedule Castes and Scheduled Tribes341.

Scheduled Castes.—(1) The President may with respect to any State or Union territory, and where it is a State, after consultation with the Governor thereof, by public notification, specify the castes, races or tribes or parts of or groups within castes, races or tribes which shall for the purposes of this Constitution be deemed to be Scheduled Castes in relation to that State or Union territory, as the case may be.

(2) Parliament may by law include in or exclude from the list of Scheduled Castes specified in a notification issued under clause (1) any caste, race or tribe or part of or group within any caste, race or tribe, but save as aforesaid a notification issued under the said clause shall not be varied by any subsequent notification.  

342. Scheduled Tribes.— (1) The President may with respect to any State or Union territory, and where it is a State, after consultation with the Governor thereof, by public notification, specify the tribes or tribal communities or parts of or groups within tribes or tribal communities which shall for the purposes of this Constitution be deemed to be Scheduled Tribes in relation to that State or Union territory, as the case may be.

(2) Parliament may by law include in or exclude from the list of Scheduled Tribes specified in a notification issued under clause (1) any tribe or tribal community or part of or group within any tribe or tribal community, but save as aforesaid a notification issued under the said clause shall not be varied by any subsequent notification.  

Ethics committee of Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha

Context: Recently, Mahua Moitra’s (MP, Lok Sabha) matter has been referred to Lok Sabha Ethics committee. She has been accused of accepting money to ask questions in the house.

Background: 

  • Rajya Sabha: Origin of ethics committee in Rajya Sabha can be traced to NN Vohra Committee in 1996, based on suggestions of Vohra Committee, the General-Purpose Committee in 1997 proposed for a Committee regarding the conduct of members of Rajya Sabha. Accordingly, a 9 member Ethics committee of Rajya Sabha was constituted by Chairman in 1997.
  • Lok Sabha: Origin of ethics committee in Lok Sabha can be traced to a resolution adopted at Presiding Officers conference in 1996. However, the first Ethics committee in Lok Sabha was constituted by the then Speaker Shri G.M.C. Balayogi in 2000.

Purpose behind setting up of Ethics committees

  • To oversee the moral and ethical conduct of the Members; and
  • To examine the cases referred to it with reference to ethical and other misconduct of the Members.

Comparison between Ethics committee of Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha

CriteriaEthics committee of Rajya SabhaEthics committee of Lok Sabha
Composition and tenureCommittee consists of ten members.Committee holds office until a new committee is appointed, the casual vacancies arising are filled by Chairman from time to time.Committee consists of not more than 15 members which are nominated by speaker.Committee holds office for a term not exceeding one year.
Functions(a) To oversee the moral and ethical conduct of members.
(b) To prepare a Code of Conduct for members and to suggest amendments or additions to the Code from time to time in the form of reports to the Council.
(c) To examine cases concerning the alleged breach of the Code of Conduct by members as also cases concerning allegations of any other ethical misconduct of members.
(d) To tender advice to members from time to time on questions involving ethical standards either Suo Moto or on receiving specific requests.
(a) To examine every complaint relating to unethical conduct of a member of Lok Sabha referred to it by the Speaker and make such recommendations as it may deem fit.
(b) To formulate a Code of Conduct for members and suggest amendments or additions to the Code of Conduct from time to time.
PowersCode of conduct to regulate the conduct of members has been brought out for members of Rajya Sabha. Ethics Committee examines the moral and ethical conduct of members of Rajya Sabha based on this code.Rajya Sabha maintains a register of interests of its members which allows the Ethics Committee of Rajya Sabha to check for possible conflict of interest of members of Rajya Sabha.Code of conduct for members of Lok Sabha is not present.
No such record is maintained by Lok Sabha, member has to state their own interests to Chairman.
Since, the Code of Conduct and Register of interests is not present. The Ethics Committee of Lok Sabha is relatively less effective in maintaining the moral and ethical conduct of the members of Lok Sabha.

Concerns about the govt.’s fact check unit

Context: Bombay High court has recently reserved its judgement on petitions challenging constitutionality of the Fact Check Unit established under the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Amendment Rules, 2023 (IT Rules) in Kunal Kamra v. Union of India.

Background:

  • In 2023, MEiTY promulgated the 2023 rules amending IT rules 2021, allowing the government to constitute a Fact Checking Unit (FCU) under IT (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code), Amendment 2023.
  • New rules require Social Media intermediaries to censor or modify the content relating to “business of Central government” if the FCU directs them to do so.
  • FCU will have power to decide whether the content on social media is fake, false, or misleading.
  • Once content is identified as fake or misleading, intermediaries must take action or lose “safe harbor” protection under I.T. Act, 2000.

Concerns against Fact Check Unit

  • Change is not in spirit with Section 79A of IT Act, 2000 which mandates providing details with reasons for such takedown orders given to IT intermediaries.
  • As there is no right to appeal or judicial oversight over orders given by the Fact Check Unit, such powers can be misused to prevent questioning or scrutiny by media organizations.
  • May create a “chilling effect” on the right to speech and expression on digital platforms which is against the spirit of Article 19(1)(a) as it gives unfettered powers to FCU.
  • Violative of Right to Equality under Article 14 as it discriminates between false news about the government and other false news.
  • Violates separation of powers as these orders have a judicial overtone but exercised by an executive unit i.e., the Fact Check Unit.
  • There is a moral argument, government cannot be the sole arbiter of what constitutes fake news.
  • Broad scope open to misuse as the FCU can verify the veracity and take down any post on IT intermediaries which relates to “any business of central government”, which is very broad and not defined.
  • No clear parameters or guidelines have been given on the grounds on which FCU flags an information as Fake or ambiguous.
  • Concerns as to what part of information would be fake, whether the source is fake, or the information itself is fake.
  • Rules do not offer protection to fair criticism of government.
  • PIB is already doing fact checking efficiently, so why need a new mechanism.
  • Ambiguity with respect to the well settled test of reasonableness under Article 19(2) with respect to the boundary separating fake news.

