Ecosystems

Fourth global mass coral bleaching

Context: The US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) declared the onset of the fourth global mass coral bleaching event due to extraordinary ocean temperatures recently.

This event carries significant implications for marine ecosystems and the millions reliant on reefs for sustenance, livelihoods, and coastal defence.

Causes of Elevated Ocean Temperatures:

  • Since mid-March 2023, average sea surface temperatures (SST) have been unusually high, reaching a record monthly high of 21.07 degrees Celsius in March.
  • Rising emissions of heat-trapping greenhouse gases (GHGs), such as carbon dioxide and methane, are the primary contributors to soaring temperatures. 
  • Nearly 90% of the additional heat trapped by GHGs has been absorbed by the oceans.

Importance of Corals and Coral Reefs:

  • Corals are essentially animals, which are sessile, meaning they permanently attach themselves to the ocean floor
  • They use their tiny tentacle-like hands to catch food from the water and sweep into their mouth. 
  • Each individual coral animal is known as a polyp, and it lives in groups of hundreds to thousands of genetically identical polyps that form a ‘colony’.
  • Corals are largely classified as either hard coral or soft coral.
  • It is the hard corals that are the architects of coral reefs — complex three-dimensional structures built up over thousands of years. 
  • “Unlike soft corals, hard corals have stony skeletons made out of limestone that are produced by coral polyps. 
  • When polyps die, their skeletons are left behind and used as foundations for new polyps,” according to NOAA.
  • Coral reefs, also referred to as “rainforests of the sea”, have existed on the Earth for nearly 450 million years.
  • Australia’s Great Barrier Reef is the largest in the world, stretching across 2,028 kilometres. 

Significance of Coral Reefs:

  • Coral reefs harbour immense biodiversity, supporting over 400 coral species, 1,500 fish species, and numerous other organisms.
  • They provide economic benefits valued at about $375 billion annually and offer coastal protection from storms and floods for over 500 million people worldwide.
  • Coral reefs can absorb up to 97% of the energy from waves, storms, and floods, which prevents loss of life, property damage, and soil erosion.

Understanding Coral Bleaching:

image 57
  • Most corals contain algae called zooxanthellae — they are plant-like organisms — in their tissues. 
  • Corals and zooxanthellae have a symbiotic relationship. 
  • While corals provide zooxanthellae a safe place to live, zooxanthellae provide oxygen and organic products of photosynthesis that help corals to grow and thrive. 
  • Zooxanthellae also give bright and unique colours to corals.
  • Corals are very sensitive to light and temperature and even a small change in their living conditions can stress them. 
  • When stressed, they expel zooxanthellae and turn entirely white. This is called coral bleaching.
  • Coral bleaching doesn’t immediately lead to the death of corals. They rather go under more stress and are subject to mortality. 
  • Coral bleaching reduces the reproductivity of corals and makes them more vulnerable to fatal diseases. If the bleaching is not too severe, corals have been known to recover.

Incidences of Coral bleaching

  • Global mass bleaching of coral reefs is when significant coral bleaching is confirmed in the Atlantic, Indian and Pacific oceans, according to a report published by The Conversation. Such events are a relatively new phenomenon. 
  • The first one took place in 1998 in which 20% of the world’s reef areas suffered bleaching-level heat stress. 
  • The next two global bleaching events occurred in 2010 (35% of reefs affected) and between 2014 and 2017 (56% of reefs affected).

Current Status of Global Bleaching Event:

image 58
  • NOAA has confirmed the fourth global bleaching event, with widespread bleaching reported across 54 countries, territories, and localities from Florida, the US, Saudi Arabia to Fiji.
  • The Great Barrier Reef is experiencing its most severe bleaching event, with approximately one-third of surveyed reefs showing extreme bleaching.
  • Bleaching was also confirmed in the Western Indian Ocean, including Tanzania, Kenya, Mauritius, Seychelles, and off the western coast of Indonesia.
  • The key driver behind the current event is higher ocean temperatures. However, the situation has been exacerbated by El Niño, a weather pattern which is associated with warmer oceans.

Impact of the Event:

  • The full impact of the ongoing bleaching event is yet to be determined, but scientists anticipate severe consequences.
  • With global temperatures rising, such events are expected to become more frequent and prolonged, posing a grave threat to coral reefs worldwide.

Response and Outlook:

  • To curb global warming and mitigate the loss of coral reefs, countries must reduce greenhouse gas emissions to net zero by 2050, as outlined in the Paris Agreement.
  • However, achieving this goal remains challenging due to continued record levels of GHG emissions.
  • The fourth global mass coral bleaching event underscores the urgent need for concerted global action to mitigate climate change and preserve coral reef ecosystems, upon which millions depend for their well-being.