Other ethical issues

  • Misleading for one may not be for the other, such terms are subjective, and open to various interpretations.
  • In editorial content such as Economy, there can be variation in data as per government and other researchers, such data cannot be called as fake data.
  • There are no provisions in Rules that provide an opportunity to justify or defend the flagged content, violating principles of natural justice.

Rationale of Government for establishing FCU

  • FCU’s notices are merely advisory in nature.
  • FCU will only notify intermediaries that the content is fake, or misleading. Intermediaries can choose to take it down or leave with disclaimer.
  • In case the user is aggrieved by the intermediary’s decision, they can avail remedy before the court of law.

Conclusion & way forward

Law has to be tested not only on its intentions, but also if its consequences are constitutional.

In Bennett Coleman & Co. vs Union of India, S.C. has held that freedom of speech and of press is the Arc of the Covenant of democracy because public criticism is essential to the working of its institutions, which must be respected.·   Moving ahead with FCU, the government must ensure that the constitution of FCU restricts to the test of reasonableness under Article 19(2) and guidelines given in Shreya Singhal vs Union of India (2015).

Regulation of Assisted Reproductive Technology and Surrogacy in India

Context: Delhi High Court seeks an explanation from the Centre about the discrimination that emerges from the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 and the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 which ban all forms of commercial surrogacy in India. 

ASSISTED REPRODUCTIVE TECHNOLOGY (REGULATION) ACT, 2021

Need for Amendment

  • India has become one of the major centres of global fertility industry over the years due to revolutions in Assisted reproductive technologies. The reproductive segment of the Indian medical tourism market is valued at more than $450 million a year. 
  • Though Assisted Reproductive Technologies have given hope to many persons suffering from infertility, but it also has introduced a plethora of legal, ethical and social issues. Despite this, there are only guidelines, and no law exists to regulate ART in India.
  • Select Committee on the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2019, has recommended that ART Bill should be brought before the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill,2019, so that all the highly technical and medical aspects could be addressed adequately in the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2019. 

About Assisted Reproductive Technology Services 

These technologies refer to all techniques that attempt to obtain a pregnancy by handling the sperm or the oocyte outside the human body and transferring the gamete or the embryo into the reproductive tract of a woman.

Following services are included in ART services

  1. Ovarian stimulation.
  2. Egg Retrieval
  3. Invitro Fertilisation (IVF)
  4. Intra-Uterine Insemination (IUI)
  5. Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)
  6. Embryo transfer
  7. Gamete Intrafallopian transfer (GIFT)
  8. Zygote Intrafallopian transfer (ZIFT)
  9. Microsurgical epididymal sperm aspiration (MESA)
  10. Testicular sperm extraction (TESE)
  11. Percutaneous epididymal sperm aspiration (PESA)
  12. Cryopreservation of gametes and embryo 

ART Procedures Could be Exploited in the following ways: 

  1. Negligence in performing surgical procedure of harvesting eggs from a woman’s body.
  2. Egg retrieval is done from young unmarried girls in many regions.
  3. Unethical preservation of ovum and sperm in ART banks.
  4. Sex selection in procedures of ART clinics
  5. Multiple embryo implantation
  6. ART banks advertising for Caucasian donor gamete.
  7. Mixing of sperms samples by banks
  8. Commercialisation of ovum and sperm donation.

Salient Features of the ART(Regulation) Act, 2021

  • Definition: The act defines ART to include all techniques that seek to obtain a pregnancy by handling the sperm or the oocyte (immature egg cell) outside the human body and transferring the gamete or the embryo into the reproductive system of a woman. Ex:  gamete (sperm or oocyte) donation, in-vitro-fertilisation and gestational surrogacy.
  • Regulation of ART clinics and banks: Every ART clinic and bank must be registered under the National Registry of Banks and Clinics of India. The registration will be valid for 5 years and can be renewed for a further five years and it can be cancelled if the entity contravenes the provisions of the act. 

Conditions for offering ART services: 

  • Age requirement for gamete donor- for male (21 to 55 years) and for female (23-35 years)
  • A woman can donate egg only once in her lifetime and should be a married having at least one alive child of her own.

Conditions for seeking ART services:

  • Only infertile married couple or single women (Indian or foreign) can seek ART services.
  • The party seeking ART services will be required to provide insurance coverage in the favour of the egg donor.
  • Mandatory checking for genetic diseases before the embryo implantation.

Offences: 

  • Selling or purchasing of gametes 
  • Abandoning children born through ART 

Concerns with the Act

  • The act excludes same-sex couples, live-in couples and individuals belonging from the LGBTQ+ community from accessing ARTs.
  • Eligibility criteria of egg donors is very restrictive.
  • The act requires ART clinics and banks to share information about the commissioning parties and donors with the National Registry. Sharing of this information may violate the right to privacy of parties.
  • The acts, ART act and surrogacy, contain different provisions on regulation of clinics based on whether they provide surrogacy or other ART procedures. This leads to overlap in the regulation of surrogacy services and other ART services. 

THE SURROGACY (REGULATION) ACT, 2021

Salient Features 

  • Definition: The act defines surrogacy as a practice where a woman gives birth to a child for an intending couple with the intention to hand over the child after the birth to the intending couple. 
  • Regulation of surrogacy: The act allows only altruistic surrogacy, which involves no monetary compensation to the surrogate mother other than the medical expenses and insurance coverage during the pregnancy. 
  • Eligibility criteria for intending couple: Surrogacy is permitted only for those intending married Indian couples who suffer from proven infertility. 

Eligibility criteria for surrogate mother: 

  • Surrogate mother must be a close relative of the intending couple.
  • Surrogate mother needs an eligibility certificate issued by the appropriate authority as mentioned in the act.   
  • A married woman having a child of her own and between the age of 25 to 35 years on the day of implantation.  
  • A woman cannot act as a surrogate mother by providing her own gametes. 
  • A woman cannot act as a surrogate mother more than once in her lifetime.  

Parentage and abortion of surrogate child: 

  • A child born out of a surrogacy procedure will be deemed to be the biological child of the intending couple.
  • An abortion of the surrogate child requires the written consent of the surrogate mother and the authorisation of the appropriate authority.
  • Regulation of surrogacy clinics: Surrogacy clinics are mandated to get registered by the appropriate authority. The central and the state governments shall constitute the National Surrogacy Board (NSB) and the State Surrogacy Boards (SSB), respectively to advice govt on policy matters relating to surrogacy and laying down code of conduct for surrogacy clinics. 

Concerns

  • Deny this opportunity to LGBTQ+ persons, live-in couples and single parents.
  • Altruistic surrogacy is paternalistic and doesn’t respect the bodily autonomy of women. It expects a woman to go through the physical and emotional tolls of surrogacy free of cost and only out of ‘compassion’.
  • Blanket ban on commercial surrogacy may lead to creation of unregulated, exploitative underground/black markets.
  • The act didn’t define ‘close relative’, which is a condition to be fulfilled by the surrogate mother.
  • Restricting surrogacy option to intending couple denies reproductive liberty to them.
  • Intending couple don’t have final say in the consent to abort a surrogate child, even if the child being born out of surrogacy arrangement is at the risk of physical or mental abnormalities.
  • The eligibility criteria for surrogate mother are irrational, unlawful, discriminatory, and violative of her fundamental rights under Articles 14 (right to equality) and 21 (right to life) of the Constitution.
  • A widowed women with age above a certain level is medically not advisable to use her own gametes denying her the chance to have a child.

Way Forward

The petitioners before the Delhi High Court have drawn attention to certain limitations of the existing acts. These limitations warrant a thorough examination. It is essential that, in the process of addressing the exploitation of surrogate mothers, the act should be revised to establish a comprehensive and inclusive procedure. This revised procedure should aim to make surrogacy readily accessible to the deserving citizens of India.

Cannot legalise same-sex marriage: SC

Context: A five-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) refused to grant legal status to same-sex marriages. 

Four key issues: 

The judgement revolved around the four key questions: 

  1. Whether there is a fundamental right to marriage in India?
  2. Whether the words in the Special Marriage Act 1954 could be given a gender-neutral meaning?
  3. The question over queer couples’ right to adopt a child. 
  4. Whether a civil union be realised under Indian law?

Evolution of Rights for Homo-sexuals:

Some key milestones:

  • 2014: National Legal Services Authority vs. Union of India: A significant development occurred with the Supreme Court of India recognizing transgender people as a third gender. This landmark judgment acknowledged their rights and provided legal recognition and protection to the transgender community.
  • 2017: Justice K. S. Puttaswamy vs. Union Of India: Another important step was taken in 2017 when the Supreme Court of India ruled that privacy is a fundamental right. This decision had far-reaching implications for the LGBTQ+ community as it paved the way for greater recognition and protection of their rights to privacy and personal autonomy.
  • 2018: Navtej Singh Johar vs. Union of India: In a historic verdict, the Supreme Court of India struck down the colonial-era law known as Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code. This law criminalized consensual same-sex relationships, and its decriminalization was a crucial step towards ensuring equality and dignity for homosexual individuals. The judgment emphasized that sexual orientation is an inherent aspect of an individual's identity and discrimination based on it is a violation of fundamental rights.
  • 2022: Supreme Court noted that all types of atypical family units (single parents, transgenders, same-sex couples) are also entitled to legal recognition and protection under various social welfare legislation like typical heterosexual family units.

Key issues

1. Right to Marry:

  • Petition: The petitioners had argued that there exists a fundamental right to marry a person of one’s own choice under the Constitution and that the court must address the denial of that right. If the court recognised this as a fundamental right (like it did in the case of privacy in the 2017 Aadhaar ruling), then it would cast an obligation on the state to protect this right.
  • The majority view upheld that the right to marriage is not a fundamental right. SC has underlined that the issue of same-sex marriage can only be resolved through the legislative route. However, the right to enter into a union/relationship is unrelated to sexual orientation and is a feature of fundamental rights in Articles 19 and 21.
    • Present status: Govt. has already acknowledged the right to love, the right to cohabit, the right to choose one’s partner, right to one’s sexual orientation as fundamental rights under Artice 21.