Importance, challenges and steps for Coastal ecosystems

Context: National Green Tribunal has asked the MoEFCC to ensure that all coastal states/UTs prepare the Coastal Zone Management Plan (CZMP) or Island Coastal Regulation Zone Plan (ICRZP) as per Coastal Regulation Zone notification, 2019.

India’s Coastline

India has a long coastline of over 7,500 km. The coastal area is a significant for India for the following reasons:

Importance of Coastal ecosystem

  1. Conventional Energy Resources: 
  • Shale deposits along coasts of Gujarat, TN and Andhra Pradesh 
  • Rich Methane Hydrate deposits along the KG Basin. (Not yet harnessed).
  1. Renewable Energy Potential:
  • Significant wind energy potential (665 GW) along with offshore wind.
  • Tropical coasts of India have vast solar energy potential.
  • Tidal energy and OTEC 
  1. Mineral Resources
  • Monazite sands and critical minerals important for India’s nuclear energy security.
  • Placer deposits rich in titanium and gold along coasts
  • Salt production and export principally in Gujarat.
  • Sand and construction material from coasts.
  1. Food Resources
  • Rich in fisheries and aquaculture – Rich source of protein and exports.
  • Seaweeds for food and fertilisers.
  1. Other important factors
  • Coastal cities and beautiful beaches are rich sources for tourism and water adventure sports.
  • Pearl fisheries and ornaments
  • Blue carbon: Coastal blue carbon focuses on rooted vegetation in coastal zone, such as tidal marshes, mangroves and seagrasses. These ecosystems have high carbon burial rates on a per unit area basis and accumulate carbon in their soils and sediments.

Challenges to Coastal Ecosystems

Natural challenges

  • Cyclones
  • Increased wave activity leading to erosion of the beaches.
  • Sea level rise: Sea level rise due to global warming is a key threat to coastal ecosystems and large populations living on the coasts. 
  • Intrusion of seawater in the groundwater making normal groundwater saline. This happens due to excess withdrawal of groundwater. 

Anthropogenic factors for coastal degradation

  • Sand mining and dredging
  • Construction of river dams upstream
  • Destruction of mangroves
  • Oil spills
  • Plastic waste disposal in coastal waters harming coastal biodiversity
  • Excessive fertilizer usage and spill-off leading to eutrophication. 
  • Overdevelopment and population pressure in coastal areas

Steps taken to protect coastal ecosystem in India. 

  1. Coastal Regulation Zone Notification, 2018: MoEFCC has notified Coastal Regulation Zone Notification, 2018 under the Environmental Protection Act, 1986 to conserve and protect the unique environment of coastal and marine areas, protect livelihoods of fishermen and other coastal communities and promote sustainable Cdevelopment on scientific principles taking into account the dangers of natural hazards, sea level rise due to global warming. 
image 16

Application of Coastal Regulation Zone: 

  • Land area from High Tide Line to 500 metres on the landward side along the sea front.
  • The intertidal zone means land area between HTL and Low Tide Line.
  • Water and bed area between Low Tide Line to the territorial water limit in case of sea and water. 

Classification of CRZs

  • CRZ-I: Areas environmentally most critical. It is further classified as:
    • CRZ-I A: They constitute ecologically sensitive areas and geomorphological features which play a role in maintaining the integrity of the coast like: Mangroves, Corals and coral reefs, Sand dunes, Biologically active mudflats, protected areas (National Parks, WLS etc.), Salt marshes, Nesting grounds of turtles and birds, Horse shoe crab habitats, sea grass beds, heritage sites.
    • CRZ-I B: Intertidal zone i.e., area between Low tide line and High Tide Line.
  • CRZ-II: Developed land areas up to or close to shoreline, within existing municipal limits or in other existing designated urban areas.
  • CRZ-III: Land areas that are relatively undisturbed (rural areas etc.) and those which do not fall under CRZ-II. It is further classified into:
    • CRZ-III A: CRZ-III area with population density more than 2161 per sq. km. as per census 2011. In these areas, area up to 50 metres from the HTL on the landward side shall be earmarked as No development Zone.
    • CRZ-III B: All other CRZ-III areas (population density less than 2161 per sq. km.). In these areas, area up to 200 metres from HTL on the landward side will be No Development Zone.
    • CRZ-IV: CRZ constitutes the water area. It is further classified into:
      • CRZ-IV A: Water area and sea bed area between LTL up to 12 nautical miles on the seaward side.
      • CRZ-IV B: Includes water area and bed area between LTL and bank of the tidal influenced water body to the LTL on the opposite side of the bank, extending from the mouth of the waterbody at the sea up to the influence of tide. 
    • Coastal area accorded special consideration for protecting critical coastal environment:
      • Critically Vulnerable Coastal Area (CVCA): Following areas will be treated as CVCA and managed with involvement of coastal communities:
        • Sundarban region in West Bengal, 
        • Gulf of Khambat and Gulf of Kutchh in Gujarat, 
        • Malvan and Achra-Ratnagiri in Maharashtra, 
        • Karwar and Coondapur in Karnataka, Vembanad in Kerala, 
        • Gulf of Mannar in Tamil Nadu, 
        • Bhitarkanika in Odisha, 
        • Coringa, East Godavari and Krishna in Andhra Pradesh
        • Inland Backwater islands and islands along mainland coast
        • Municipal limits of Greater Mumbai.