2. Interpretation of Special Marriage Act 1954:

  • Petition: The SMA was enacted in 1954 to enable marriage between inter-faith or inter-caste couples without them giving up their religious identity or resorting to conversion. The petitioners had asked the SC to recognise same-sex marriage by allowing a gender-neutral interpretation of the legislation that governs a civil marriage, in which the state rather than religion, sanctions the marriage. The petitioners had asked the SC to interpret the word marriage as between “spouses” instead of “man and woman”. Alternatively, the petitioners had asked for striking down provisions of the SMA that are gender-restrictive.
  • The majority ruling stated that the court could not interpret the SMA to include same-sex couples since the objective of the legislation is not to include same-sex couples within the realm of marriage. The provisions and the objects of the SMA clearly point to the circumstance that Parliament intended only one kind of couples, i.e., heterosexual couples belonging to different faiths, to be given the facility of a civil marriage.
image 53

3. Queer couples’ right to adopt a child:

  • Petition: The petitioners had argued that the guidelines of the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA), which does not allow unmarried couples to jointly adopt children, are discriminatory against queer couples who cannot legally marry.
    • The guidelines allow only a couple who have been in at least two years of a stable marital relationship to be eligible to adopt.
    • Individually, queer persons can adopt as single people. However, a single male is not eligible to adopt a girl child — even though a single female is eligible to adopt a child of any gender.
  • The majority view largely agreed with the discriminatory aspects of preventing queer couples from adopting children, and that couples tied together in marriage are not a ‘morally superior choice’, or per se make better parents. But the majority view said that this change cannot be “achieved by the judicial pen”, rather the remedy is to be provided by legislature. 
    • The fact that Parliament has made the legislative choice of including only ‘married’ couples for joint adoption (i.e., where two parents are legally responsible), arises from the reality of all other laws wherein protections and entitlements flow from the institution of marriage. 

4. Civil unions for queer couples:

  • Petition: Before full marriage rights were recognised for same-sex couples by the US Supreme Court, several states had allowed civil unions. However, the petitioners argued that civil unions are not an equal alternative to the legal and social institution of marriage, and relegating non-heterosexual relationships to civil unions would send the queer community a message that their relationships were inferior to those of heterosexual couples.
  • The majority view disagreed that the court can prescribe a choice of civil unions to queer people. It is difficult to create the right to civil union through a judicial diktat. 

Positives of the judgement:

The Supreme Court of India has issued directives to both the Union government and state governments to prevent discrimination against the queer community based on their sexual orientation. Here are the key directives:

  1. Non-Discrimination: The government must ensure that there is no discrimination against the queer community in terms of access to goods and services.
  2. Public Awareness: Efforts should be made to sensitize the public about the rights of the queer community. (including that it is natural and not a mental disorder)
  3. Helpline for Queer Community: A dedicated helpline should be established to provide support and assistance to the queer community which they can contact when they face harassment and violence in any form.
  4. Safe Houses: Safe houses (Garima grehs) should be created in each district to offer protection/shelter to queer couples who may face threats or harassment.
  5. Forced operations of Inter-Sex Children: Treatments offered by doctors or other persons, which aim to change gender identity or sexual orientation, cease with immediate effect. Inter-sex children are not forced to undergo operations with regard only to their sex, especially at an age at which they are unable to fully comprehend and consent to such operations.
  6. Formation of Committee: The SC recorded the statement of the Solicitor General that the Union government will constitute a committee to decide the rights and entitlements of persons in queer unions. The issues before the committee will be mentioning queer couples as family in ration cards, allowing queer couples to nominate for joint bank account, allowing them all the rights that from from pension, gratuity, etc.

The Supreme Court has also issued specific directions to the police:

  1. No Harassment: Police should not harass queer couples by summoning them to police stations or visiting their residences solely to inquire about their gender identity or sexual orientation.
  2. Freedom of Choice: Queer individuals should not be forced to return to their families if they do not wish to do so.
  3. Protection of Freedom: When queer individuals file complaints alleging that their family is inhibiting their freedom of movement, the police should verify the genuineness of the complaint and ensure their freedom is not curtailed.
  4. Protection against Violence: If a complaint is filed apprehending violence from the family due to the complainant's queer identity or relationship, the police should verify the genuineness of the complaint and provide appropriate protection.
  5. Preliminary Enquiry: Before registering an FIR against a queer couple or an individual in a queer relationship, the police should conduct a preliminary enquiry to determine if the complaint discloses a cognizable offence, following the guidelines set in the Lalita Kumari vs Government of UP case.

India needs a separate anti-discrimination law which inter alia prohibits discrimination based on sexual orientation. Presently, several laws have an anti-discrimination aspect to them but they are fragmented and may fail to capture the multitudinous forms of discrimination.  

Hurt by remarks of new Public Service Commission member, says Gehlot

Context: Recently Rajasthan government appointed 3 members in State Public Service Commission.

Constitutional provisions:

  • Article 315 of Constitution provides that there shall be a Public Service Commission for the Union and a Public Service Commission for each of the state.

Appointment:

  • Article 316 deals with appointment of members, which shall be appointed by the Governor o State in case of State Public Service Commission.
  • Strength: Constitution does not specify the strength of commission.
  • No qualifications are prescribed for the members, except one half of the members should have held office under Union or State Government for at least 10 years.
  • Conditions of service are determined by the Governor of State.
  • Tenure: Chairman and Members hold office for 6 years or up to 62 years of age.
  • They can relinquish the office by addressing resignation to the Governor of State.

Removal:

  • Article 317 deals with the removal and suspension of a member of Public Service Commission.
  • Only by President: Although appointed by Governor, they can be removed only by President.
  • Grounds of removal are, being adjudged insolvent or
  • Engaging in paid employment outside the duties of his office, or
  • Unfit to continue office by the reason of infirmity of mind or body, or
  • Misbehavior, however in this case, President has to refer the matter to supreme court for enquiry. 
  • Constitution has defined misbehavior in this context, it involves-

(a) Being concerned or interested in any contract or agreement made by the Government of India or state.

(b) Participates in any way in the profit of such contract or agreement.

Maratha quota case, curative petition will come up in due course, says CJI Chandrachud

Context: Recently, CJI in response to an oral mentioning said that curative petition against the SC judgement holding Maratha reservation law unconstitutional will be listed in due course.

Background: In 2021, Supreme Court declared the Maharashtra government law providing for reservation benefits to Marathas as unconstitutional on the ground of breach of 50% ceiling limit.

About Curative petition:

  • Curative petition is a petition filed for reconsideration of final judgement or order passed by the supreme court, after exhausting the remedy of review under Article 137 of the Indian Constitution.
  • In Rupa Ashok Hurra case, the supreme court came up with the idea of curative petition to prevent abuse of its process and to cure gross miscarriage of justice.

Reasoning given by Supreme court to introduce curative petition:

  • To take into consideration rarest of rare cases.
  • To prevent miscarriage of justice.
  • To prevent fraud or suppression of material facts. (Union of India v Union Carbide)
  • To rectify any error which has been brought to the notice.
  • To meet circumstances where declining to reconsider the judgement would be oppressive to judicial conscience.
  • If the judgement causes perpetuation of irremediable injustice.

Constitutional provisions in favor of curative petition:

  • Inherent powers of Supreme Court along with the powers flowing out of Article 142 to do complete justice.

Provisions related to the powers of Supreme Court:

Article 32: Remedies for enforcement of rights conferred by this Part. — (1) The right to move the Supreme Court by appropriate proceedings for the enforcement of the rights conferred by this Part is guaranteed.

Article 129: Supreme Court to be a court of record. —  The Supreme Court shall be a court of record and shall have all the powers of such a court including the power to punish for contempt of itself.

Article 136: Special leave to appeal by the Supreme Court. — (1) Notwithstanding anything in this Chapter, the Supreme Court may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any court or tribunal in the territory of India.

Article 137: Review of judgments or orders by the Supreme Court. — Subject to the provisions of any law made by Parliament or any rules made under article 145, the Supreme Court shall have power to review any judgment pronounced or order made by it.

Article 142: Enforcement of decrees and orders of Supreme Court and orders as to discovery, etc.—

(1) The Supreme Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction may pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it, and any decree so passed or order so made shall be enforceable throughout the territory of India in such manner as may be prescribed by or under any law made by Parliament and, until provision in that behalf is so made, in such manner as the Presidentmay by order1 prescribe.

(2) Subject to the provisions of any law made in this behalf by Parliament, the Supreme Court shall, as respects the whole of the territory of India, have all and every power to make any order for the purpose of securingthe attendance of any person, the discovery or production of any documents, or the investigation or punishment of any contempt of itself.

Grounds of filing curative petition: 

  • Filing of petition has to be treated as a rarity rather than regular mechanism.
  • It can be filed if, the order is in contravention of principle of natural justice, or
  • The order being without jurisdiction or
  • Non-disclosure by judge of any conflict of interest, giving scope for apprehension of bias.
  • Judgement has adversely affected the petitioner.

Mechanism followed: 

  • Certification by a Senior advocate with respect to fulfilment of above-mentioned requirements.
  • Curative petition first has to be circulated to a bench of 3 senior most judges of supreme court and judges who passed the judgement.
  • If the majority of bench concludes that the matter needs hearing, it is listed before the same bench.
  • Bench may ask a senior counsel to assist them as amicus curiae.
  • If the bench at any stage holds that petition is without any merit and vexatious, it may impose exemplary cost on petitioner.

Issues, challenges and prospects in MGNREGA

Context:· While West Bengal is currently in the spotlight due to alleged irregularities in the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Scheme (MGNREGS) implementation, resulting in funds being stopped by the Centre, the National Level Monitoring (NLM) reports available with the Union Ministry of Rural Development show irregularities in implementing the rural job guarantee scheme across several states.

Now the question arises, why do we cover this?

Because UPSC syllabus of GSII has these lines:

  • Government policies and interventions for development in various sectors and issues arising out of their design and implementation

Since MGNREGA is also one of the important schemes of the government, we need to cover it.

So the way we will approach this discussion is:

  • Past employment schemes in our country
  • Issues with these past wage employment programs:
  • Benefits
  • Issues with MGNREGA
  • Steps taken by the government in trying to resolve the issue:

We are going to cut the details about the feature of the scheme in this discussion because that has already been covered multiple times in our DNS

The extent of India’s poverty can never be overstated

  • The Global Multidimensional Poverty Index-2023: India still has more than 230 million people who are poor.
  • As per Tendulkar Committee this estimation is around 21.9% of the total population of the country.