Activities prohibited with CRZ:

  • Setting up of new industries and expansion of existing industries, operations or processes.
  • Manufacture or handling of oil, storage or disposal of hazardous substances.
  • Land reclamation, bunding or disturbing the natural course of seawater except for activities permitted.
  • Discharge of untreated waste and effluents from industries, cities or towns and other human settlements.
  • Dumping of city or town wastes 
  • Port and harbour projects in high eroding stretches of coast.
  • Mining of sand, rocks and other sub-strata materials.
  • Dressing or altering of active sand dunes.
  • Disposal of plastic into the coastal waters is prohibited
  • Drawal of ground water. 
  1. Coastal Vulnerability Index (Index)
  2. Blue Flag Certification of Beaches: Blue Flag Certification standards have been established in 1985 by Copenhagen-based Foundation for Environmental Education (FEE), a not-for-profit, non-governmental organisation. Ten Indian beaches have Blue Flag Certification:
    1. Shivrajpur in Gujarat 
    2. Kovalam in Tamil Nadu 
    3. Ghoghla in Diu 
    4. Eden in Puducherry 
    5. Kasarkod, in Karnataka 
    6. Padubidri in Karnataka 
    7. Kappad in Kerala 
    8. Rushikonda in Andhra Pradesh 
    9. Golden in Odisha 
    10. Radhanagar in Andaman and Nicobar Islands
  3. Regeneration of Mangroves in the coastal areas. Central Government has notified MISHTI scheme for regeneration of Mangroves in Coastal areas.
  4. Integrated Coastal Zone Management Plan: Focuses on prevention of soil erosion, shelterbelt plantation, mangrove plantation, strengthening requirements for ecosystem monitoring, biodiversity conservation and sustainable livelihood of coastal communities.

Way forward/Suggestions

  1. Conducting a nationwide island and coastal areas vulnerability assessment for understanding vulnerability of coastal areas.
  2. Installation of GPS/GNSS based station with respect to each tide gauge across islands to estimate vertical land motion which can accurately quantify the future sea-level rise over India’s coasts and islands.
  3. Conducting field based topographic surveys to map the accurate inundation of islands and coasts under different climate change scenarios.
  4. Nature-based growth and development of blue economy based on marine and coastal fronts.
  5. Nature-based restoration of environment and ecology on India’s coasts and islands.
  6. Mainstreaming Climate-resilient activities for livelihood.
  7. Protection of coral reefs and mangroves and monitoring of coral bleaching and mangrove regeneration.
  8. Monitoring shoreline change rate to identify hotspot zones.
  9. Construction of coastal structures for protection of highly eroded shoreline zones.

Factory fishing in Antarctica for krill targets the cornerstone of a fragile ecosystem

Context: Antarctic krill (Euphausia suberba) fishing is banned in U.S. waters due to concerns that exploitation of Antarctic Krill could impact whales, seals and other animals that feed on the shrimp-like creatures. Krill fishing has been taking place for decades in Antarctica, where krill are most abundant. 

About Antarctic Krill

image 15
  • Antarctic Krill are shrimp like crustaceans living the Southern Ocean.
  • It’s estimated that there are over 700 trillion adult individuals of Antarctic Krill.
  • Adult krill can live anywhere in the Southern Ocean – from the very surface layer to the seafloor, and from inshore areas to the deep open ocean.
  • Antarctic krill grow up to 6cm in length and can weigh 1 gram.
  • Antarctic krill (and other krill species) are bioluminescent, meaning they produce light. They are frequently found in such abundance that they colour the sea a reddish-brown. They may be small individually, but there is an estimated 400 million tonnes of Antarctic krill in the Southern Ocean.
  • Antarctic krill aggregate in schools or swarms, where the density of the animal can be as high as 30,000 individuals per cubic metre.
  • Antarctic krill are a key species, supporting populations of penguins, seals, whales and other marine life.
  • Antarctic krill feed on phytoplankton (single celled marine plants), which absorb carbon dioxide. Krill then egests this carbon through their faecal pellets and by shedding their exoskeletons, which then both sink to the sea floor where some of the carbon gets stored away.
  • It is one of the most common species in its range and it is not at risk of endangerment or extinction.
  • IUCN Status: Least Concern

UN agreement to protect marine life

Context: Members of United Nations adopted the first ever treaty to protect marine life in the high seas.