And a major contributor towards this is lack of Employment opportunities in our country.  For which the governments have run various schemes from time to time, like:

Past employment schemes in our country

  • Integrated Rural Development Programme (IRDP):
  • Jawahar Rozgar Yojana/Jawahar Gram Samriddhi Yojana:
  • Sampoorna Gramin Rozgar Yojana (SGRY)

But these schemes were not very successful as they faced following Issues

Funds                                 

  • Funds were not fully utilized
  • Untimely release
  • Inability of the states to raise the matching contributions

Lack of planning

  • Very low coverage area (less than 5% villages across country)
  • Allocation was disproportionately tilted towards capital acquisition
  • Serious flaws in project selection which had adverse impact on usability of the asset.

Lack of people’s participation

  • No involvement of people in planning and implementation
  • Limited role of Panchayats
    • Only minimally involved in implementation but totally out of planning stage 

Lack of inclusive ness

  • Participation of women was very low

Hence a need was felt for a total reform in the way we look at the employment schemes

Then came MGNREGA

It marked a paradigm shift

  • Provides assured employment for hundred days to rural household.
  • Uniqueness
    • Focus on the word “GUARANTEE”
    • This was the first time that employment was legally recognized as a right

Benefits:                          

1. Poverty and Unemployment Reduction:

a. Obviou

Direct payment

b. Not obvious

In many states, up to half of the MGNREGA income was spent on food, which improved health and nutrition — a critical factor in a country plagued by malnutrition.

  • Increase in agricultural wages and enhanced bargaining power of the rural poor.

2. Vulnerable section upliftment

a. Women Empowerment/ Gender bias in wage removed:

MGNREGA has been a critical source of income for female-headed households, providing as much as 15 percent of the household income in some states.

b. Backward classes

Since only the most needy sought work under this Act, it was an accurate self-targeting scheme, with a major proportion of the beneficiaries — much higher than their percentage in the general population — belonging to Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes and other marginalized communities.

3. Migration reduction

There has been a drastic reduction in DISTRESS migration post MGNREGA from rural areas.

4. Asset creation benefits (Benefits for Economy)

Scheme has boosted agricultural productivity through development of wasteland/fallow land, and construction of post-harvest storage facilities and work sheds.

Additionally, the studies have revealed a significant reduction in water vulnerability index, agriculture vulnerability and livelihood vulnerability.

MGNREGA has also had a multiplier effect on the rural economy, with the additional purchasing power generated from it spent on items produced in the rural economy

The studies reveal that, far from being a wasteful expenditure, the works under the MGNREGA have helped create rural assets and infrastructure, ranging from anganwadis, toilets for individual households, crematoria, cyclone shelters, and playgrounds for children, to drought-proofing, flood protection and control, water conservation and harvesting, and rural road connectivity.

Hence it was meant to not only enhance the income of the people in short term by providing employment, but it also intended to create durable assets.

Issues with MGNREGA (ARC)

Shift towards universalization and entitlements

  • Guaranteeing reach
    • Becomes difficult because of legal guarantee and seasonality of unemployment (explain agro cycle)
    • This becomes even more difficult because there is no selection criterion of beneficiaries (only BPL)
  • Hence successful implementation requires understanding of
    • region specific labour demand
    • seasonal variation in labour demand
    • This has been lacking
  • Guaranteeing outcome
    • Two outcomes are expected from MGNREGA
      • Sustainable livelihood for poor
      • Creation of durable assets
  • Ensuring Convergence
    • Multiple flagships run parallelly which have almost the similar target group and aim
      • For Example: PMAY asset + Employment
    • This creates duplicity of efforts
    • There is a need for a holistic integrated development plan at the local level.

Funding by the union and execution by the state government

  • Fund flow
    • The implementation of MGNREGA is mainly done on the funds transfers from the center which requires a great deal of two way communication from local level (demand flow) to centre (fund flow)
  • Conflict 
    • Since the funding agency and executing agencies are different, this leads blurring of accountability.
    • There is a need to delineate the accountability through institutional mechanism. 

Centrality of local governments

  • Panchayati Raj Institutions have been given the responsibility of
    • planning
    • implementation
    • Social auditing
  • However, given the track record and capacity levels of the PRIs across the county, there is a need for capacity building.

Administrative and Intuitional arrangements

  • Leakages
    • Have become a common feature in MGNREGA
    • There have been large scale association of contractors and fabrication of muster rolls.
  • Transparency
    • In most cases there is lack of transparency in the way
      • Beneficiaries are identified
      • Identification of work
      • Preparation of estimates
    • There is also lack of community participation in any stage which perpetuates the opacity.

Issues related to wages

Two different rates and their clash:

  • While the minimum wages are fixed by the states, NREGA wages are fixed by Central Government; this creates a conflict because these wages are below minimum wages in many states.
  • So, states demand that central government should fix the wages above their minimum wages. But since, any such increase would put financial pressure on the centre; this has become a centre-state tussle for last few years.

Wrong Anchor

  • The Centre has linked the wage rates to CPI-Agri Labour. However, it is thought that this index does not provide a comprehensive picture of inflation in rural areas.

Delay in wage payments

  • Supreme Court has slammed the government many times for not giving compensation to workers for delayed payment of wages under MGNREGA even during the current drought.

Reduces the availability of agricultural and industrial labour

  • The MGNREGA has altered the power balance between the landless poor and their employers (agricultural landlords, labour contractors), making it less loaded in favour of the latter; two, by raising rural incomes, it has decreased distress migration to the cities, thereby reducing the numbers of the reserve army of labour, and increasing the cost of labour.
    • For ex: Prevented migration of cheap agricultural labour to Punjab, Haryana and thus, inflation in agricultural produce. Shortage of construction workers in metro cities.

Quality of assets:

  • the assets created by MGNREGA works are of poor quality; that the money would be better spent on skill-development; that promoting economic growth and private investment is the only way to battle rural poverty, etc.
  • Most of the assets made are not durable and thus donot reflect properly on our GDP growth.

Social audits not being conducted.

  • CAG submitted report on MGNREGS Social Audit Rules, 2011, according to which: 
    • Only 51% of the gram panchayats were covered for social audit across the 25 states.

Steps taken by the government in trying to resolve the issue:

  • Transparency in Implementation
    • Management Information system
    • Social Audit
    • Dist. Level ombudsman
    • Transparency in execution of work (uploading three photographs)
    • Proactive disclosure

Initiatives of the Government to strengthen the implementation:

  • Professional staff at gram panchayat level
  • MGNREGA audits of scheme rules

Focus on IAP districts

  • To lay special focus on backward areas.
  • Addition of 30 new works (Watershed, Irrigation and Flood management works, Agricultural and Livestock related works, Fisheries, Rural Drinking water and Sanitation related works)
  • NREGAsoft:
    • Link the scheme with Skill India to prevent recurring of MNREGA activities in same areas.
    • Allow migration for people and MNREGA benefits can be linked all across India using Aadhar
  • Geo Tagging
    • Geo-tagging can help track the location and development status of, say, a pond or a bridge, funded by MGNREGA and located in any of India’s 6 lakh villages. 

Law Commission Report On Pocso Act

Context: Law commission has recently come up with Report #283 Titled: Age of Consent Under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offenses Act, 2012, in which it has advised against changing the present age of consent under POCSO act which is 18 years. (Section 2(1)(d) of POCSO act defines: “child” means any person below the age of eighteen years.)

Issues related to Age of Consent under POCSO Act

  • POCSO imposes a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years for statutory rape without regard to minor’s (16-18) consent (POCSO is a gender-neutral act).
  • POCSO Act, 2012 has led to the increase in age of consent from 16 to 18 years. This has increased the number of prosecutions of adolescents for indulging in consensual sexual activities among minors.

This has following concerns:

  • Leads to shame and stigma associated with criminalization of consensual sexual activity.
  • While these cases do not necessarily lead to conviction, the stringent law results into denial of bail and prolonged incarceration.
  • Most people adversely affected with this provision are youth from poor and marginalized population, with adverse consequences particularly for girls.
  • A study by UNICEF India conducted in WB, Assam and Maharashtra found that one is every four cases under the POCSO Act constituted “romantic cases” and consensual relationships.
  • Often when the children (below 18) who elope or marry, the male partner is sent to jail and the women is usually pushed towards a life of poverty and destitution (observed in Veekesh Kalawat vs State of MP)
  • State has no obligation under POCSO to provide basic minimum required for survival of the female and/or her child.

Views of Law Commission against reducing age of consent

  • Existing age of consent (18 years) should not be tinkered due to dangers of child abuse, trafficking, and prostitution.
  • Consent can be manufactured, thus a lot of genuine cases falling under POCSO might not see trial on account of agencies declaring them to be cases of consensual romantic relationships.
  • In many cases, “consent” arises after the occurrence of alleged offence, thus reducing age of consent can provide escape to child abusers.
  • Can lead to negative fallout on fight against child marriages.
  • Emerging trends of grooming and cybercrimes such as sextortion against women, increase vulnerability of children to sexual exploitation necessitate a need for stringent protection.
  • Provide a gateway to abuse of law leading to coercion of minor girls into subjugation, marital rape, and trafficking.

Way forward/Suggestion

  • Law Commission has suggested for introducing guided judicial discretion to deal with situation in case where there is tacit approval on part of child aged between 16 to 18 years.

However, scholars have emphasized placing the child at the center while formulating laws, while POCSO serves protection of young from sexual abuse, equally important is to protect young from being shamed, punished and jailed for exploring what is developmentally appropriate for their age.

  • Age-appropriate sexuality education should be given in schools.
  • Access to confidential medical counselling.
  • Prohibiting laws from criminalizing consensual sexual activity with peers.
  • Courts to address these matters with sensitivity and increased public dialogue.· “Close-in age” exception in case of consensual relationships as followed in USA and Canada can be looked into.

Schedule Areas Under Fifth Schedule of the Constitution

Context: Despite demands from many states, scheduled tribal populations of India have been left out of fifth schedule’s protection awaiting approval from the Indian government. 

Under Fifth schedule the constitution of India provides that “in this Constitution, the expression “Scheduled Areas” means such areas as the President may by order declare to be Scheduled Areas.”    

These areas are primarily inhabited by Scheduled Tribes in any State other than Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura, and Mizoram, which are indigenous or tribal communities. These areas are subject to special constitutional provisions and safeguards to promote the welfare and advancement of the Scheduled Tribes living in these regions. 

Key features of Scheduled Areas Under Fifth Schedule  

Tribal Advisory Council

  • Each state with Scheduled Areas must establish a Tribes Advisory Council, consisting of not more than twenty members of whom, as nearly as may be, three-fourths shall be the representatives of the Scheduled Tribes in the Legislative Assembly of the State. 
  • This council advises the Governor on matters related to the welfare and development of Scheduled Tribes in the state. 