UN High Seas Treaty:

image 118
  • The United Nations adopted the Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction Treaty (BBNJ), also known as the High Seas Treaty, marking the first-ever legally binding international treaty governing the high seas.
  • The High Seas Treaty was approved by all 193 U.N. member states and aims to establish regulations to protect the environment, prevent conflicts related to natural resources and shipping, and address various issues in waters beyond any country's national jurisdiction.
  • The treaty introduces a framework for the creation of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) in the high seas, which will complement existing MPAs within national territorial waters. 
  • This initiative is intended to address biodiversity loss and ecosystem degradation caused by climate change impacts such as ocean warming and acidification, as well as challenges posed by plastics, pollutants, and overfishing.

Focus areas under High Seas Treaty: 

  • Marine genetic resources (MGRs), including the fair and equitable sharing of benefits.
  • Area-based management tools (ABMTs), including marine protected areas (MPAs).
  • Environmental impact assessments (EIAs). 
  • Capacity building and transfer of marine technology (CB&TMT).

Protection of the ecology of western ghats

The Supreme Court on Friday directed the Environment Ministry to file its counter-affidavit to a petition filed by a minor, M. Kaviya, a resident of Nilgiris, seeking judicial intervention to protect the Western Ghats from destruction.

Several environmental activists and NGOs such as the Goa Foundation and Peaceful Society, Bandora, from across six Western Ghats States have joined hands with Ms Kaviya to seek judicial intervention to reinstate the recommendations of the Dr Madhav Gadgil led Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel’s report.

Intergenerational Inequality

Ms Kaviya and seven other children have sought “justice in terms of intergenerational equity”, saying that unbridled “development” in the ancient mountain system would leave their generation without a future or a livelihood.

They have sought an “effective, sustainable and credible conservation regime for the Western Ghats, its diverse ecosystems and ecologically sensitive zones”.

Importance of western ghat

Goa Foundation said the petition concerned a total land area of 1,29,037 sq. km. While 50 million people were directly dependent on the Western Ghats and its ecology, another 200 million were indirectly dependent. The future of the entire southern India was intimately linked with the healthy survival of the Western Ghats.

Gadgil committee recommendations: It recommended variable protection to 100% area of western ghats i.e., Protected areas, ESZ1, ESZ2, ESZ3.

ESZ1 almost all developmental activities to be restricted in it.

It asked for a bottom-up approach rather than a top-down approach to planning.

It also asked for decentralisation and more powers to local authorities.

It recommended constituting a statutory body Western Ghat Ecology Authority under EPA 1986 at central and state levels.

 Problems with the Gadgil report:

Its recommendations were not realistic in nature as it limits the developmental need of the country

Hence government constituted a new committee under Kasturi Rangan and it recommended (2013):

Only 37% area of the western ghats is under ESA.

Highly polluting industries should be banned by ESA.

No thermal power is allowed and hydropower projects are allowed only after a detailed study.

Mining in ESA areas should be phased out within the next five years or at the time of the expiry of the mining lease, whichever is earlier.

But this report has many lacunas;

It gave more power to bureaucrats as compared to local bodies.

Many fear that farmers would get evicted if the Kasturi Rangan Committee report is implemented. Under this report, the mining and quarry lobbies are expected to flourish. When these lobbies and tourism flourish, it will be disastrous to the environment.

The panel used remote sensing and aerial survey methods for zonal demarcation of land in the western ghats it led to the inclusion of ecologically non-sensitive areas under ESA and left out many ecologically sensitive areas.

Due to erroneous recommendations of the Kasturi Rangan report, people turned violent due to fear of their eviction if their village fall under the purview of ESA (123 villages were under ESA as per Kasturi Rangan report), hence Kerala’s CM (Oommen Chandy) appointed another committee to study the Kasturi Rangan Report.

Recommendations of Oommen Chandy report:

It recommended stopping land acquisition proceedings according to the Kasturi Rangan committee report.

Exclusion of inhabited regions and plantations from the purview of ecologically sensitive areas while the Kasturi Rangan report had said 123 villages fall under ESA purview.

MoEF recently came out with the order barring mining in ecologically fragile areas (EFA not to be confused with ESA), setting up of thermal power plants and restricting buildings to less than 20,000 sq. ft in 123 villages mentioned in the Kasturi Rangan report.