Regulations

  • The Governor of the state has the authority to make regulations specific to Scheduled Areas.  
  • These regulations can include restrictions on land transfer, land allotment, and the regulation of money-lending practices, among other aspects, to protect the interests of Scheduled Tribes. 

Laws and Their Application

  • The Governor can issue notifications exempting or modifying the application of certain laws passed by Parliament or the State Legislature in Scheduled Areas.  
  • Additionally, the President has the authority to declare, modify, or rescind Scheduled Areas. 

Amendment

  • The Fifth Schedule itself can be amended by the Indian Parliament, but such amendments do not require the special amending procedure outlined in Article 368 of the Indian Constitution. 

Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996

  • PESA empowered the gram sabhas to exercise substantial authority through direct democracy and stated that structures “at the higher level do not assume the powers and authority” of the gram sabha. 

Criteria For Declaration of a Scheduled Area  

Neither the Constitution nor any law provides any criteria to identify Scheduled Areas. The Supreme court in a judgement held that the identification of Scheduled Areas is an executive function, and it lacks the expertise to scrutinise the empirical basis of the same. 

But based on the 1961 Dhebar Commission Report, the following are the guiding norms for their declaration: 

  • Preponderance of tribal population. 
  • Compactness and reasonable size of the area. 
  • A viable administrative entity such as a district, block or taluk. 
  • Economic backwardness of the area relative to neighbouring areas. 

Declaration of a Schedule Area 

The process of designating an area as a Scheduled Area in India involves a series of steps.  

Consultation with State Governments 
Before issuing the Presidential Order, the President usually consults with the concerned State Government.  This consultation is aimed at considering the views and recommendations of the state government regarding the proposed designation of the area as a Scheduled Area. 
Presidential Order  
The initiation of the process typically begins with a Presidential Order.  The President of India can, by issuing an order, declare that a specific geographical area or region is to be designated as a Scheduled Area.  This initial order specifies the boundaries and details of the Scheduled Area. 
Parliamentary Approval  
After the Presidential Order is issued, it needs to be approved by the Parliament of India.  The order is typically laid before both houses of Parliament (Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha) for discussion and approval.  This step ensures that there is legislative scrutiny and debate regarding the designation. 
Amendment  
If Parliament approves the Presidential Order, it becomes part of the Fifth Schedule of the Indian Constitution.  Any changes to the Fifth Schedule, including the addition or alteration of Scheduled Areas, require a majority vote in Parliament but do not require the special amending procedure outlined in Article 368 of the Indian Constitution. 
Notification  
Once the area is designated as a Scheduled Area under the Fifth Schedule, the government issues a notification specifying the boundaries and details of the Scheduled Area.  This notification is essential for the implementation of special provisions and regulations in that area. 

After that the administration of the Scheduled Area is regulated as per the provisions of the Fifth Schedule. The Governor of the state in which the Scheduled Area is located plays a significant role in its governance, and a Tribes Advisory Council is often established to advise on matters related to the welfare and development of Scheduled Tribes in the area. 

Facts about the Scheduled Areas  

image 25
  • India has 705 Scheduled Tribe (ST) communities, comprising 8.6% of the country's population. They are spread across 26 states and six Union Territories. 
  • Scheduled Areas cover 11.3% of India's land area and are notified in 10 states: Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Odisha, Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Himachal Pradesh. Kerala has proposed to notify more areas, pending approval. 

Challenges Faced by Scheduled Areas 

  • Land Alienation: Land disputes, inadequate implementation of land reform policies, are persistent issues in scheduled areas. Due to lack of awareness about land rights communities often struggle to assert their land rights depriving them of their traditional means of livelihood. 
  • Inadequate Implementation of Laws: Due to bureaucratic hurdles, corruption, and lack of awareness there is an ineffective implementation of laws and provisions that protect the rights and interests of tribal communities. 
  • Lack of Political Representation: Despite reserved seats in legislative bodies, tribal communities often face challenges in electing representatives who genuinely advocate for their interests leading to lack of voice in decision making. 
  • Naxalism and Conflict: Some Scheduled Areas are affected by left-wing extremism or Naxalism, which disrupts governance, development, and security. These areas face a unique set of challenges related to insurgency and counterinsurgency operations. 

Recommendation of Xaxa Committee on Schedule Areas 

The Xaxa Committee, officially known as the "High-Level Committee on Socio-economic, Health, and Educational Status of Tribal Communities of India," was constituted to examine the status of tribal communities in India, particularly in Scheduled Areas.  

Land Rights and Livelihoods 

  • Ensure the effective implementation of the Forest Rights Act and Land Acquisition Act to protect tribal land rights. 
  • Recognize and protect the rights of tribal communities over minor forest produce and traditional occupations. 
  • Promote sustainable and community-based livelihood options such as agroforestry and non-timber forest produce collection. 

Governance and Participation 

  • Strengthen the Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) in Scheduled Areas and ensure that they have adequate resources and decision-making powers. 
  • Promote tribal participation in local governance and decision-making processes. 
  • Establish effective mechanisms for the implementation of tribal welfare schemes and monitor their progress. 

Legal and Land Reforms 

  • Undertake land and tenancy reforms to protect tribal land rights and prevent land alienation. 
  • Review and repeal laws that are detrimental to tribal interests. 
  • Provide legal aid and support to tribal communities in land-related disputes. 

Women's Empowerment 

  • Promote the participation of tribal women in decision-making processes at all levels. 
  • Implement programs to address issues of gender-based violence and discrimination in tribal areas.